2: England, the Peak District and into the West Riding.
Derwent Dam, Ladybower reservoir. Peak District.
The Story So Far…. In Part One A nineteen year oldLe Patron has walked from the Forest of Dean in Gloucestershire in the south west of England, through the rolling hills of mid Wales and then on to the jaggy mountains of north Wales. He started his journey on March 22, 1965. On his seventeenth day he has hitched-hiked from the Idwell Cottage youth hostel in north Wales to Chester in England. With the schools breaking up for Easter he is getting concerned that many of the youth hostels will be fully booked. His destination is the English Peak District, but on April 8, 1965, his overnight night stop will be in the Chester youth hostel. He’s had a sit-in fish and chips in a Chester fish and chip shop where three lads were reading Merseybeat. Heearlier noted that the moat by the Chester Old Wall was full of filth and oil. He’s now sitting in the main Public Library, waiting for the youth hostel to open at 5 p.m.
_____________________________
April 8. Thursday. Chester Public Library. 2.10 p.m.
It’s raining, so into the Public Library.
4 pm. Still here. There’s a lot of down and outs sitting or sleeping in here.
Chester YH Common Room. 8 pm. Chester YH Common Room is a CRAPHOLE, one big craphole, as is the whole hostel. So left the library and walked to the hostel in Hough Green road. Not quite open, another five minutes. There’s about 10 people, mostly girls, sitting, waiting, on the steps outside, a transistor (radio) going. Get in. It’s an old hotel, I think. It’s crappy, messy, big and cold. Down in the self cookers – God – everyone nervously glancing at everyone else, strained/restrained. I felt like saying FOR FUCK’S SAKE LET’S BREAK THIS UP, but we all went on being careful, apologetic smiles, and people trying to eat making as least noise as possible. So now this Common Room – there’s two girls playing table tennis and two old people, and an impossible young American who’s capable of unspeakably boring conversation talking to a cyclist bloke who looks half dead.
________________________________
April 9. Friday. Around 1 pm near Holmes Chapel.
Chester to Holmes Chapel. Acknkowledgement to Esso Road Map No 5 Wales and Midlands, published 1965.
Left Chester YH and the talkative American behind at 10 am, heading for Holmes Chapel. Walk to the outskirts of Chester and start to hitch. It’s beginning to rain heavily. Quite a lot of traffic, but with the rain nothing stops until a shagged out Mini van and bloke going to Winsford takes me part of the way, dropping me off at the road for Nantwich.
Austin Mini Van
But consulting my map I realise I should also make for Winsford. Never mind. Into Winsford in a Cortina driven by a Dick Emery type pansy – packet of Benson and Hedges Silk Cut cigs in the front – everything very smooth – watch – ring, etc.
Dick Emery in ‘character’.
Winsford, small town, loads of school kids. The rain’s going off. The accent around here is getting stronger – sort of Coronation Street accent. Cheshire Plain’s crappy. Winsford to Middlewich lift from a woman – yes, a woman. First woman driver who has picked me up in this country. Son’s a hosteller. She’s driving a NSU Prinz. Nippy cars.
NSU Prinz 4
I get dropped off the other side of Middlewich on a main road with no traffic by a field where two blokes are banging poles in for some horse show on Saturday. Still no traffic so walk along the road, cross the M6, look down on it – cars, trucks belting along. (The M6 in Cheshire had opened to traffic 17 months before Le Patron was looking down on it, in November 1963.)
M6 in Cheshire. Source The Motorway Archive.
I walk into Holmes Chapel. Buy two Knorr sauce mixes and go into a fish and chip shop and after a wait in the queue along with building site workers get a fish cake and chips for 1/2. (approx. 5½ p.)
Holmes Chapel, 1950s.
3.15 pm and I’m about half a mile from Windgather YH. I’m sitting protected by a limestone wall on a country road, bit of drizzle and I’m wondering what my chances are of getting into Windgather YH tonight.
Anyway, to recap: Holmes Chapel – Sit on a bench in the centre, near the bogs, and eat – and have a smoke. Ask two postman which way for the Macclesfield Road. Buy some rum and raison toffees and get on it. Half heartedly hitch, chewing away on my toffees – they were good – and a big Austin stops. The driver – looks like a headmaster – tells me about his son who goes hostelling, and spent a year working before going to University. Drops me at Chelford for the road to Macclesfield and it’s starting to rain again. Dormobile stops – two youngish blokes going to Buxton.
Sit in the back of the Dormobile, on the floor. Bumpy fast ride into the Peaks through Macclesfield and the rain’s really heavy now. The Peaks, not too impressed. Admittedly this isn’t a good part of them – low moorland. Dropped off in Buxton. A pretty rich looking place – Victorian?
Buxton
Meet a few other hostellers who tell me Buxton and Castleton are booked up. Buy some bread and milk and sit on a wall, rain’s gone off, looking at the shop front of W.H.Smith’s across the road. Then get on the Stockport road, steep road out of Buxton and an artic with trailer stops and takes me to Whaley Bridge. Start walking to Kettleshume and bloke coming out of a drive delivering swiss rolls to Kettleshume P.O. takes me there. The P.O. is a small tidy cosy well equipped little shop and bought a bar of chocolate. Walk out of Kettleshume to where I’m sitting now, sheltering by this limestone wall, about half a mile from the YH.
Kettleshulme and Windgather youth hostel. Acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey One Inch Tourist Map The Peak District, 1960 revision date. Windgather youth hostel is the red triangle south of Kettleshulme, near Fivelane-ends.
7.30 pm. Windgather YH To my surprise the hostel is almost empty. Just me and 4 girls here tonight.
Windgather youth hostel.
It’s a small friendly place, women warden. The self cookers are outside the main building, where I cooked a meal of spaghetti bolognese. Nice common room/dining room – dark warm panelled wood – looks like the interior of a log cabin.
_____________________________
April 10. Saturday. Around 11 am. On the road from Kettleshulme to Oldgate Nick
Last night the rain and wind beat against the hostel but in the morning it looked promising and the sun came out, and stayed out. After a breakfast of cornflakes, grapefruit, bread and marmalade (bought last night from the YH stores) and coffee I went down to Kettleshulme P.O. and cashed some money and bought some provisions. One thing I must try while I’m in the Peaks is the pancakes – big ones, like you get on Pancake Day- that I’ve seen in some of the shops. But, I’ve been thinking about hitching up to Scotland for the rest of April/May, as I’ll be able to get in easy at the hostels up there, and stay a week at a lot hostels. I’ll ring up Ewden and see how he’s booked. It depends. Buxton, Castleton, Edale are booked solid. So, on this pleasant road making for Oldgate Nick.
Windgather youth hostel – Oldgate Nick – Shining Tor. Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist map.
Neat limestone walls and a view of desiccated plateau – mild, nothing outstanding, but pleasant – and the wind’s blowing and the sun’s shining and I feel good and I’m whistling. Yes, for the moment, this is the life.
Dinner time, on Shining Tor 1864′. Eating a packet of Royal Scot biscuits, sitting on Shining Tor. Yes, moorland, dissected by valleys – nothing staggering or outstanding, pleasant but not a region to stay in for too long. Can’t really understand why hostels in the region should be booked up, unless it’s all SJP’s (School Journey Parties). I passed a massive army of them – about 40, scrambling along the ridge, laughing, giggling, with their masters. Or maybe because there’s Manchester on one side and Sheffield on the other there’s not enough countryside to go round for folk. A bit of peat up here.
Area of Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist MapFernilee Reservoir 1960. Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist Map, 1960 revision.
Afternoon near Fernilee Reservoir. Shortly after lunch it started to rain and for an hour I took shelter behind a wall and kept dry as it threw it down. There was a sheep about 10 yards further along the wall also taking shelter. So I sat there singing, whistling, eating chocolate, smoking a cig and watching the low cloud belt along in the wind. Occasionally it cleared and glimpses of the hillside opposite. Then the rain suddenly stopped and I set off again, descending to near this reservoir where it looks as if they’re making an extension, blue huts on the hillside, cranes, diggers, uprooted trees and smashed down walls. A mess. (The “Extension” was to be Errwood Reservoir, opened in 1967. Like Fernilee Reservoir it supplies water to Stockport and its surrounding area.)
At map top: Whalley Bridge and Hawkhurst Head on its left. Acknowledgement: Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist Map.
4.15 Hawkhurst Head near Whaley Bridge. Walked along the reservoir on the left hand side and followed path into Whaley Bridge following two other hikers in front of me. Walk down to the Co-op. It’s closed. Peculiar place. It’s quiet – all the shops seem to be Co-op, and all closed on this Saturday afternoon. Find a small independent shop and buy a Vesta Beef Curry but they had none of those big flat pancakes. Walked out of Whaley Bridge past the station, up the hill and the road looks down over the town and a lot of expensive looking houses, and modern houses down there.
Whaley Bridge, circa 1930s
Continue walking, past a small sand/gravel pit, and now here at Hawkhurst Head. Rolling hills and farms.
Evening. The YH, Windgather Cottage. Bit of thunder and rain outside just now. Tonight, compared with last night, the place is almost full to capacity – party of Girl Guides in civilian clothes. Before the rain started I went down and phoned up Ewden hostel – cost 1/- (5 p) – and I’m in for tomorrow night provided I can get there for 7.30 pm. Difficult to get to from here – it’ll be a mixture of hitching/bus-ing/walking. We’ll see.
To recap on the day. Left Windgather Cottage YH around 9.30 and tried hitch-hiking from Whaley Bridge, but no go – few cars being a Sunday, and those that were passing through full of sightseers. Just when I thought I would have to get a bus to Buxton a Cortina stops, a young couple going to Edale, bloke wearing anorak. And so Edale.
Orange triangle: Edale.Edale village, summer. 1950s.
Edale was like a hikers centre – hundreds of the buggers. Shop open. Buy two packets of dates, and then get on the track to Nether Booth, near, but not quite, Edale YH.
Edale youth hostel.On the way to Ewden: Edale (bottom left) to the Shooting cabin (top right). Ordnance Survey One Inch Tourist Map The Peak District
Follow path down to Woodlands valley and it starts to hail heavily. Cross River Ashop by the ford and I’m getting wet from the hail so shelter in a barn.
Ford over the River Ashop, lower arrow. Ordnance Survey One Inch Tourist Map The Peak District.
The hail goes off so on again – along the A57 and then climbing up and then dropping down to Ladybower Reservoir following a stream through Forestry Commission. Very steep and slippery, me slipping and falling before getting to the road by the reservoir.
Derwent Dam , Ladybower Reservoir. Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist Map.Derwent Dam from Ladybower Reservoir.
There’s a dam across the reservoir with two towers and water spills down it – white. There’s sightseers, an ice cream van. Kid dropped a cone and mother throws it over the wall. Cross the reservoir by the road and on the other side have dates, cig, etc and then follow road on this side of reservoir and then ascend and follow Abbey Brook – very reminiscent of the Yorkshire Dales – very steep sided small valley and at the top come across what’s marked on the map as ‘shooting cabin’.
Shooting Cabin by Abbey Brook. Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist Map.
Dilapidated wooden cabin – hundreds of scrawlings inside – and of all things a YS symbol (Labour Party Young Socialists) besides CND (Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament) symbols, plus naked women.
Continue following a plateau like top, nearly all peat bog and peat erosion.
Shooting Cabin (lower left) to Ewden youth hostel (top upper right). Ordnance Survey One Inch Peak District Tourist Map.
4.10 pm near Ewden. Cold, cold wind blowing. Came off the plateau to fields, and being barked at by a dog and played around with bullocks – like a bull fight. One bullock kept coming at me, I’d shout back, wave my arm, and it would keep coming, ducking its head, and then shear off to the side – I was enjoying myself. Climbing over the fence, turned around and gave the bullock the V sign.
“Bring Slippers”. Apart from “Bring Slippers” the YHA handbook entry was similar (and also apart from ‘Next Hostels’) in 1965. This is the Ewden youth hostel description in the 1945 YHA hostel handbook.
7.30 pm. Ewden Youth Hostel common room. To pick up to where I left off – walked into Ewden, a craphole of wooden houses, all looking the same. Had trouble finding which one was the YH as all the houses look the same.
Ewden Village, before 1929.Ewden Village, before 1929, woman at door
Four art school type girls here tonight, plus three blokes who said they were at Idwell when I was there. (Idwell, Snowdonia, on April 7, four days before.) Strange, didn’t remember them.
_____________
(“Ewden Village… During the early 20th century a timber built village was constructed, to house workers working on the Morehall and Broomhead reservoirs. The village was completed in 1929. By 1969 only 15 of over 70 buildings were occupied, and by the 21st century the village was practically abandoned. By 2008 a single worker’s cottage remained from the original navvy village.” – Wikipedia entry, with grateful acknowledgement.
The Broomhead and Morehill reservoirs were built for water supply to Sheffield and were completed in 1929. Ewden Village in its day (1914 – 1929, and into the 1930s) was far from being a “craphole”. The village houses, church, social club and village store were built by the Sheffield Corporation Waterworks Dept., for the workers and their families employed in building the reservoirs. The photographs displayed here were commissioned by William Terrey, General Manager of the Sheffield Corporation Waterworks Department. This information, and photos above and below are courtesy of the Stocksbridge & District History Society and are found on their website: stocksbridgehs.co.uk)
Ewden Village house interior.The Ewden Village shop, interior.Ewden Village billiards and social roomThe “infreqent” bus service between Sheffield and Ewden village, circa mid to late 1950s – note Milk Marketing Board advertisement on the side of the bus. Note the steps up on the right hand side – leading to one of the village streets?
_____________________
10.15 p.m. About nine-ish the warden showed us some colour slides he’d taken, including Joe Brown climbing the over hang on Kilnsey Crag in Wharfedale.
Joe Brown, believed to be late 1950s.Kilnsey Crag, Wharfedale, Yorkshire Dales.
Not bad. After warden went the four girls, three boys and me chatted, and now to bed.
_____________________________
April 12, Monday. Holmfirth YH. 7.30 pm
OS Sheet 102, “Huddersfield”, One Inch Seventh Series.Ewden youth hostel to Holmfirth youth hostel, Esso Map No 5, Northern England, published 1964.Ewden, bottom right to Upper Midhope, top left. With acknowledgment to Ordnance Survey, Map 102, One Inch Seventh Series, published 1958.
A blustery, wet day of April showers, heavy showers. Left the hostel at 10 o’ clock and it pisses down almost straight away as I climb out of Ewden Valley and along to Bolsterstone where I got into the Coop and buy date bar.
Then along country road and then track and view of Stocksbridge over to my right. Rain turns to driving hail, shelter behind a wall, keeping more or less dry. Drop down into Midhopestones and walk to Upper Midhope and Longsett Reservoir. Upper Midhope is a peculiar collection of farms, and then down to the reservoir. Big notices saying don’t pollute the water, and don’t start a fire.
Upper Midhope, bottom left, to Holmfirth youth hostel, top right. With acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey, Map 102, One Inch Seventh Series.
Continue along track/path until I cross a stone bridge at the end of the reservoir, and ascend, past a farm and boisterous sheep after me. Come onto the main road – A628 and cross it, near Moor Transport and Commercial Cafe – heavy lorries going between Manchester and Sheffield.
(The Moor Transport and Commercial no longer exists. Writing in Truck Net UK, on the ‘Old Cafes’ forum, Fodenway wrote: “…Closed years ago was the Moor Cafe just west of the old Flouch crossroads on the A628 Woodhead road. The derelict building is still there, gradually crumbling into the undergrowth and unseen from the re-aligned main road” – Forum entry of October 15, 2009. With grateful acknowledgement to Truck Net UK and Fodenway.)
Location of Moor Transport and Commercial Cafe, near Flouch Cross Roads. Acknowledgement Ordnance Survey One Inch Seventh Series Map 102.
Follow a path to Carlecotes, then B6106, then turn off and follow more tracks eventually into Holmfirth. Holmfirth built of black grimed sand coloured stone. It’s in a valley, narrow steep streets down into the town. Real old sort of mill town with little shops, Park Drive cigs.
Park Drive cigarettesHolmfirth, 1960s.
Down into the town and do some shopping and start making for the hostel and starts to rain heavily. Shelter in a derelict house for a while. Then continue, it’s a hard slog.
It’s a nice hostel, warm common room, but four 13 year old Nottingham yobs spoiling it, arsing about.
______________________________
April 13, Tuesday. Holmfirth YH 7.15 pm
First of all, cooked myself a bloody awful tea earlier, and ate it. Theoretically hamburger, egg and chips – only it was all fat and no salt and I spilt half the fat over the table in the self cookers – one bloody mess and hell trying to clear it up. And those Nottingham yobs here again, and they were doing chips and made an even worse mess – fat everywhere, blocking the sink up with it and putting dirty dishes and cutlery back, and I felt down. Last time I try frying when hosteling – they just don’t have the right equipment – all their frying pans are too thin, and often buckled. So, it was a bad end to an expensive day – spent 27/-. (£1.35p)
Holmfirth to Bradford by bus, via Huddersfield.
Left hostel nine-ish and walked down to Holmfirth, red double decker Huddersfield bus passes me, run for it, jump on as it waits at the bus stop.
Huddersfield Corporation double decker, 1960s. Photo courtesy of Huddersfield Passenger Transport Group.
Youngish clippie – small black mop of hair – patched up great-coat, old ticket puncher, leather money bag – a little make up and she had a funny sort of face – a sort of Yorkshire Edith Piaf. I liked her. Huddersfield. Get off and walked down to where Bradford buses go. A blue and cream Bradford Corporation double decker comes. West Indian driver, Pakistani conductor. Get in and we’re off to Bradford.
Bradford Corporation double decker, 1960s.
Don’t recognise anything as we get near Bradford until we hit Manchester Road – those old junk shops Pete and I went round. And the garage with the girl in black tights I watched in the pouring rain the first day I was in Bradford (October, 1963.). And the old shops and bomb sites behind where we took the photographs. (Bradford was bombed August 1940 and March 1941, but damage was not that heavy. “Bomb site” was often a term used to describe land where houses had been demolished by the local council, as part of ‘slum clearance’, pending new building.)
House clearance, Bradford. November, 1963. photo Pete GraftonOld and new housing, Bradford, November 1963. photo Pete Grafton
They’ve built a load of five storey deathless flats there now. And so into the centre and Kirkgate and hop off the bus. More new buildings. Into the bogs on the island – surrounded by road. And then to Smith’s to get OS 95 (Blackburn & Burnley), and have a general look round. Over to Kirkgate Market, through it and into that bakery as you come out and two long buns – now 4d. instead of the 3d in 1963.
Kirkgate Market, Bradford. Demolition 1973.
Then up Manningham Lane, making for Norm’s cafe. On the way go up Eldon Place to see No.8 (Le Patron rented a room there, as did a lot of Irish labourers). Still the same, even the same curtains up there in the room, red patterned things, and so along to Norm’s – BUT – big disappointment. No Norm’s, instead an Italian coffee bar. Yes, BIG DISAPPOINTMENT. Go in and no proper cooked meals like two veg, or steamed pudding and custard. Go in and have a coffee. No one else in the cafe – I should think he’ll be going bankrupt at this rate. (Norm’s Cafe, Manningham Lane was a busy little cafe that did a lunch-time “Mains” and “Afters” for 2/6d (12½p). In the autumn of 1963 Freddy & The Dreamers You Were Made For Meseemed to be the most popular tune on the juke box.)
Come out and across the road I see that bloke who put me up for 12/6d in that workers lodging house first night I was in Bradford – still wearing the same beret. Then back down Manningham Lane, went into Forster Square station – exactly the same – dense smell of train smoke – choking.
Pigeon’s eye view of Forster Square station, Bradford. Early 1960s.
Then into Fine Fare via the subway which they were building when I was here. Buy sugar and Kellogs. More walking around and then back to bus stop.
On Huddersfield bus back to Holmfirth thinking about cycling to Israel. Thinking about it so much that I nearly went past the stop. Holmfirth 3 o’ clock, writing postcards I’d bought in Bradford for six people, post them and then walking back to hostel.
________________________
April 14, Wednesday. 10.25. Hey Clough.
Sitting behind a stone wall, beck descending in front of me, reminiscent of Dales – well, it is the West Riding. Overcast day, slight rain now and then. Followed a track past several deserted farms, one with a stone front door lintel engraved ‘1782’ on it. Sheep baa-ing – they seem bigger and dirtier coloured sheep than the ones I saw in Wales. I’m walking along thinking of spending Christmas in a tent in the hills somewhere.
8 pm, Holmfirth YH. After I wrote the above it really started to rain and it didn’t stop for the rest of the day. I followed Hey Clough part of the way and then climbed the steep valley slope and up on to the top – a lot of peat bog, peat erosion – peat rivers, peat beds, great banks of them – like a mammoth river bed during the dry season. Rain getting heavier and trying to find Black Hill.
Peat erosion, Peak District.
Found it but didn’t stay long and start descent following the cairns – low cloud. After a while I lose the path, but keep going down to Heyden Brook and coming out near Woodlhead Reservoir. Follow path to Greenfield, past Highstone Rocks, valley below me. Start descending but realise something is wrong. Instead of Chew Reservoir there’s a broad stream flowing towards me. I’ve taken a wrong footpath in the low cloud.
Holme Clough and Saddleworth Moor. Acknowledgement Ordanance Survey One Inch Seventh Series Map 102.
I’m following this stream and getting worried. Use compass, keep heading north then come on (as I guessed) Holme Clough. To be on the safe side – cloud is very, very low, I follow it down and a steep dodgy descent to the reservoir, along it, up the hillside past the trees, and man, was I glad to hit the main road. First car I hitch stops and we drive through mist, his wipers going, and he drops me off at the youth hostel. It’s 6 pm and I’m soaked and my jeans and anorak are covered in mud/peat after slipping down a bank coming down Holme Clough. Change into my shorts and hang my stuff into the not very warm drying room.
I’m the only one here tonight, and make myself a reasonable, yes reasonable meal. Incidentally, the warden is a screwy, zany woman, with an ex-boxing manager looking husband and secretarial looking daughter called Christine, who was about to go off to Switzerland and warden was excited about it.
________________________
April 15, Mankinholes YH. Evening
Mankinholes youth hostel. Photo courtesy YHA.
Mankinholes is a bloody great hostel – one of the best I’ve been in for a long time: warm, friendly, cosy common room, decent kitchen, really hot water and a tinder dry drying room. After a meal of spaghetti – Knorr Tomato sauce mix and English Cheddar cheese, which was good and tasty, I washed a load of my clothes and stuck them in the drying room.
Ewden youth hostel to Elland. Acknowledgement Esso Map No 5 ‘Northern England’, published 1964.
But the rest of the day: left Holmfirth hostel with mixed feelings about this Walk – damp, dirty and smelly, me smelly, anorak falling to pieces and jeans dirty from yesterday’s slide in the mud and rucksack filthy from the mud and clothes still damp. Walk down into Holmfirth. It’s grey and drizzling and smell of coal smoke. Useless hitching so got bus to Huddersfield. Try and buy OS 77 (Northumberland) but no go. Start along Halifax road. See a shop and nip in and buy spaghetti, sauce mix, Vesta Veg curry. Started hitching and get a lift to Elland from bloke wearing hat – tubby bloke in a Mini.
Elland – Greetland – Sowerby Bridge. Acknowledgement Ordnance Survey One Inch Seventh Series Map 102.
Elland – walk to Greetland. Towns huddled in the valleys. Smokey, black grimed mill towns with the moors up above. Walk to Greetland past a dead looking mill, but hear them inside the canteen. It’s 12.30. A few young mill girls pass me eating fish and chips and a Pakistani stands near the mill rolling a cig.
A steep walk out of Greetland. Over on the other side, a factory. Three white coated apprentices chasing each other – one falls, gets up slowly. The game’s over. I continue walking along the road. Halifax Corporation buses pass me – great vulgar colour combination – cream, orange and lime green. (Glasgow buses had a similar livery.)
Halifax Corporation double decker, 1960s. Note destination: Steep Lane. (See below, after Sowerby)
I’m now on the B road going to Ripponden, climbing, turn off to the right onto a moor road. A view of Halifax in the valley. Big dark chimneys. Walk through a group of cottages. Everywhere the stone is grimy black and the white cement pointing contrasts unpleasantly. Onwards and a steep descent down into Sowerby Bridge. Kids playing in one of the streets, kicking the ball against a wall, bounce off, kick it back. Sowerby Bridge another mill town. Stop on a bridge and look down at the stream. Filthy. From outlets a blue detergent comes, and from others, steam. From another a milky coloured liquid is dribbling into it. Absolutely filthy.
A steep walk out of Sowerby Bridge up to Sowerby, now looking down on the valley and even though it’s overcast I’m beginning to feel good. Despite the gradient I’m belting up it, almost as if I’m going to take off. Feeling really good. Sowerby is crumbled down black grimed houses and two Victorian churches.
Sowerby – Steep Lane – Cragg. Acknowledgement Ordnance Survey One Inch Seventh Series Map 102.
Through Sowerby up to Steep Lane, still striding along, thinking of a maroon 2CV Citreon and a cottage somewhere in Steep Lane, over-looking the industrialised valleys. Stop to have a cig and a girl turns up, with young brother who looks at me, and then hides behind his sister’s coat. The sister asks me if there’s a bus due – don’t know – and by now I feel great. Fuck the smell, the dampness, the filth, I feel overwhelmingly good and satisfied.
Steep Lane down into Cragg, pass a farm, there’s a dead pig, small one, in the silage. Cragg could be a beautiful place with a clean up but spoiled by made up roads of ash and jerry built huts, in a valley with a second valley coming into it.
Withens Clough reservoir – Mankinholes – Todmorden. Acknowledgement Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch Map 95.Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch Map 95 ‘Blackburn & Burnley’. Revision date 1961.
Walk up the short valley to Withens Clough reservoir. Two workers pass me, presume Water Board, going down to Cragg. One old, one young, the young one’s got a transistor (radio) going. Donkey jackets and ex-WD gas mask bags for their sandwiches, etc.
Slight drizzle as I drop down to Mankinholes and the hostel. Two young girls there and later a Scottish couple – bloke got an unpleasant sour face – and a bloke from Manchester. Me and the bloke from Manchester went to the pub – chic expensive type place. In one room a fire, and a tubby wearing glasses bloke and his mate are playing a banjo and sax. Back to the hostel, write this as the two girls play chess and soon to bed. Staying here tomorrow as Slaidburn booked up.
_________________________
April 16, Good Friday. Todmorden.
Todmorden
Went down into Todmorden earlier, when I left the youth hostel. Another grimy town in a valley, people in their best clothes – Good Friday. Nip into a bakers and bought two Hot Cross Buns – only they were cold and tasted if they were baked a week ago. Out of Todmorden past the railway station and into Centre Vale Park where I ate the hot cross buns.
Centre Vale Park to Mine at Carr & Craggs and Heald Moor. Acknowledgment Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch Map 95.
11.45 am on Heald Moor Smoking a cig. Been walking along to here singing loud. Rolling green moorland and hills and so far it’s keeping dry. Passed a small party of Scouts by a derelict small coal quarry way back. There’s a bird singing somewhere.
Cant Clough reservoir, 1.35 pm. So from a bird singing somewhere up to Thievely Pike 1474′ and then down into Holme Chapel, underneath railway bridge and onto the main road.
Thievely Pile to Holme Chapel and on to Cant Clough reservoir. Acknoweledgement Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch Map 95.
Stop to consult map, cross the main road and follow track to reservoir, passing a hill billy scrap farm on the way. Now for a cig.
Mankinholes YH 10 past 8 pm. From Cant Clough reservoir up, following the stream to the track and along. Quite a few others walking around and on the track – I guess because it’s the Easter weekend.
Cant Clough reservoir – Gorple reservoirs – Colden. Acknowledgement Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch Map 95.
From the track down to Gorple reservoirs and from there down to Colden – a peculiar collection of farms, cottages and unmade roads. And eventually back to the hostel for 5.10 pm. After a meal I walk down to Todmorden – it’s starting to drizzle – over the canal and getting some change from a woman at a bus stop into a phone box, to ring Slaidburn and confirm that I am definitely in for tomorrow night. Yippee. I am. Walk back to a by now very crowded hostel.
Mankinholes youth hostel to Todmorden and the Rochford canal.
_____________________________
Next
Part Three: The Forest of Bowland, The Yorkshire Dales & Westmoreland
“There’s a cottage down there, tin out-buildings, an old car on its side, a stream and some chickens. Go down to the cottage and a women wearing a beret and her old man’s old jacket – stained on the lapel – tells me I’m on the wrong track. ” – Forest of Dean, March 23, 1965.
Introduction Between March and June, 1965, Le Patron walked over the hills and through the dales from Wales to England and then on to Scotland eventually to Kishorn in Ross and Cromarty, staying in youth hostels along the way. He was nineteen. He funded the walk by saving hard whilst working the winter of 1964/1965 on a building site near Bristol.
Kishorn, Ross and Cromarty, 1965.
On some sections of the walk, where there were gaps of more than 25 miles between a hostel and the next hostel he hitch-hiked. In the 1960s drivers were usually ready to stop and give a lift. This was partly a left-over from the Second World War and from National Conscription, when servicemen and women and civilians regularly hitched. Many of these in turn, back in civvy street, would often give hitchers a lift.
Le Patron kept the weight of his Karrimor rucksack to a minimum by, for instance, sending Ordnance Survey maps he no longer need back to his parents’ address. Basic equipment included a cheap compass, a small torch and, for emergencies, a whistle. He had read that to gain attention if he had fallen or was in other serious difficulty, steady blasts on the whistle was the recognised help signal. He’d also read that date block was high in energy, along with other sugary things like biscuits. In the 1960s date blocks were readily available from village and town shops. A date block was a rectangular block of compressed dates (the stones removed) in cellophane, about 4½inches long by 1¼inches deep (11.5cm x 3.2cm). There were several brands. They are now a rarity in shops and supermarkets. In the daily notes that Le Patron wrote in cheap exercise books as he went from hostel to hostel he refers to them as “date bars” – but they were the date blocks as outlined above. Date bars as understood and marketed in 2017 did not exist in 1965.
The other essential item he carried in his rucksack was the England and Wales Youth Hostel Handbook for 1965, and the SYHA (Scottish) Handbook. The England and Wales handbook listed all the YHA hostels, giving details of the individual hostels, where the nearest railway station or bus stop was, along with the local shop half closing day, that in in 1965 was still part of village and small town life. It also noted whether the hostel took SJPs: School Journey Parties. SJPs were a curse for the lone walker as some small hostels accepted them, and these hostels could be unexpectedly full when arriving at them having done a twenty mile hike across the hills. Unless you were part of a largish organised group, the handbook stated that hostellers were not allowed to use a car to arrive at or travel between hostels. On the whole this wasn’t abused too much, although it happened, with cars discretely parked out of sight of the hostel and the warden. In Scotland, because of greater mileage between some hostels, there was a tolerance from the Scottish Youth Hostel Association (SYHA) about the use of cars by hostellers.
The Youth Hostel symbol on an Ordnance Survey was, and continues to be, a red triangle, as above. Contour lines and hill and mountain heights on the Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch maps were in feet.
_________________________
TOWN….
March 22, 1965. Northolt tube station, north west London, and the A40. Monday morning.
…..and COUNTRY
March 22nd, 1965. Mitcheldean Youth Hostel, Gloucestor. Monday night.
Mitcheldean. Acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey. Sheet 142, Seventh Series 1″ Map, published 1952.
Mitcheldean Youth Hostel
Just made a meal and am now sitting in an empty Common Room. Raining outside, but it’s warm in here: there’s 6 cane chairs with cushions arranged around one of those big old range fires. The place looks like old stables, cream painted stonework with crimson paint and an archway leading into a yard.
This morning I was at my parents home in Essex. Left home at quarter past eight and it took me 1½ hours to get to Stratford (East London) station. Stop start, stop start. Drivers all mad, one long queue. It’s stupidity – you do an 8 hour day and it takes you 30% of that time, if not more, getting to work, and getting back. From Stratford the Underground to Northolt and A40. Start hitching. Don’t wait long. Bloke in Bedford delivering meat pies gives me a lift to 10 miles from High Wycombe, stopping on the way to deliver his pies, whilst “Music While you Work” (Music on BBC Light programme) blares out the radio he’s got in the van. Don’t have to wait long after he drops me off. I get a lift in a Cortina from a youngish late 20s, early 30s good looking bloke, and doesn’t that Cortina go – feel it pulling away from under you.
Automatic transmission. Don’t talk much at first. Notice a box of Kleenex tissues, a Daily Sketch and a pair of hi-heels in the front.
Daily Sketch front page from the previous year, Mods and Rockers. May 19, 1964.
Get talking and it turns out he’s a theatre director, just come back from Canada and returning to the Oxford Playhouse. Tells me about something he heard when he was in Canada – some students in the U.S. went round with a petition in a town and 84% refused to sign it – and it turned out it was the First Amendment of the American Constitution.
“The First Amendment (Amendment I) to the United States Constitution prohibits the making of any law respecting an establishment of religion, ensuring that there is no prohibition on the free exercise of religion, abridging the freedom of speech, infringing on the freedom of the press, interfering with the right to peaceably assemble, or prohibiting the petitioning for a governmental redress of grievances.” (Summary by Wikipedia).
He drops me off on the Oxford ring road. A bit of a wait and then a lift from a young mechanic driving a 15 cwt van going, returning to Gloucester. I’m knackered and almost fall asleep, and the continual noise of the engine gives me a headache. We don’t talk much. He drops me off on the Gloucester ring road. Standing outside some industrial site – Brackley Builders, Instant Car Wash, caravans, flags flying…Behind me post war, just post war, council houses, a patch of green and a glimpse of Gloucester Cathedral.
Gloucester, Cinderford and the Forest of Dean. Acknowledgement to Esso, Map No. 3 “South and West England”, published 1963.
Lift at last to near Cinderford, bloke driving a Fiat 600 on his way to Newport. It starts to rain.
The driver drops me off where the road goes to Cinderford. It’s still quite a way and a small country road so wait for a bus as hardly any traffic. Wait and wait, I’m getting wet, my rucksack seems to weigh a ton and I’ve still got the headache, and the scenery’s dull. At last an old 1952 type double decker comes, a firm called Red and White.
The scenery starts to get more interesting, more valley like. The bus goes to Cinderford. Cinderford’s one of those big/small places – coal mines, heath, forest, hillocks and vales
Cinderford coal mine, early 1960s.
I have to get off the bus at Cinderford and get into a stationary bus waiting for Mitcheldean. It’s just gone 5. It starts to fill up with workers who all seem to know each other, and the bus conductor. Some talk with a Gloucester accent and some with a Welsh accent. Curious. As the bus fills up they chat to each other. “Did you see that try on the TV, Dai?” – and with a ding ding of the bell we’re off and get into Mitcheldean quarter of an hour later. It’s a bit like Cinderford, less industry, just as old and narrow streets and small grubby shops. Go in one and buy a loaf, and sugar. Find the youth hostel and enter. First thing that happens is a youngish plump woman crosses the archway – there’s a door on it – it leads straight onto the street in the village. She’s carrying a pile of blankets. She tells me I’ll have to hang on as she’s got to move them, then asks for help. I drop my rucksack and help her carry them into the Drying Room. She’s trying to stack them properly and swearing “Bloody things… Bugger this”. Two kids looking in annoy her, she shouts at them, and at an old man who is also looking in. He’s got a displaced jaw that makes him look mental, and deep set eyes and prominent cheek bones.
Make a meal. Still got the headache.
__________________________
March 23, St Briavels Youth Hostel, Tuesday evening.
“There’s a cottage down there, tin out-buildings, an old car on its side, a stream and some chickens. Go down to the cottage and a women wearing a beret and her old man’s old jacket – stained on the lapel – tells me I’m on the wrong track. “
A test of character today as it rained all the time. Slightly aching as I write this in the Common Room and a damp body, but otherwise OK.
Left Mitcheldean about nine in drizzling rain.
Mitcheldean, Speech House and Cannop Ponds
I’m wearing my ex-WD (War Department) cape, over-trousers and sou wester. Climb up a hill that overlooks Mitcheldean, but there is a misty cloud hanging over the village. The village nestles in a valley surrounded by low hills. Then walk through Forestry Commission land and come onto cross roads and then realise I am lost. Start on a track that goes past a small quarry and curves round to a cottage – green hillside, wood on one side and looking down on steep little valley. There’s a cottage down there, tin out buildings, an old car on its side, a stream and some chickens. Go down to the cottage and a women wearing a beret and her old man’s old jacket – stained on the lapel – tells me I’m on the wrong track. So climb back up and retrace my steps to the cross roads. Bit of a bleak view but not too dismal. A woman waiting at a bus stop with a young girl points me in the right road to Speech House.
Mitcheldean and Drybrook and Birch Wood
The track goes across bog, waste ground and small coal slag heaps with grass growing on them. The track winds around to a small brickworks, and crosses a railway line. The brickworks is old and small; long low sheds and four square shaped chimneys. Inside you can see a furnace glowing red. The track then goes steeply up, through woods, and I come to an old railway track – the rails removed and the track now a flat green elevated path through the forest. Come to an old railway station. (Drybook Road station, closed 1929, in Birch Wood.) There’s a platform and a cottage, right here in the middle of the forest. Someone is still living in the cottage but the platform is crumbled and overgrown with grass and here I must turn left and follow another a forest track. It’s conifers on each side.
It’s still raining when I come out at the Speech House, an expensive looking inn with an expensive looking car parked outside.
Speech House and Cannop Ponds
I walk along a road that goes past a school, it looks like a Special School, it’s by the road but surrounded by trees, a Victorian building with a modern well designed extension, Off the road and on to the track again through more forest. As it gets wetter I realise my 9/6d plastic leggings are useless – great gashes/splits in them, so that’s that on Day Two. There’s a couple kissing in a car, and I wonder what they’re doing out here, right out here in the forest, more than just kissing I reckon. I descend to the same railway track of earlier and another platform but no station. There’s a large swing crane, perhaps used for swinging large stone slabs onto the platform from trucks when there was a railway once here – for past a lake and a long artificial water chute/waterfall there’s a stone works. It’s a long shed with open sides and there are about six cutting machines and some blokes are working there, half in the dry, half in the rain. One machine is cutting stone into five thin slabs, like so:
Pennant Sandstone online site, 2016:
“Barnill Quarry sits at the head of Bixslade, close to Broadwell village. Our office and production plant, Bixslade Stoneworks is around a mile away, next to Cannop Ponds. The man-made ponds were built in 1825 and 1829 to create a head of water to drive a wheel at the ironworks at Parkend. Today we use the Ponds to power our micro hydro turbine generating electricity for our works.” – Forest of Dean Stone Firms Ltd
Bixslade stone works, 1903. Photo source Forest of Dean Stone Firms Ltd
A bit further on I come to and cross a road and follow a very muddy track up a slight valley. There’s a lorry with fresh cut tree trunks, stuck in the mud. The driver in the cab shrugs at me, not sure what he can do. My boots are sticky with clay/mud and I realise I’m lost. End up in a hill billy looking place – hummocks, streams, some houses. Ask a bloke the right way. He directs me back in the way I came, only following a stream lower down. Eventually ascend and descend to Oakwood Inn, ascend again, accompanied by wolf whistles from two yobs on the road below.
And at last get onto the road that leads into St Briavels.
St. Briavels. With acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey Seventh Series One Inch Map 155
Buy some food in the village shop, and after she says “Be careful with the eggs” I go and drop them on the pavement outside as I make a grab at the door to close it, my other hand loaded with milk, spuds, grapefruit, etc. Hurriedly scoop eggs off the ground and put them in my billy can and trot off to the YH.
Old Norman castle. Enter through one of those keep doors, small door in a very big door, so small you have to stick your rucksack etc through first, and then follow. Yes, very old castle place.
Me and four others here tonight – a young German couple on bikes and two students who have gone down the boozer. I’m sitting in the dining room, the room with the fire and am writing this.
________________________
March 24. Llandogo, Monmouthshire. 11.20 a.m.
“When the bus comes it’s a single decker painted red and pay as you enter. Sitting, riding along, two women chat behind me. “That Mrs Jones is a very nice person”… – “Do you know Mr Thomas?”… They talk about music, and choirs and people they know, and we’re coming into Crickhowell.”
Trying to rain when I left the hostel. German couple passed me on their bikes, free wheeling down the hill, the long descent to the Wye Valley. When I get down to the Wye there’s a new steel bridge which I cross. The river’s chocolate treacle colour, bulging, flowing fast, pieces of hay and branches getting swept along. On the other side a steep wooded slope and hugging the slope and the river is the main road and below, at a second level, a ripped up railway track and disused station. Walk along the railway track and pass two men shovelling earth from a dumper, down the side of the railway bank.
St Briavels, Llandogo, Cecil Ford and Tintern Forest.
Walk into Llandogo which is round the corner and it looks exactly like somewhere in the Rhine Gorge.
Llandogo
Houses up on the hillside, and dug gardens, which from a distance could be mistaken for terraced vineyards. The Wye has a sharp corner here. There’s a few houses down on the main road and tourist cafes.
The drizzle has stopped, the sun is now shining, there’s a slight breeze and birds are whistling and looking down on Llandogo I feel moderately good.
Treworgan Common. 3.5 p.m.
Treworgan Common and Raglan
Sitting for a cig near a farm house. Grey stone, blue/grey slate roof, green painted door and windows. Grey stone outbuildings with rusted tin roofs, and a stone bridge crossing a stream. Daffodils, dandelions, violets, bluebells and snow drops beginning to bloom. There’s pussy willow and green buds on the trees. Sheep and lambs baa-ing, some cattle and on the way here rain followed by a hail storm for five minutes. Earlier, about 12 a.m., back near Tintern Forest/Cecil Ford I asked a sewage bloke in a lorry if I was on the right road. I was. Welsh accent, long oldish face, needed a shave.
Flat country around here.
Crickhowell YH, Breconshire. 9.50 p.m.
Crickhowell Youth Hostel
Back to this afternoon: In Raglan at 3.45 p.m. and buy a grapefruit, tin of soup, packet of biscuits and get on the A.40. I’m hitching the other side of a round-about but there’s not many cars. Then at 4.15 a yellow Consul stops and he’s going to Abergavenny. Get in – the interiors a mess, papers, empty fag packets. Nice ride to Abergavenny, there’s a lot of school children around, just out of school as we get there. He drops me off. It’s a moderately big place. Buy more food as it is half day closing in Crickhowell.
In Abergavenny roll a cig as I wait for a bus to Brecon that will take me to Crickhowell. When it comes it’s it’s a single decker painted red and pay as you enter. Sitting, riding along, two women chat behind me. “That Mrs Jones is a very nice person”… – “Do you know Mr Thomas?”… They talk about music, and choirs and people they know, and we’re coming into Crickhowell.
Crickhowell
I find the YH. According to the Handbook the warden lives in a house adjoining. Knock, her son comes to the door “She’s out”, he says, and takes my money and takes me to the YH and shows me around. It’s a sort of Georgian House, and tonight I’ve got the place to myself. Explore the kitchen as I start to cook a meal. Some previous hostellers have left a load of moulding food in one of the cupboards. As I’m throwing it out the warden turns up. Not worried I’m here, and doesn’t ask me to sign the hostel book yet. Pretty lax here.
Go out for a drink, a pint of bitter, but I didn’t really enjoy it. Youngish bloke in the near- empty bar telling anyone who cared to listen a. how he applied and failed to become a prison warden at Horfield, Bristol and b. how the law was cock-eyed. “Done away with this hanging, see. S’not right, is it?” The woman behind the bar chimes in with “They only get 15 years now.” Only? And I kept drinking.
Back at the hostel I noticed, which I hadn’t noticed before, “Victoria Toilet Fixtures” on the toilets in the bog.
_______________________
March 25. Thursday. near Bont, Black Mountains.
“Suffering from misguided romanticism I ache, I’m wet and I’ve sore feet.”
Acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey. Sheet 141. Seventh Series 1″ Revision Date 1959Pen Cerig-calch and Bont.
Back towards Crickhowell it was blotchy black and blue a minute ago and jet black clouds were rolling over the brow of Pen Cerig-calch on my left. The hills around here are in some respects like the Yorkshire Dales, but with different colouring. They are black on top, probably some kind of grit, otherwise they are fern covered limestone. The fern and bracken is dead, a sort of ginger colour. There are small patches of forest – mixed colours: olive greens, light browns, burnt reds, and on the farthest mountains there are patches of snow. There are quite a few cottages and farms in the valley and a lot of the hill slopes are fenced/walled in green pasture.
12 o’ clock. Grwyne Fechan valley, by the Hermitage.
Hermitage
The Hermitage is a derelict stone two storey building, no roof, with two Elizabethan or possibly Gerogian looking chimney stacks. This winding, steep sided valley is beautiful with a wide fast flowing mountain stream hissing over the boulders, on its way down to Crickhowell. I’ve passed about half a dozen derelict cottages/farm houses right by the water’s edge. There was one set back from the stream in some trees. The roof had fallen in and crows were flying in and out of it. But you’d have to have about £3000 to rebuild them to live in. Further back still there were a couple of houses that had been converted, looked like rich men’s country cottages. But I’m not rich. Now for some date bar.
Further Up the Valley Could so easily be raining, but it isn’t. Most of the time the sun is out despite the black clouds. I’ve left the Hermitage and woods behind. The valley is in its earlier stages here, the slopes are less acute and the valley floor is wider. Crossed a flat stone bridge with no walls that spans the stream. Made a sketch of the view.
3.20 Reservoir. Abertilly Reservoir, built 1928, 1,750′ above sea level.
Waun Fack and Abertilly Reservoir
I continued climbing up the Grwyne Fechan valley and to my surprise there was a path that went over Waun Fach (2,660′). It’s not shown on the map and I don’t think it was a sheep track. Great panoramic view from Waun Fach. Snow on the Brecon Beacons. There are a lot of patches of snow around where I am – snow and ice. Snow on my boots. The ascent and the descent was very boggy with the melting snow. Luckily not much wind.
Later, in Crickhowell Y.H. evening. Suffering from misguided romanticism I ache, I’m wet and I’ve sore feet. To pick up the story from where it was left off. After leaving the reservoir it started to rain (and me saying ‘It could so easily be raining’ earlier). I thought it would clear up, but it didn’t. It went on and on and I started to get wet. I’m walking down the wooded valley of Grwyne Fawr, getting wetter and wetter. Instead of going the long way round on a road that eventually goes into Crickhowell I try a short cut across the mountains, but it misfires, I come out of a wood back onto the same road. By this time – 4.30 – I’m about as wet as I can be, jeans soaked, sticking to my legs, water squelching out of my boots as I walk along. I’m swearing as there is no short cut back (well, no easy one) to Crickhowell. Come to a road junction with a sign that says Crickhowell’s 5 miles. Teeth literally gritted together, I set off as fast as I can, looking down at the road thinking psychologically this will make me think I’m covering a lot of distance, but the road’s unending and the rain’s unending. Eventually come to a point where I’m looking down on Crickhowell. It looks like a small German town, and irony of ironies – it’s now 7.15 p.m. – it’s stopped raining and there’s a strong wind.
Descend into the town and at last, at 7.35 make the YH. In and change my clothes, empty my boots of water. There’s a young Civil servant here tonight, besides me. He’s got a pot of tea and offers me a cup which I gladly take. Seem to spend all of the evening hanging up my clothes to dry and trying to dry my rucksack. Later, in the dormitory, in our beds before we go to sleep, me and the Civil Servant discuss the mental make-up of dachshunds.
___________________
March 26. Ty’n-Y-Cae Youth Hostel. 8.55 p.m.
Tyn-Y-Cae Youth Hostel
Having a sort of little crisis at the moment. The weather was nice today as I walked to Tyn-Y-Cae but my boots suddenly hurt like fuck, big blisters on my heels. Maybe because the woman warden at Crickhowell dried them in an oven for me overnight. She said it would be alright, but I think they’ve shrunk. Walking today was hardly tolerable and my pack seemed heavy, and the scenery, apart for one or two spots, was dull, as because my feet were hurting I decided to walk most of the way along the Monmouthshire and Brecon canal.
Monmouthshire & Brecon Canal
The little crisis is that at one point as I was walking along the tow path I thought “Fuck it! I’ve had enough of this.” Three months hike to Scotland was a glorious big misconceived idea! Besides the boots and heavy rucksack, nearly all the hostels seem booked up in the coming weeks, and also there is a pressure to get to a youth hostel before local shops close at 5.30 to get food for myself, and sometimes with the distance between hostels or the terrain, that isn’t always possible. (Small hostels often did not have a hostel ‘store’ selling basics such as tinned food, or milk.) Still, what would I do if I packed it in. Spend three months writing TV plays? I don’t think so. Let’s see what I feel like this time next week, next Friday.
Incidentally, Tyn-Y-Cae is dead smart and nice. Quite a few walkers turned up. Friendly lot. It even has a proper hot bath. I soaked in it. Staying here tomorrow so I can hike to the Brecon Beacons.
_____________________
March 27. Saturday. Tyn-y-Cae YH
“There was a slight diversion this evening (he’s gone to bed I think) of a Welshman staying this evening, muttering about “immorality” in the YHA.”
Pen y Fan and Brecon Beacons
Today was good, very good. I went with a group of Cardiff hostellers over the Brecon Beacons to Storey Arms. They were: Anne with blond hair; a small dark wearing glasses girl and two blokes, one tall and one short. Thank goodness my boots were comfortable, I’d dubbinged them the evening before. It was quite a climb, leaving Brecon by the old Roman Road, up to the three peaks, the highest which we went to being Pen-Y-Fan. (2906′)
It clouded up there and there was a bit of a wind, but otherwise walking up it was sunny. Made our way down to Storey Arms YH on the main road that goes through the mountains. In the same house there is a cafe. We all bought something. I had a cup of tea and two buns. Old couple run the cafe. Some army blokes and birds came in. (The Brecon Beacons are still used by the Army for training and other exercises.) The blokes drank tea and they had pop. Anne and the Cardiff hostellers were going to stay at the Storey Arms, so I started hitching for Brecon.
Get picked up in a new maroon coloured Mini and taken to Brecon. Shops still open so buy postcards, OS 128 map, Shreddies and walk to the YH. A new list of booked hostels has been put up by the warden. It’s not good. It’s fucking terrible. Because of Easter in April and school holidays some I had planned to stay in are now fully booked up. Instead of being spontaneous I really have to plan very carefully with that nagging worry, because I can’t afford bed and breakfast, which would eat desperately into my weekly budget, and this is not the best time of year for sleeping out. However, there was a slight diversion this evening (he’s gone to bed I think) of a Welshman staying this evening, muttering about “immorality” in the YHA. He didn’t make it clear what sort of “immorality” he was talking about. Was he religious?
____________________
March 28. Sunday. Glascwm YH.
“It’s dusk, almost dark now. Start the walk along an uninhibited valley to Glascwm, after putting my anorak on, taking out my torch and eating chocolate. On one side of me the sound of a stream in the valley, on the other side a dark hill slope running up to a dark sky, with stars starting to show.”
Left Tyn-Y-Cae YH at 10. Blue sky, warm day. Walked up the main road that goes to Hay on Wye. Hitched for half an hour but being a Sunday road very quiet, so thought “Sod it” and started the long walk to Glascwm, which it’s turning out to be.
Yes, it’s a warm, sweaty, pleasant day.
Pentre-newbry
Walking along quiet back roads. In one two girls looking for eggs in the hedge. Past a church, it was more like a house, near Llwyn Cynog. No-one around. Church – Chapel? -goers Austin’s and Morris’s parked on the grass outside. There’s a cat sitting on one of the car bonnets looking at me. Start on the steep road for Pentre-newbry. A dog back near the church starts barking at me. At Pentre-newbry it’s flatttish heather clad highland. Then on to Mynydd Fforest (1312′) where I make a bad mistake.
Mynydd Fforest, Llyswen, Boughrood.
It’s all grass tracks up there and I took the wrong one, although it took me to as far as Llyswen to realise it. Ten miles out of my way. I should have come out onto the road further up, to the north. It’s four o’clock and I’m weighing up my chances to getting to Glascwm across the hills before it gets dark. Meet four lads with rucksacks who’ve been camping in the town, as small as it is. I cross the Wye to Boughrood. The river is cleaner, fresher looking here. It’s 4.5 p.m. Buy a bottle of Corona Clarade – it tastes like cherryade – and some chocolate – long walk ahead of me.
Cross the hills and come down into Pentre. Ask a woman where the footpath is that crosses the stream and up over the next hill is. Her hubby sits on a tractor a way off. She shows me. I have to cross the stream but there’s no bridge so take my socks and boots off, cross and start the climb up. I get up to the ridge and it’s 7.30 p.m. The sun’s setting and there’s five horses – golden silhouettes against the sinking sun. They look good.
Ireland, Rhulen and Glascwm.
Then a knee deep walk in bracken and heather to a deserted house called Ireland, and follow a track down into Rhulen, which is a few farms. It’s dusk, almost dark now. Start the walk along an uninhabited valley to Glascwm, after putting my anorak on, taking out my torch and eating chocolate. On one side of me the sound of a stream in the valley, on the other side a dark hill slope running up to a dark sky, with stars starting to show. And before I calculated it I’m in Glascwm. It’s 9.5 p.m.
The YH is a small school house. The warden’s house is across the road.
Glascwm.
Two others staying there – oldish couple, cycling. The couple give me a welcome cup of coffee, and then I go across with them to pay the bed night fee, buy some eggs, chocolate, biscuits, milk and there’s a letter for me I was three quarters expecting from Judith. Read it as I have tomato soup followed by coffee. Nothing startling but an amusing letter none the less. The oldish couple act like a couple of 18 year olds. I like them, spirit, guts. Living in the present. The sky is now jet black and intensely starry.
______________________
March 29. Monday. 10.7 a.m. Near Little Hill, 1,601′. Starting on my way to Llandrindod Wells.
“Leisurely descent down to Llandindod Wells. It’s a weird place. I walked into it along a tree lined avenue – it was like walking into a Sunday afternoon from 60 years ago.”
Woke up this morning around 6.30 and I can hear the couple talking. “I say, isn’t it beautiful!” She’s a bit of out-of-this-world pleasant nutter. Like an 18 year old unsophisticated girl. She holds her age well, I can’t guess it – perhaps 40? They cycled off before I left. I left at 9.30. I’m near Little Hill.
Llandrindod Wells. With Acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey. Sheet 128. Seventh Series 1″ map.
Its peaceful here. There’s a blue sky, a warm sun and there’s a bird singing somewhere in the burnt chocolate coloured heather. The only other sound is my watch ticking as my hands are behind my head as I look up at the sky. There’s a sudden fluttery noise and that bird has just flown over. A plane flies slowly overhead, wonder where it’s going, wonder who’s piloting it. I sit up and read Judith’s letter again.
1.55 p.m. Just past Pawl-hir. Descended from Little Hill, crossed A 481, quiet country road, no traffic on it, and then walked to Frank’s Bridge and partially followed the road by the River Edw, and then climbed up a track that went past a tree plantation, conifers with a sign saying Economic Forest Group. Spoilt by the barbed wire going around the plantation.
This is a pretty leisurely day, compared with the long hike yesterday. I’ve paused to have my dinner – bar of chocolate, water and a cig. From here there’s a path descending eventually down into Llandrindod Wells.
4.30 p.m. Waiting for the YH to open. Still warm. Leisurely descent down to Llandindod Wells. It’s a weird place. I walked into it along a tree lined avenue – it was like walking into a Sunday afternoon from 60 years ago. No one around, came to the town centre, a square, a few people. A policeman talking to a bloke, a dog chasing another dog. The place is like a Victorian New Town – nearly all the buildings are Victorian suburban houses. If you took the cars away it would be like being back 60 years. Some of the “main” buildings are monstrous – 4 storey high, red brick, glass veranda with ghastly turret towers shooting upwards from the side.
9.35 p.m. The YH, Llandrindod Wells.
This hostel gets me down. It’s not a YHA hostel, but YHA members can book in to it. It’s part of St Christopher’s Holiday Centre, what ever that may be. (St Christopher, Patron Saint of Travellers. YHA hostellers could use its facilities between 1962 – 1966. The holiday centre is believed to be now closed.) I’m sitting in what I’ve been told is the ‘temporary’ common room. Presumably they’re doing up the regular one. There’s Catholic scrolls encased and hanging on the walls, which gets me down, which smothers me. There’s also a weird framed large head and shoulders painting of Christ with long sort of blond hair, and wherever you are in the room, he seems to be following you – the eyes. There must be some trick with it. It’s a craphole of a hostel and I wish I hadn’t booked in for tomorrow night, but I have. A lone cyclist here, waiting to go to Birmingham University. Went to a pub with him and had 2½ pints of bitter.
______________________
March 30. Tuesday. Near Cefn-y-grug, 1,542′.
“This waterfall looks like the Consulate Menthol Cig ad on the back of last weeks’s Observer.”
Left the hostel at twenty to nine and caught a bus to Penybont. The bus runs on Tuesdays only. Run by a company called Cross Gate Motors – even more decrepid than Pennine Services in the Yorkshire Dales. Cross Gate buses are old Bedfords. There’s me and just two other people on it
Cross Gate Motors Bedford bus. Photo Allan Farrow, from his Flickr account.
From Penybont I take a track and then footpath up to the summit of Cefn-ygrug (1,542′), and I’m having a cig before I follow the path along to Nyth-grug (1,767′) and then down to Water-Break-Its-Neck.
Penybont, Cefn-y-grug and Water-Break-Its-Neck
The sun’s out, it’s a warm day and just had dinner of an orange and chocolate. Bits of the landscape here remind me of the Yorkshire Dales. It’s a good place.
Water-Break-Its-Neck.
2.28 p.m. Water Break It’s Neck is the name of a 100′ waterfall – the highest in Central Wales, which I’m sitting near the foot of. It’s not that impressive as it isn’t a sheer drop. There are Forestry Commission woods around here, mixed conifers including larches. Lovely blend of colours. The path here crossing the hills was a wild flat plateau top, and dropping down on the way to here is a shooting range belonging to Imperial Metal Industries.
Actually, this waterfall looks like the Consulate Menthol Cig ad on the back of last weeks’s Observer.
Consulate – Menthol-fresh.
3.34 p.m. On the long track back across the hills to Penybont, stopped by a beck to have a cig, lying on its bank and look up at the blue sky. Rusted barbed wire across my field of vision against the blue ceiling, and rotting wooden posts.
8.45. Llandrindod Wells YH. Got to Pennybont five to six and waited until 6.30 by which time I reckoned the bus wasn’t coming, so started walking, when a Civil Defence van, woman driver, two blokes, stopped and gave me a lift into Llandrindod.
_______________________
March 31. Heading for Nant-Y-Dernol YH. 11.25.
“This is the greatest place I’ve seen yet. It’s beautiful”
On Rhiw Gwraidd, 1,429′ Stiffish cold breeze but the sun’s out. A view from here of rolling hills and patchwork fields: that’s Central Wales. All farm dogs around here seem to be black and white scruffs. (Given his semi-suburban upbringing Le Patron didn’t realise that these “scruffs” were pedigree Border Collies that all hill farmers in Wales, England and Scotland use because of their exceptional ability to round up and control sheep and cattle.)
Franklyn’s Mild is the cig tobacco around here. Hardly ever see it in England, usually AI Light or Sun Valley. Yes, rolling hills around here.
Llandrindod Wells to Rhayader.
1.5 p.m. Near Gaufron.
Gaufron to Rhayader
Instead of going across the hills to Rhayader I ended up on the A44 going to Rhayader having taking the wrong track.
Nantymynoch to Gaufron
It’s now a hot day. Asked a farm worker at Nantymynoch where I was. Old bloke, woman by a farmhouse weeding, two blokes with a tractor in a stream, washing it. I find a track that’s running above the A44 which I’m now on. It really is hot here.
Rhayader.
2.25 On unclassified mountain road to Aberyswth, as I write this. Rhayader is a great place – a real country town in mid Wales, genuine and not like Llandrindod. Bought a Cornish pasty and date bar in the town, which also has several hotels, classy as well, but a nice place. The scenery around here starts to pick up.
Glan-llyn, near Rhayader.
3.10 p.m. This is the greatest place I’ve seen yet. It’s beautiful. It’s on the mountain road between Dderw and Craig-ddu. A great, great valley with the road slowly climbing on one side, and you look down and see the slopes covered with silver birch and there’s a small lake in the bottom. Looking up the slope from the road all you can see is knarled twisted silver trunked trees, flaking grey limestone slabs and just about, the blue sky. But amongst all those trunks and branches it looks almost black.
Between Dderw and Craig-ddu, near Rhayader.
Up here at the pass you look down and that wooded hill slope looks fantatsic – lime/olive greens, ginger (from the dead fern), silver from the birches, sand yellow colours and the grey of the limestone and the faded yellow green turf on top – all this in a clear blue sky and Spring sun. Where I’m sitting, either side of me, great slabs of flaking limestone jutting out of the hillside, and there’s some sandstone and slate too. And dotted along the roadside white painted posts for the weary driver at night.
Pen-rhiw-wen to Nant-y-Dernol YH
3.55 Pen-rhiw-wen It’s one big cotton grass and turf plateau top up here. From Ryadader it’s been the best walk so far. Weather’s great, I’ve been lying back on the turf feeling the sun on my face. A few people pass in cars, sight-seers, like me.
5 o’ clock Near Dernol, on hill slope overlooking the Wye Valley. Yes, the River Wye again. It’s in it’s early stages here.
10 to 10 p.m. Nant-Y-Dernol YH.This place is even better than Glascwm. Nearest shop is 7 miles away, in another valley. The hostel is on a valley slope, by a track. The warden’s house is ½ a mile down the road, and I’ve got the hostel to myself. No electricity, sanitation or water. I have to fetch my water from a well that’s further up the track. There’s a very old looking range with side compartments and there’s a red coal fire burning. There’s a pile of wood in the corner and light comes from two gas lamps that are run off a Calor Gas cyclinder. Black beams above, and the floor is old stone slabs. I got fresh milk and eggs from the warden, who’s an old woman who milks the cows on the farm down the valley. Another great starry night. I look out and you can see the dark outline of the hills opposite. This is the sort of place I’d like to live in.
Nant-y-Dernol Youth Hostel on OS 1″ Seventh Series Map, Sheet 128.
______________________
April 1. 10.40 a.m., near a ford, sitting on the banks of the River Wye, north of Nant-y-Dernol.
“When I was waiting for the Y.H. to open, two small boys walked up to the spot where I was, one carrying a yellow balloon, and came and joined me and then interrogated me as I started to walk back down into the town.”
Valley of the Wye from Llangurig.
What a difference from the Wye I crossed last week near St.Briavels. Here it is crystal clear, about three to four foot deep, moving leisurely, about 25 foot wide with a few pebble banks. Valley is quite wide here, a bit of meadowland and then the hills rising up on either side. Another great blue sky warm day. Left Nant-y-Dernol YH at 9.30.
Llangurig & River Wye. Photo copyright Ray Holdsworth/Estate of.
12.35 p.m. Llangurig is a nice small village. Bought a packet of biscuits in the village shop/Post Office and then a steepish walk out of Llangurig on the unclassified road. Talked to a shepherd as he moved his sheep along the road from one field to another.
Llangurig to Llanidloes
After talking to the shepherd I sat on a bank and being the pig I am I ate the packet of biscuits – this being lunch, this being 11.30, this only intending to eat four. Wide valley ahead, a view of Llanidloes and sound of children playing in the distance.
4 p.m. Walked into Llanidloes at about half one. It’s a beautiful place. Georgian, with two wide main streets. A lot of grey/blue slate in the buildings and slate cobbled paths. Hardly anyone around. It’s warm, quiet and peaceful. Serene. Went into the Public Conveniences, as the Council calls them. And out again. A few old men standing around. There’s a great black timber and white plaster market building in the centre with arches going through it –
The Old Market Hall, Llanidloes.
– yeah, well something like that, and so onto the road for Newtown. Light traffic – green fields, river – donkeys in the field, rolling in a dust patch.
Llanidloes and surrounding countryside.
Van stops, dark green Austin van, get in, going to Newtown – incredibly, gloriously untidy inside. Forestry bloke, shrubs, private, not Forestry Commission. Gives me an Embassy, tells me about the floods they had in Newtown last December, pointed out the caravans where flood victims now live. Apparently it hit the whole town, smashing down buildings and smashing in shop windows.
River Severn flooding at Newtown. Year unclear, either 1960 – a previous flood – or December, 1964.High Street, Newton.Flooding of Parker’s Lane, Newtown, December 1964.
Goes out of his way to drop me off at the YH, an old church by the looks of it. I walk to the only shop that’s open – half closing day – the Co-op, and get some food I didn’t intend to get as they haven’t got what I wanted – i.e. grapefruit, and a Vesta meal.
Despite its name, Newtown is another pleasant old town with wide streets. I’ve taken a steep walk out of the town, in the countryside, to wait ’til 5 0′ clock and the YH to open, and write these notes.
Newtown and the River Severn.
11.35 p.m. Newtown Y.H. When I was waiting for the Y.H. to open, two small boys walked up to the spot where I was, one carrying a yellow balloon, and came and joined me and then interrogated me as I started to walk back down into the town. One of them asked to hold my map case, and the other one showed me where a milk vending machine was in the town. They left me when I went into the Y.H. which was now open. A woman there in the office takes my card and says the warden will be up later.
Eating my meal in the self-catering kitchen he turns up and turns out to be bent – calling me Pete, offering me cigs – which I took – and dropping his cig ends all over the floor. Lights a fire in the women’s dormitory and sits by it, with me, while I pretend I’m reading the Observer. He eventually pushes off – (warning) telling me he’ll be back at 9.
Two Israeli girls turn up, who at first I mistake to be French. Nice to look at, nice to talk to. They drop off their stuff and go out to the town to find something to eat and in the meantime Cyril returns. (“Cyril”, as written in the notes, is not his real name. The real Cyril was a sports teacher at one of Le Patron’s former schools, who enjoyed ogling the boys in the showers as his glasses steamed up and later left teaching to join the Church of England.) Stilted, suggestive comments and conversation for half an hour and getting nowhere with me he pushes off again. The girls return from the town and the three of us talk solid ’til ten past eleven – mainly – well – spiritual things, philosophy – call it what you will. Sartre, existence, etc.
_______________________
April 2. Harlech station, possibly 4 p.m.
“Suddenly – from nowhere – a load of scruffy looking, shouting, squealing school children – and I guess I was like that once – black blazers and grey flannels and hats on the back of their heads – and ties off – the heat – and scruffy looking. They pile into the 4.13, me with them. And the amazing thing is the majority are speaking Welsh. I always thought use of Welsh was isolated, but here are tens of school children speaking Welsh – a foreign language to me – but their first language.”
Watch has packed up, so that’s why I’m vague about the time.
_____________________________
“To The Warden,Youth Hostel, Greenfield Road, Holmfirth, Huddersfield, Yorkshire.
Dear Warden,
I would be grateful, if it is possible, if you could reserve a bed for myself (male) for the nights: Thurs, Friday and Saturday, April 15-16-17th.
I would also like to order in advance 3 pints of milk, 2 loaves of bread and a dozen eggs for that period. I enclose a P.O. for 16/9 to cover overnight charges”
(The dates requested were the Easter weekend in 1965. 16/9 = 84 pence)
_____________________________
That was written a couple of minutes ago but I’ve changed my mind as it will be absolutely useless trying to book in advance, without seeing the hostel booking lists and with me having no definite YH address for the warden to write back to. So, to pick up the story after last night in Newtown.
Got up early, though didn’t realise it as, as I said, my watch has packed up. Didn’t realise it ’til later. Had breakfast, two cigs, and then hesitant if I should knock on the girl’s dormitory and wake up Sima and Shula to say goodbye. Saved by hearing their voices. So I knock. “Good morning” they say from inside. “Can I come in?” – “Wait a moment please” and I do. In the meantime the woman from yesterday turns up to give us our YH cards, and the girls emerge. The three of us exchange addresses and promises of seeing each other again – in Israel? It’s an idea. So I leave and cash some money at the Post Office.
Get on the road for Dolgellau.
Newtown – Machynlleth – Dolgelly (Dolgellau). Acknowledgement: Esso Map No.4 “Wales and Midlands”, published 1965.
Get a fairly long lift in a new Austin van, bloke delivering paint, going to Towyn. Hot, hot day, pleasant valley scenery. He dropped me off at Machynlleth a pleasant old town, and I bought a date bar and the O.S. map for Snowdonia.
Machynlleth.
Walk past a railway station, over a bridge – wide, clear river.
Machynlleth, The Dover Bridge.
Hitch, though there are few passing cars. And then a big Austin stops and I get in. At a rough guess, a farmer. A tin of black treacle in front of me. He has a stuttery, almost incoherent speech, telling me that being such a nice chap I should get my hair cut, that it would effect my chances for a job in an interview, then keeping silent for the rest of the journey apart from whistling softly. And he’s a terrible driver. I don’t mind him going slow – I was enjoying the view – but he kept putting the break on every 50 yards for no conceivable reason – there was nothing on the road, a clear view, and yet, brake again almost to a crawl, and then off again, but it’s a great road into Dalgellau.
DolgellauDolgellau Bridge.
He drops me off across the bridge on the road going to Barmouth/Ffestiniog. I start to back over the bridge for a pee when I hear someone calling – “Peter!” I turn and it’s Sima and Shula. I’m glad to see them. They’re making for Caernarvon. We’re having a chat when a young American turns up. He’s just come over from Ireland, spending a year in Europe.
I give Sima and Shula first chance at hitching, as we’re on the same road. The American crosses the bridge going into Dolgellau, and I have a discreet pee by the bridge.
I’m noticing three things: first the greenness of the tress, the leaves, buds sprouting – didn’t see that in south and central Wales; two, the mountains – although only 1,500′ – 2,000′ – are rugged, stark and impressive looking. A different rock accounts for that. I think a lot of it is volcanic, not sure and three, a lot of people are talking Welsh.
A bloke in an old Austin van picks me up. He’s just been in hospital and the fool I am – and I was kicking myself afterwards – go the coast route with him, which is a diversion.
Ffestiniog YH. No idea of the time, gone 8 p.m. I think. There’s no fire and I’m cold.
Anyway, to pick up where I left off – The coast road’s pleasant and he drops me off seven miles the Harlech side of Barmouth. He assures me I’ll get to Ffestiniog easy from the drop off place. But there’s sod all traffic on the road. Nothing. Sand dunes and a RAF camp (RAF Llanbedr, now no longer a RAF camp) in the dunes in the distance and training jets with bright red paint screeching across the very blue sky.
Provest Jet trainer. RAF Jet Trainer of the 1960s.
I walk along the road, rest and eat and walk and eventually make Harlech a nice, dead place. Dead meaning no traffic.
Go into a cafe and have an ice cold glass of orange, cold yes, but not much of it. I ask about buses – missed one by ten minutes, I’m told. Next one’s 7 p.m. Pee-ow. I think, walk down the road, change my mind, no traffic, and go back to the cafe and ask about trains. Information sounds more helpful and hopeful, so I trot down to the station which is near the dunes. Train at 4.13 to Penrhyndeudraeth and I was told I can get a bus from there to Ffestiniog.
Harlech station, early to mid 1960s. Source Unknown
There’s a fly annoying me as I write this, it’s flying around this big cold hostel room. Anyway, back at the station and the train comes in and suddenly – from nowhere – a load of scruffy looking, shouting, squealing school children – and I guess I was like that once – black blazers and grey flannels and hats on the back of their heads – and ties off – the heat – and scruffy looking. They pile into the 4.13, me with them. And the amazing thing is the majority are speaking Welsh. I always thought use of Welsh was isolated, but here are tens of school children speaking Welsh – a foreign language to me – but their first language.
Get to Penrhyndeudraeth and a mad clumsy dash to get the bus. Make it after asking a small kid if it’s gone. He spoke English to me – “Don’t know”, then turns to a mate and asks his mate in Welsh. It’s – ah, sodding fly! – amazing how they can switch from one language to the other.
So it’s a green “Crosvilles” double decker – looking like an Eastern National – to Ffestiniog.
Crosville double decker bus. Photo copyright Ian Wild, from old-bus-photos.co.uk.
Conductor’s smoking an Embassy tipped and telling me where the shops are in Ffestiniog. Ffestiniog and those – bastard fly – those only 2,000′ hills look fanatastic, ragged angry against the sky – a great alarming makes me afraid sight. Buy some food, a lot of food and milk from a dairy I had trouble finding, where again the two shop hands had no trouble switching between Welsh and English with me. Make my way to the hostel. Large Victorian house.
Ffestiniog Youth Hostel.Ffestiniog Youth Hostel. With acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey. Seventh Series One Inch Map 107.
It’s completely empty – and yet there are other hostels 15 miles away, nearer Snowdon, that are probably booked up. Hard to define how I feel at the moment. See what the morning brings.
__________________
April 3. Saturday. Tan-y-grisiau
“After taking a wrong direction I can’t go on any further because there’s a crag and I’m on a narrow ledge, virtually a sheer drop below me where fantastically quarry trucks must have gone down – you can make out the track and about 15′ above me there’s a winch.”
It was a warm morning to wake up to – the warmest yet, and the visibility was so sharp and intense, like that morning in the mountains in Switzerland.
Ffestiniog, Tan-y-grisiau, Llyn Clogwyn brith, Cwm Croesor valley, Moelwyn Mawr and Moelwyn Bach
Last night at half past midnight (!) a load of students in a Land Rover turned up at the YH. In the morning they had a dirty great box of stores which they unpacked in the kitchen whilst I had my Kellogs, grapefruit and coffee.
After breakfast walked to Tanygrisiau which looks like a one time slate mining village – slate heaps, narrow gauge railway, grass growing over it and here and there the track torn up. The village is at the foot of the mountains – little slate cottages spread along and discarded pieces of machinery. Walls made of thin slabs of slate sticking vertically upwards and pieces of iron and tubing scattered around. I can see a new power station in the distance and electricity pylons spanning the craggy mountains. (Ffestiniog Hydro power station which had started producing electricity in 1963.) A place full of feeling.
Sometime before dinner time.Llyn Clogwyn brith. This really is a fantastic valley ascending from Tanygrisiau.
Llyn Clogwyn brith
I’m sitting at the top, looking down on the valley, which is curved. Wide, flat valley bottom and steep craggy sides. Great piles of slate 150′ high, layers of it and broken down deserted cottages/houses, even a church and at a rough guess I would say they’re not more than a century old. Old quarries, remains – pieces – of trucks that once went on the track – a winch for pulling them up and down the steep slope. All remains of a once thriving slate industry, yet sitting here it’s hard to imagine activity, people living in these slate broken-in-roof cottages or working in the quarries with the rusted track and the long grass. I had a look inside the church, and a house. From the outside they look alright but go in, and the ceiling’s gone, the floor’s are gone – nothing but stone and rubbish.
Later, over-looking Cwm Croesor valley.
Cwm Croesor and Croesor
After taking a wrong direction I can’t go on any further because there’s a crag and I’m on a narrow ledge, virtually a sheer drop below me where fantastically quarry trucks must have gone down – you can make out the track and about 15′ above me there’s a winch. It’s a straight ‘U’ shaped valley. Further back was the main quarry – rusted bogies, decaying buildings, dripping water, a shaft going into the hillside. You could see the sleepers amongst the pools of water and rock and weed and literally mountains of discarded slate.
Now to retrace my steps and find the right route.
Later, the bridge that crosses the Afon Maesgwn near Croesor. But I changed my mind, retraced some of my steps and then walked above. I could see two big mountains, and wondered if one of them was Snowdon. I was surprised to see the sea and the estuary five miles away. And then on to Moelwyn Bach, 2334′ and Moelwyn Mawr, 2527′ and suddenly I saw something in a bush I’ve never seen before – a red squirrel. Seen tens of grey sqirrels but never a red. It had a an orange/cream stomach. I was five feet away from it, it couldn’t decide what to do, and then dashed down and onto and along a stone wall.
______________________________________
Moelwyn from the youth hostel near Ffestiniog.
Afternoon, between Moelwyn Bach and Moelywn Mawr, overlooking Llyn Stwlan.
Moelwyn Mawr, 2527′ and Moelwyn Bach, 2334′.
A lot of hills in the hazy distance. It was a puffy walk up to this point but rewarded with a view when you make it. The rock is black, slatey, craggy, harsh and glistens white like glass in the sun. Streaks of white crystalline in it. Can hear blasting in the distance, probably from Blaenau Ffestiniog. (There was still slate mining in Blaneau Ffestiniog in 1965. Significant quarrying ceased in 1970, putting many out of work. Some small scale quarrying continues but tourism is now the main ‘industry’.)
Wish I knew what the time is – wish my sodding watch worked – well, it’s ticking but the hands keep getting stuck. The sun’s been very hot, but just gone in behind some puffy looking white clouds.
Ffestiniog YH, around 7.30 p.m. at a guess. Again in this big cold room, but no fly this evening, thank goodness. The students haven’t returned yet – if they had, or did, we might get a fire lit. So back to the afternoon: descent to Tanygrisiau, only the path flaked out so had to descend at my own initiative. Passing and looking at more mine shafts followed by a descent down the piles of slate slag, on through derelict buildings and down into Tan-y-grisiau. A hot Saturday afternoon, hardly anyone around, very quiet. Go in a shop, get a small loaf and find out it’s 4 p.m. Walk to Ffestiniog looking forward to a meal of fish and chips but find that they don’t fry on a Saturday night. In the YH I have a middling meal of cauliflower soup and one Oxo cube and brown bread and Marie biscuits and coffee. Writing this now and feeling a bit bored and thinking I could be doing other things at the moment. Like what?
__________________
April 4. Sunday. 10.35 a.m. near Llyn y Manod
“From Manod Quarry a walk to a second disused quarry, but once in use possibly 10? 20? 30? years ago. Long sheds, go in – broken machinery – pulleys, saw benches, files, tools and outside there are trucks still on the tracks and two small engines for pulling them.”
Llyn y Man0d, Blaenau-Ffestiniog, Manod Quarries, Tre-Gynwal and Penmachno.
Woke up feeling enthusiastic with a peculiar vision of the joys of seeing different parts of Britain. I usually do wake up in the morning feeling better than when I went to bed. Had my breakfast and outside a misty rain, which cleared up by the time I left.
Hills are lower here – 1,ooo’ to 2,000′. I look down and see flat undulating lowland. On either side of me the start of very black, craggy rock slopes and I’ve got to ascend the right hand one.
Later. Passed Llyn y Manod, which is a small lake, and now over-looking Blaenau Ffestiniog below. Impression of planned streets and everything a complete grey: grey slate roofs, a huddled slate mining town surrounded by slate slag heaps, and old quarries filled with water, the sun partly shining through low white clouds that are moving steadily along.
Blaenau Ffestiniog 1959.
Manod quarries and Tre-Gynwal
Overlooking Manod Quarries. A completely different scenery here – low smooth rounded hills, some wooded, some a dirty brown. There are telegraph poles descending to the quarry and then continue over the hills.
1.25 p.m ? One mile from PenmachnoI’m sitting near the road on the edge of a Forestry Commission forest. From Manod Quarry a walk to a second disused quarry, but once in use possibly 10? 20? 30? years ago. Long sheds, go in – broken machinery – pulleys, saw benches, files, tools and outside there are trucks still on the tracks and two small engines for pulling them. A lot of rusting machinery. And then a descent into Tre-Gynwal. Very quiet, cloudy Sunday morning. Slate roofed, walled cottages. Pass one shop, “Closed”, then a second “Open” and to my luck it is. Buy a pint of milk and two packets of biscuits. Then walk along this broad flat valley with a river to Penmachno. Gentle descending valley slopes here, bleating of sheep, wood on left hand side, a few farms. Have bread and chocolate, a cig and write this.
Penmachno and Pwll-y-gathPenmachno, late 1930s, or late 1940s.
Around 4 p.m. Just come through Pwll-y-gath and near Tan-y-clogwyn. Walked through the the forest after Penmachno. Out of the forest into Pwll-y-gath – three farms strung along a small pleasant very green in parts valley. Dragging on a cig, sound of a waterfall below me and low wooded hills in the distance.
______________________
April 5. Monday. Overlooking Dolwyddelan. 20 to 11 a.m.
“Bill please come down to the hall – Mama has invited us all to lunch – Joan.” Hand written message pinned to a board outside a place called Lledr Hall Guest House – Outdoor Pursuits Centre. Wonder what that was about.
Grey slate roofed country village where no one seems to have heard of Vesta meals after unsuccessfully going into the shops to buy some.
DolwyddelanVesta Meal magazine advertisement, believed to be mid to late 1960s.
(Vesta Meals were ideal for hikers as the packet was light to pack in a rucksack and all that was needed to make them in the hostel self-catering kitchen was boiling water, and they tasted better than the tins of grisly, fatty Irish Beef Stew that were often on sale in the hostel ‘shop’.)
Dolwyddelan multi views.
Overcast but bright. Craggy hills in the distance, possibly Snowdon amongst them. Sitting on a green painted wooden bench writing this.
Timeless – watch finally packed in, on way to Moel Siabod, 2860′. A walk through the forest, up a small hill, past a party of students with leader, past a lake and now here. A view of big mountains, probably the ones I’ll be crossing tomorrow to get to Idwal Cottage. Behind me, Moel Siabod – craggy, brutal, dark.
Dolwyddelan and Moel Siabod 2860′
One o clock? Sitting on the pinnicle top of Moel Siabod 2860′. Panoramic view of Snowdon and other mountains on both sides of me. The best view yet. In front of me are low hills, dark greens, almost black, and fawny browns and faded, faded greens. Behind me and around me in a semi circle dark, dark jagged mountains, Snowdon, the lot. Completely dark, in an outline and there’s a fantastic looking cloud curtain just above them. Something like this.
Looking towards Snowdon from Moel SiabodSnowdon, 3560′
It was a long and at many times steep and sweaty walk up to here, passing on the way a party of school boys and master. On the peak rock and boulders – dark, black – tumble steeply down into the rolling hills below.
Two o clock? Following the ridge from Moel Siabod.Sitting opposite the Llanberis Pass and Snowdon and can make out the miner’s track part way up to the summit. A little further on a flat moorland plain below me, fawny green/yellow.
Around 25 to 5, in forest above Dolwyddelan. The “flat” moorland plain wasn’t so flat as it looked when I descended to it – “undulating” would have been a better word. And it was quite boggy, so not straight-forward walking as I thought it would be. Follow streams, then onto the Ancient Track, and of then off and then back on, past the Castle in Dolwyddelan…
Ancient Track, Lledr Valley youth hostel and Dolwyddelan CastleDolwyddelan Castle
… past two blokes trying to push a mixer (cement mixer) onto the pavement and into the village and into a cafe to buy a box of matches. Surprised to find it’s only twenty past four which means (theoretically) that the ascent of Snowdon from Idwell (and back) should be done comfortably – say eight or nine hours.
Went into the village post office that also sells wool, small clothes, cotton, etc, besides the usual, and buy two 2½ d. stamps. (The Labour Government Postmaster-General, Anthony Wedgewood Benn, was to announce on 25 April, 1965 that charges for letters were to inclease to 4d for letters and 3d for postcards, effective from 17 May, 1965.)
Going out, in the street I notice a bloke with a fantastic looking large pack that must be killing him.
Just as I’m writing this in the forest, three Forestry Commission workers and a dog pass me, we nod at each other, and they all have the universal ex WD gas mask bag slung over their shoulder, with the Thermos flask poking out, just as I have on the building sites.
Lledr Valley YH evening.
“Bill please come down to the hall – Mama has invited us all to lunch – Joan.”
Hand written message pinned to a board outside a place called Lledr Hall Guest House – Outdoor Pursuits Centre. Wonder what that is all about. On the way to the YH it’s a walk along the River Lledr which is wide and full of boulders and clear and deep in places, and past the above named place. I ask a bloke who is passing what the time is and he says 5.45. As I’m walking, near to the YH, there were two girls walking along the road and for about a minute I thought they were Shula and Sima but getting nearer – ah no – two New Zealand girls – beefy.
Lledr Valley youth hostel, before it was faced with shingle tiles.
The hostel should be open but there are two bottles of milk outside the front door, not taken in. Is the warden in? Is he ill? Is he dead? I wait, sitting on the steps writing this and it’s spitting with rain. The New Zealand girls are waiting too. But – a-ha – the warden turns up and I was thinking I would complain for being late when he opens up and having to wait, but being me when he asks if we’ve been waiting long I say no (and the girls say no too) . But he’s a nice chummy chap.
The hostel from the outside looks vile – Victorian monstrosity built – of all things – wooden tiles painted institution green. But inside it’s not at all bad – warm for one thing and pleasant interior decoration. I’m given a small warm dormitory. A party of army cadets are in another dormitory, and there’s the two New Zealand girls.
I cook a Vesta Meal for One, chicken curry, with trepidation but to my surprose, because I hadn’t had the Chicken Curry one before, it turns out to taste pleasant plus a big filling meal. So again, Batchelors deserve a medal. The Vesta meals weigh only 3 ozs, they’re easy to carry several in your pack and they’re cheap, 2/3d. (27 pence.)
Whilst I was cooking the Vesta curry the army cadets came into the kitchen with their boxes of army rations, and on each box a little bit of paper says that besides the rations the contents contained are can opener, cooking instructions and – and – bog paper. They open the cans, cook the stuff and then use the bog paper when they’ve got the shits from eating the stuff. Is their food really that bad?
Used the pay phone to ring up Idwell Cottage (youth hostel), having difficulty pronouncing Dolwyddelan 202 to the Welsh operator (the Dolwyddelan bit). I managed to get booked in for tomorrow night. I then bought two postcards from the warden. Wrote one to parents and one to Colin and all at Pilning – hope they get it. (Le Patron had saved hard during the winter, working as a brickie’s labourer on the site of what was to be the Fire Station for the new Severn Road Bridge which was still being built. Colin was the affable foreman on the job, and the blokes on the site were a good lot. On a clear day from the incomplete roof of of the Fire Station there was a view of the Welsh hills across the Severn estuary. The Severn Road Bridge opened to traffic in September, 1966. The Fire Station has since closed. )
So, chummy warden with wife and kid of 3½. it’s OK here.
______________________
April 6. Tuesday, on track leading to Capel Curig. Around 10.15 a.m.
“I went up the steep climb gradually, often having to grab the heather and rocks. Some shifted though luckily most of them stayed. Having got to here I’m feeling pleased with myself. Unjustifiable though. It was a stupid thing to do. It could have been dangerous.”
Left the hostel 9.15 after having a chat with the warden. He worked in the shipyards at one time, was a shop steward. Went to the Peace Conference in Vienna in 1951. This morning he had a mild argument with the army cadets, well, more a discussion, about the army.
There’s a white frost this morning and a white mist in the valley, but the sun’s out and it’s getting warm. Walking to Capel Curig I’m thinking – as I’ve often thought – that I’d like to be a YH warden. But how does one start? Presumably by joining a local group, getting experience as an Assistant Warden during the summer season and then applying for a full time Warden’s job. I think it would be a nice and rewarding job. However, as I know, dreams can often be better than reality.
A comfortable walk through the forest, then out of it and along a slowly descending track.
Lledr Valley to Capel CurigCapel Curig
Later, near Capel Curig, Idwal Cottage side. There’s a great grocers shop at Capel Curig, about the only building there and I guess it gets a lot of hostellers/tourists stopping. The bins outside are stashed full with empty Coke, Orange, etc, tins and spilling over onto the ground. And of all things, this shop sells mostly Continental food! French biscuits, Chinese food – the lot. And Vesta meals. I got several.
I’m sitting on the track that will eventually take me to the Devil’s Kitchen. A couple of minutes ago over there on the other side of Afron Llugwy I watched a big red Austin lorry loaded with coal grinding up the gradient of the A5, with three cars following it.
Devil’s Kitchen, Tryfan, Glyder Fach and Glyder FawrTryfan, Snowdonia
Later About 100′ below the summit of Tryfan after climbing up – and I mean climbing up – its rocky heathery face because I lost the track down in the valley. So I went up the steep climb gradually, often having to grab the heather and rocks. Some shifted though luckily most of them stayed. Having got to here I’m feeling pleased with myself. Unjustifiable though. It was a stupid thing to do. It could have been dangerous.
Tryfan rises up out of the ground like a triangle, and on top, above me there’s jagged rock that sticks vertically up reaching for the sky. When you’re looking at it from a distance, before you climb it, it looks like people standing on the summit. As I’m writing this I can see a track that will take me to the top.
Adan & Eve, Tryfan
On the summit Great view – in front of me Glyder Fach, 3262′, which I’ll be going over later.
Tryfan 3010′, Glyder Fach 3262′ and Glyder Fawr 3279
A lot of snow over there on Glyder Fach. Just eaten my lunch of date bar. Black vertical jaggy mountains and the valley below me.
Glyder Fach summit. photo John R. Edwards/Estate of.
Then Restarted. The low clouds came even lower until it started to piss down and I took shelter under a slab of rock that was resting against Tryfan. Then the rain cleared for a bit and a tricky descent and ascent of Glyder Fach, 3262′ – a long ascent and the low cloud returned and I was guided by small cairns, spaced roughly at ten yards intervals. If they hadn’t been there I’d have been fucked, compass or no compass. Got to Glyder Fach and the summit is fantatastic – like a stone cactus, as if a gigantic mechanical shovel or crane had dropped great slabs on the top of it. Some are horizontal. Not the result of erosion, or glacial erosion I should think. A fantastic sight.
Coming off Glyder Fach I met four coming up – they told me I could follow the cairns down to Devil’s Kitchen, so I followed the cairns, climbing Glyder Fawr, 3279′ – another stone cactus – and started descending in the rain and low cloud following the cairns, which I thought were so friendly until I started descending a very, very steep slope that I mistook for Devil’s Kitchen – and to my horror of horrors I then realised I’d come down the wrong side – Llanberis/Snowdon side.
Llanberis (A4086)
Swearing and cursing and wet I descended to the road. There’s a bloke walking along with three kids and find out it is five past six and I’ve got one sod of a walk ahead of me – but car comes, hitch a lift and get a thankful lift to Capel Curig. He was a young bloke driving a Herald looking for somewhere to pitch his tent.
Triumph Herald. Courtesy Old Car Ads.
He drops me off and I walk along the road from Capel Curig. Two cars pass me but don’t stop, but a third does and drops me at the hostel. Leave boots in the drying room. Hostel is crowded – party of girls and army party. Have a meal. Talk to a bloke in warm coal fire common room and write this.
__________________
April 7. Wednesday. Penyrole-wen, at 3211′ point
“A lot of snow around. Snowfields on the cliff face, driven into the cliff face.”
Penyrole-wen, Carnedd Dafydd, Carnedd Llywelyn, Craig Yr Ysfa
Ten to eleven? Woke up and hear rain outside and there’s low cloud on the mountains. I’m not on the mountains and there’s still low cloud – wearing shorts – as if it rains at least I’ll have a dry pair of jeans to change in to when – (if?) – I get back. There was no point going up Snowdon in this visibility. Yes, low cloud, visibility down to 15 yards and coming up to this point it’s been a case of using my initiative and occasionally following the cairns, which I keep finding and losing. So far dry, but I doubt whether it’ll keep like that. There’s no wind at least and not too cold. Can’t see a thing except immediate surroundings which are jagged grey moss and lichen covered rock and heather.
12 a.m. Watch seems to be working. Sitting on summit of Carnedd Dafydd, 3427′ and an easy ascent. Great beds of small rock all the way up. Like at the beach when the tide’s gone out. Penyrole-wen was more difficult to get up.
Penrole-wen and Carnedd Dafydd 3427′
Been following the cairns and using my compass. Sun’s come out several times and you suddenly see blue sky, but low cloud has now closed in again.
Looking towards Craig yr ysfa
1.30 p.m. Craig Yr Ysfa. Half an hour ago having lunch on summit of Carnedd Llewelyn, 3485′ and before that the sun penetrated and the low cloud lifted and a great stirring view on either side of me – a massive U shaped valley and these fantastic deserted big valleys below and a view of Ffynnon Llugwy, the lake and still a lot of snow around. Snowfields on the cliff face, driven into the cliff face. All in all very impressive wild boggy craggy terrifying scenery. Carnedd Llewelyn was also an easy descent – again pebbles but even smaller. Now walking along a broad ridge to descend to the lake. Another big deserted brown/green dark rock valley below me. Really is great scenery.
Just past the lake, 2.25 p.m.A dodgy descent over loose scree to the lake – path just flakes out.
Carnedd Llywlyn, Craig yr ysfa and Ffynnon Llugwy
Sun out at the moment and got a view of Tryfan from here. It looks like the Matterhorn. It really is a peculiar mountain – lower than the rest and yet dominant. It’s shape, I think, and needle top. Looks like one of those dark mountains where witches have their castles on top in Walt Disney films.
Later at 4.15 p.m. Just finished writing a letter to parents – one way of killing time otherwise I’ll end up at the YH before five. After the lake descended to the A5, then back on the track I was on yesterday and now at the foot of Tryfan writing this – killing time.
______________________
April 8. Thursday. Chester Public Library. 2.10 p.m.
Idwal Cottage Youth HostelIdwell Cottage youth hostel (at head of Llyn Ogwen, red triangle above “T” for “Telephone”).
Left Idwal in the rain and I spent quarter of an hour by the roadside, by the lake, hitching the few cars that went past, and then a new Hillman stopped – and luck – got a lift past Llangollen on the road to Wrexham. Firm’s car, running it in.
1960s Hillman MinxA5 from Idwell Cottage (top left hand side) to Llangollen (bottom right hand side). Acknowledgement: Esso Map No.4, published 1965.
Youngish chap who in some ways reminded me of the warden at Lledr Valley – been in the army, national service, enjoyed it – married, done some camping. Pleasant bloke. So on the Wrexham Road and a Pakistani stops in a Thames Trader – Radio Caroline on the portable wireless and I notice different scenery.
Llangollen to Wrexham. Esso Map No 4, published 1965.
Flat land, red brick houses, completely different scenery – red bricked villas, roadside transport caffs, NCB (National Coal Board) lorries and a road sign saying “This Road is Liable to Subsidence”. Because of mining, presumably, Corporation buses and you’re nearly back in England and a few slag heaps in the flat land.
Wrexham to Chester, and the Mersey. Esso Map No.4, published 1965.
Wrexham and get a lift to Chester from young bloke in another Trader, mechanic. Gives me a cig, going along, the rain’s driving down, the wind screen wiper making a noise. Dropped me in Chester around 12. Old place – students and school kids with satchels and football gear, perhaps they’ve broken up for Easter. People shopping, blokes in boiler suits – and it’s drizzling now. Find a bog, have a piss – go through an indoor market, buy grapefruit, Kellogs, etc. Walk past some of the Old Wall – there’s a moat or river filled with filth and oil. Go in a fish and chip shop, in the dining room, and after a long wait for service have fish, chips, peas, bread, tea for 3/6 – and they could have been a bit more sparing with the chips.
Mersey Beat, a 1964 copy. The “Next Beatles Film” was to be Help, released in the summer of 1965.
The dining room’s in the back – no windows. Woman and I presume her aged mother sitting at a table to the side of me, aged Mum chewing on her chips and a piece of fish. “That were lovely.” – “Did yer enjoy it? Are yer feeling better now? – Ooh, she does enjoy her chips. – I said, you like your chips, don’t yer mother.” Three young blokes sitting opposite me reading Merseybeat, and two girls and father on my side. Curious mixture of people in the place. So pay, go out, buy meat pie, potatoes, walk around but the rain gets heavier, go into the Public Library at 1.15 p.m. and I’m still here in the library.
____________________________________________
Walking to Scotland 1965
Next
2: England, The Peak District and into the West Riding.
Kodachrome slide, 1968. USA.A page in a German photo album of 1938.From The German Experience, a future Post at Pete Grafton Photos.Girl in a straw hat, England. 1914Girl in a straw hat, 6″x4″ glass plate negative.
________________
Photos by Pete Grafton
Fernandel at Bern bus station. September 2009.Girl wearing FCUK top, Edinburgh Festival. 2006.
Dawlish Air Show visitors. August, 2015.Lavassa, Bern Railway Station. October, 2008.
Pete Grafton. Self-portait. Dawlish, 2014.
Pete Grafton Photosare a monthly selection of photos taken by Pete Grafton throughout Europe, and from the Pete Grafton Collection – photos, slides, photo negatives and photo albums that he has collected in bric-a-brac shops in Europe, and on eBay. They have been posted since November 2016 at petegraftonphotos.com
______________________
Next Post here is on 22 March, 2017:
Walking to Scotland 1965
Kishorn Loch, 1965. Scotland.
Part I: Forest of Dean and Wales goes online here at petegrafton.com on 22 March, 2017.
A German card sent at Christmas, 1942. source Pete Grafton CollectionThe card was sent by German Forces Feldpost on 22 December, 1942.
The card was sent to a Minna Urban, living in Nürnberg (Nuremberg) in southern Germany. Within three years Nuremberg would become particularly known for the Nuremberg Trials, the prosecution by the victorious Allies of surviving Nazis such as Göring, Hess, Ribbentrop and Speer, and of German Forces commanders including Raeder, Keitel and Dönitz.
Theo, the sender writes “Best Christmas and New Year Wishes. It would be nice to hear from you again”.
Theo’s return address is Münster in north west Germany, which in 1942 was a city with a significant concentration of German Army barracks and units. Theo was fortunate to be writing his card to Minna in Münster in December, 1942. Over a month before, in north Africa, at the Second Battle of El Alemain the seeming invincibility of the German Army was broken when German, and Italian soldiers, were defeated in battle, and thousands taken prisoner. Field Marshal Rommel on 3 November, 1942 started a withdrawal.
Later in November – the 19th – USSR mounted a counter attack against the Germans at Stalingrad in near sub-zero temparatures and by 22 November, 1942 General Paulus the commander was telegramming Hitler that the German Sixth Army was surrounded.
From Christmas 1942 onwards, although it was not immediately clear at the time, the Allies had started to turn back German National Socialism and break for ever the German military class that had helped to put the National Socialists in power in 1933. (1) The Third Reich was annihilated two Christmas’s later, in the unconditional surrender of May 8 1945.
_________________________________
Other Christmas letters and cards had been posted in 1942 for Allied Forces in North Africa and the Middle East.
“One and a half million letters in one plane.” Source: British Daily Mirror, November, 1942. source Pete Grafton Collection.
________________________________
A National Socialist Christmas: Hitler at a Christmas Party, believed to be pre 1939. photo Public Domain.
The German National Socialists, enemies of Christians and Christianity, stripped Christmas of its Christian meaning, reverting, as they saw it, to its original German significance and meaning: a celebration of the winter solstice, the rebirth of the sun, and coming together of the community, witnessing the strength of their race. The Santa Claus was a Christian corruption of the German god Odin they claimed. The image of Mary and the baby Jesus in the manger was changed to an Ayran mother with a blond child.
Luftwaffe Officers, Night Fighter School, Christmas 1942. source: nachtjaegersoden.de“Reasons for joy: Receiving Christmas letters and packages at the Front.” source: feldgrau.comChristmas Party for some children of Mercedes Benz staff, 1938. Source: Prussian Heritage Image Archive/bilderarchivpreussischer kulturbesitz.Kriegs Weihnacht (War Christmas) 1942. Public domain.
German soldier taken photo: Unknown location, occupied territory eastern Europe, possibly 1942. Photo printed on Agfa paper. photo Pete Grafton Collection.
__________________
We do not know whether Minna did get back in touch with Theo, or whether they survived the war.
____________________________
Footnote
For the background to the German Army holding the reins of power behind the scenes from 1918 to 1933, and then outwitted by Hitler, who they thought they could control, see The Nemesis of Power: The German Army in Politics 1918 – 1945. J.H.Wheeler-Bennett, Macmillan, 1953.
It is late August, 1964: a dusty deserted roadside in Calabria. Either side of the road are olive trees.
Le Patron is hitch-hiking north of Reggio Calabria, the mainland port and ferry crossing for Sicily. His objective is another port, Bari, over to the east, on the Adriatic side of Italy. It is late afternoon and there is little traffic on the road. A pick and shovel repair gang a few yards up the road are occasionally pecking at the road verge. Le Patron is trying to understand a bus timetable tacked to a concrete shelter. One of the gang saunters over to Le Patron. He wears a dust stained vest and his trousers are held up by a bit of string, improvising for a belt. Le Patron splutters out pidgin Italian, but before he can finish his incomprehensible sentence the Italian smiles and says in a perfect Brooklyn accent: “Da bus goes at seven turty.” Besides the British 8th Army, American army units also travelled this road in the summer of 1943, heading north.
Allied troops, Cantabria, summer 1943.
Twenty one years before, almost to the month, Allied forces tanks, heavy artillery and jeeps would have jam packed the road, heading north, whilst up at Salerno the main allied thrust would have been taking place. In 1943, before the bus shelter had been built, in the middle of what seemed empty countryside children and adults would appear, cannily cheering the Allies on whilst asking for cigarettes and what ever else they could get, or barter for. A significant commodity in the bartering system was sex. (1)
He’s a youngish man, in his early thirties. He’s smiling and encouraging me by gesture to take a look at the black and white studio photo of his wife and two young children, that he’s just taken out of his wallet. “My wife, Maria, my son, Roberto and my little girl, Caterina.”
American tank crew soldier, south of Naples, 1943.
___________________
There’s a fearful, threatening black curtain hanging down from the sky, claustrophobically bearing down on the growing maize.
To the left there is a hurrying, receding blue sky. The buildings on the outskirts of Bari look as if they will give no protection to the Apocalypse that is about to unleash. And then it starts: the roll of thunder, the sheet lightning and goblets of rain smashing the windscreen of the Fiat family car, the wipers working manically to clear the sheets of water distorting the view of the road ahead.
In the twenty minutes it takes to arrive at a small block of flats in the centre of Bari the rain has stopped and the black shroud is moving on to put the fear of God into people and animals in the fields from where the car has just come from.
Le Patron had managed to get a lift into Bari with a youngish professional couple and their son. The car was a new four door shiny black Fiat sedan, and at the front of the four storey brick built flats were two sodden palm trees, still dripping. Around the flats was a low brick perimeter wall with high metal railings. The entrance to the block was up two wide steps and then through a metal framed door with a full length frosted glass panel. There were buzzers for the eight flats and eight letter flaps. Le Patron followed the small family up the stairs to the first floor and was shown in to the flat on the right by the husband, the attractive wife and their young son. It was the first time he had been in an Italian home.
The floors were shiny wood parquet, and the rooms were furnished in a spare, modern way. Le Patron had never seen a home with parquet flooring before. It was very foreign, in an interesting ‘cool’ way. It was almost like one of the rooms in La Dolce Vita where Steiner, intellectual friend of Marcello Mastrianni’s character lived, or so he thought.
La Dolce Vita (1960). Marcello in Steiner’s flat
The husband and wife spoke enough English for Le Patron to understand, the husband more so. The wife prepared lunch, and then afterwards following the lunch the husband showed Le Patron into a room with two single separate beds for the siesta. He and Le Patron occupied the room. Unlike the husband, Le Patron couldn’t sleep. Having a siesta after a meal was not something his 19 year old British body or culture could adapt to. Lying awake he wondered where the son and wife were having their siesta. There didn’t seem any clues as to whether this was a spare guest room or the son’s bedroom.
After the siesta Le Patron and the husband went through to the living room where the wife and son were watching Little Lord Fauntleroy, dubbed into Italian, on a television standing alone in the corner, on its futuristic stick legs.
Little Lord Fauntleroy (1936). Dolores Costello and Freddie Bartholomew as Little Lord Fauntleroy.
When the film finished there was a brief announcement, the logo of RAI – the Italian state TV – and the channel closed down. It was late afternoon. The TV service would begin again in the evening.
Later that night in the Bari campsite where the family had kindly driven Le Patron, he thought about the wife telling him about the RAF raid on Bari during the war, asking why they had done it. She was not angry, but perplexed. She had been 17, she said, working in the Bari Telephone Exchange when with no warning – no siren – the bombs fell on the harbour area.
It was years later that Le Patron realised he had spectacularly misunderstood the circumstances of the bombing of Bari. Looking back he realised she had been asking why the RAF didn’t prevent the bombing of Bari.
An estimated 105 Luftwaffe planes bombed Bari on 2 December, 1943, and in just over one hour sunk 27 Allied supply and cargo ships. There were 1000 deaths of Allied seamen and service personnel, and also an estimated 1000 Bari people were killed, although accurate figures for the civilian deaths are still unavailable as many Italians left Bari and went out to the countryside, staying with friends and family members, fearful of further attacks on the town, and some of those fleeing civilians died from gas poisoning. What no one knew in Bari at the time of the immediate attack (including the skipper of the boat) was that part of the cargo of the bombed U.S. John Harvey was mustard gas.
Allied ammunition boat exploding during German bombing, Bari, December, 1943.Burning Allied boats, Bari harbour, December, 1943.
In the first 24 hours medical staff in Bari did not realise that the injured they were treating had been gassed. The full story did not become widely known until 1967. Of 628 hospitalised military victims suffering from mustard gas poisoning 83 were to die. It is believed the figures for those civilians who fled Bari, and subsequently died from mustard gas complications is higher.
Bari, December, 1943. Photo source: Al Saldarini, Ist CCU, from the Official Website, 450th Bomb Group Memorial Association.
The RAF command covering the Bari area though it highly unlikely that Bari would be a Luftwaffe target, believing the Luftwaffe in Italy was too thinly stretched. There were no RAF fighters based in Bari. The attack has occasionally since been referred to as a “Little Pearl Harbour”.
Mustard Gas was waiting to be unloaded as part of a potential Allied counter measure to German threats to use gas in their Italian rear-guard campaign, although the alleged German threat is disputed in some accounts. (2)
_________________________
Fig trees south of Rome
Turning to dusk, somewhere on a country road to Rome, a long, long way south of Rome, the driver of an Alfa Romeo drops Le Patron off. The earth is a terracotta colour. During the drive through olive groves and fig trees, every now and then and always suddenly, out of nowhere, a lone boy would leap out in front of the car with a fist of figs. “Fichi! Fichi!“, and just as quickly and agilely leap back as the driver flicked him to one side, driving on. It seemed a precarious and fruitless way to earn a few lire.
As Le Patron looked at his Shell filling station road map of the area he was vaguely aware of a small figure sauntering along the road towards him. He seemed to have a Dick Whittington staff slung over his shoulder, with a bundle of belongings hanging on it. As he came up Le Patron could see he was about 16. In very good English, Oxford English, he asked where Le Patron was headed for. “Rome.” “I am going to Rome too! My name is Ugo, and if we travel together we can stay in my Uncle’s flat in Rome.” Wonderful. What luck! A young Italian who knows his way around, with a relative who has a flat in Rome. It was too good to be true. In the end, that’s how it turned out to be. This was Ugo.
Le Patron never did quite work out how long he had been on the road. He was certainly travelling lightly. His technique for trying to hitch a lift was the same as the sellers of filched figs. By now it was getting dark. A set of lorry headlights approached. “I stop this, Peter” he said and threw himself into the road, waving his arms in a crossing motion. And with the agility of the fig sellers he jumped just as quickly back as the lorry bore down on him. “Son of a bitch” spat Ugo. Le Patron, a little fraught at the thought of being with this maniac until they arrived at the fabled flat in Rome, said he would try hitching the next vehicle. This suggestion had to be negotiated, as Ugo said his technique was the one that worked. He knew best. Le Patron quickly learned that with Ugo, everything – the silliest, stupidest, daftest thing had to be negotiated. Ugo always knew a better way, and couldn’t understand why you couldn’t see it. It was so clear. It was so obvious. What was your problem? And always mentioning the Uncle’s flat in Rome.
So, after a negotiation that was as frustrating and brain exploding as a UN session running into the middle of the night on a contested sub-clause, with a shrug of the shoulders Ugo finally let the Patron hitch the next vehicle.
The next vehicle stopped. Ugo said it was luck, and his method was the still the best. We were dropped off about twenty kilometres up the road, near a small camp site and we set up for the night. Le Patron had a spirit stove and soon the water was boiling and he made coffee. Having just one aluminium cup, part of a compact army type set, he offered it to Ugo who took it, sipped and, with eyes opening startlingly wide – cartoon like, as if he had been poisoned – sprayed it out at high velocity. “Ugh! That isn’t coffee!! That’s disgusting! What do you call this!”
The thing was, when he wasn’t being totally exasperating he was amusing, and sometimes interesting, particularly as a gateway into some political aspects of Italian life. Fascism, for instance.
A few days before, Le Patron had been amazed and shocked to see in a village posters advertising a forthcoming Mass commemorating the life of Benito Mussolini. Mussolini had been captured in the north, and then shot by Communist partisans on the 28th April, 1945, a few days before Hitler committed suicide. His corpse was strung up, upside down, alongside that of his mistress in the suburban square of Piazzale Loreto in Milan. Le Patron mentioned the posters to Ugo and how surprised he was.
Il Duce (The Leader) – Benito Mussolini
– “So? Mussolini was good for our country. He did great things. He was a great man”
– “But he was a fascist!”
– “And?”
– “What about Hitler? He was a fascist”
– “No, he was a National Socialist.”
Hitler & Mussolini, Florence, 1938.
– “What about Franco? He’s a fascist.”
– “Franco’s bad for his people.”
Mussolini with Papal representatives of Pope Pius XI, the Vatican, Rome, June 1929.
Slowly making our way closer to Rome over the next two days, the clincher came when, out of the blue, and in sight of Rome Ugo informed Le Patron that he would have to buy a suit – he too was going to buy a suit – if we were staying with his Uncle. A suit!
A suit would instantly pauperise Le Patron. His budget for hitching around Europe for three months was £4 a week, give or take: hard earned and hard saved money – £50 – from working on building sites as a labourer during the preceding 5 months. A bloody suit!!
Le Patron had been aware that Ugo’s pockets seemed to be sewn up all the while Le Patron and he had been together. The thought had crossed Le Patron’s mind once or twice that he was being taken for a ride. On reflection, the truth, Le Patron thought, was that this 16 year old from a middle class background was used to other family members paying his way. Papa, and Uncles. The good Italian coffee that he drank at home would be made by his mother, or grandmother, or sisters or aunts. He’d probably never made a cup of coffee in his life. And wouldn’t know how to. He would be proud that he would not how – that was not man’s work. This was Italy. His father had probably already wired his brother – the Uncle in Rome – the money for a suit and shoes, and what ever else was appropriate. Coming from this background – he didn’t get an Oxford English accent from nowhere – he would have no conception of a life lived differently, whether for a 19 year old from Britain, or a dusty Sicilian peasant with patches in the arse of his trousers.
Ugo could not understand why Le Patron could not afford to buy a suit. Rationality did not enter in Ugo’s understanding of the world or people. We were back to a late night session at the UN on a torturous sub-clause. “Basta! Basta!” Enough! Le Paton had had enough. It was time to part company, here and now, at the roadside.
Parting company was a melodramatic scene – How could I do this to him? Weren’t we friends? etc, etc, over and over again. And when that didn’t work, the reproachful look. The long reproachful look. The guilt inducing look.
_______________
Another side of Italian politics, besides Italian fascism, was Italian communism. Banned by the fascists in 1926, post 1945 the Italian communist party quickly became the largest communist party in western Europe. It was the opposition party to the catholic Christian Democracy party (Democrazia Christiana), and at various times controlled many Italian town and city administrations.
l’Unita, daily newspaper of the PCI, the Italian Communist Party, announcing the death of leader Palmiro Togliatti.
On 22 August, 1964, Le Patron saw large posters with heavy black borders suddenly appear in towns and villages. The Italian Communist Party leader Palmiro Togliatti had died on holiday in his beloved Socialist Motherland at the seaside resort of Yalta in the Soviet Union. The message was straight forward: “Togliatti È Morto“. Communist Party members would have been busy overnight, printing, distributing and pasting these posters. “Profonda emotion in Italia e nel mondo” – “Deep emotion in Italy and the world“ – the Italian communist daily paper l’Unità” claimed the day after his death. Outside Italy, apart from national communist parties and nervous strategists in the American White House, no one else would have heard of him, apart from maybe some followers of football who might have wondered if Togliatti had once played for Juventus or AC Milan.
The American strategists needn’t have worried too much about the Italian Communist Party and its leader destabilising the status quo in western Europe. Since 1945 all the Communist Parties in Western Europe were following the Moscow dictated “Democratic Road to Socialism”. No threat of revolution. In hindsight Togliatti has sometimes been criticised, within Italy, for following Moscow’s line, rather than supporting local political and industrial actions by his own communist party members.
The Italian Togliatti, a loyal supporter of the USSR, celebrated on one of their stamps.
_________________________
“The Ties that Bind”
Another part of Italy, another side of Italy, another lift. A young man, training to be a surveyor. It had been a good ride. As Le Patron gets out, he gets out too, to open the boot where Le Patron’s rucksack is. As he hands Le Patron the rucksack he asks how old Le Patron is
-“19!! How is it you can travel around like this. Don’t your parents object?”
– “No.”
He is astounded, and envious, and deeply frustrated bangs the roof of his Fiat.
– “For me it would be impossible. My Mother, she would say ‘How can you do this to me? How could you do this to your sisters? You can’t leave us! For three months?’ It would never end. It would go on and on. You are very lucky.”
It took some time before Le Patron realised that there wasn’t an absence of husbands and fathers in Italian households – they were so rarely mentioned. It was always the Mother, the Sisters, the Grandmother, the Aunties. Had there been high casualties amongst Italy’s men during the Second World War?
Italian prisoners captured by the British at Sidi Barrani, Egypt, are marched into captivity, December, 1940.
No. The answer was, of course, this was a catholic country: Mother/Madonna ruled.
Italian family life gets too much for Aurelio (Armando Brancia). Amarcord, Federico Fellini, 1973.
And the other side of the Madonna was the whore. And the Madonna/Whore polarity was stark in the South, particularly in Sicily. And in 1964 bringing shame on the family could end in an honour killing. It would be a daughter, a sister, or a wife who would bring dishonour to a family. A step down from honour killings would be ‘abductions’ and ‘kidnappings’, staged to circumvent dishonour to a family. Pietro Germi covered this particularly in his stark Sedotta e Abbandonata (Seduced and Abandoned) 1964, and in Divorzio All’Italiana (Divorce Italian Style) 1961, he shows a cynical Marcello Mastrianni using Italian law and the honour killing of his wife to marry his young niece.
Seduced and Abandoned, Pietro Germi, 1964.Seduced and Abandoned. Father (Saro Urzi) and Daughter (Stefania Sandrelli)Divorce Italian Style. Pietro Germi. 1961. Sicilian Communist Party meeting…..
Divorce Italian Style.
Marlene Dietrich, 1964. Madonna or Whore? Photo Peter Basch.
Le Patron’s planned hitch-hiking route in Italy, having crossed the Yugoslav border a few weeks before was to head for Sicily. Sicily was a potent symbol of poverty and corruption. In the Spring of 1964 he had read Danilo Dolci’s To Feed the Hungry. It had left its mark on him.
To Feed the Hungry, Danilo Dolci. UK edition, MacGibbon & Kee, 1959.
Le Patron was very ignorant about Sicily. Danilo Dolci had not mentioned Taormina in his To Feed the Hungary. Taormina was where Le Patron had been dropped off late afternoon having hitched from the port of Messina. It was an old town but buying peaches he realised something was wrong. They were double the price he had been paying elsewhere in Italy. And then he saw a poster advertising that Marlene Dietrich was playing at the local exclusive nightclub. Without knowing it, he had arrived at a favourite spot of the Med Yacht Set. The near empty campsite was on a cliff edge. Way below, in a sparkling sea – a holiday brochure blue – and so clear you could see the bottom and brightly coloured sub tropical fish, people with snorkels and flippers snorkelled, whilst in the distance Mount Etna puffed slightly threatening. Le Patron was desperately bored with the holiday brochure setting. He had come to Sicily looking for ‘authenticity’ and had ended up in a place that had as much relevance to Sicily as the English singer Cliff Richard had playing at the Sun City venue in apartheid South Africa. (Queenalso played in apartheid South Africa and their lead guitarist Brian May couldn’t see what the problem was, when they were slapped down by the U.N. and the British Musicians Union).
But Le Patron was going to have to cut his search for authenticity in Sicily, and start heading back. His finances were starting to run low.
The notion of “Authenticity” is tricky, difficult to explain, and probably shot through with dubious and naive emotion and intellectual inconsistency and sloppiness. But for Le Patron in the Italy of 1964 it meant a tiny Fiat 500 stopping when he was hitching and the bulging family inside – (there really was no room, and the occupants could probably have got into the Guinness Book of Records for how many people you can get in one car) – apologising for not being able to give him a lift and pushing a bunch of white grapes into his hands for roadside sustenance until he got a lift, and waving him goodbye as they drove off; it meant a young lad telling him to hop onto the back of his Lambretta three wheel van with deliveries to a nearby campsite, and then insisting he takes some bread and cheese and fruit from the deliveries when he arrived at the site.
Or being off the beaten track in a hilly, hot landscape in what seemed a deserted village on a slope of a hill, with noonday shadows as black as death and the light as white as phosphorous – the sort of high key lighting used in Fellini’s 8½ (1963), or that came naturally in the films shot in Sicily by Pietro Germi (Divorce Italian Style 1961, Seduced and Abandoned 1964) and by Francesco Rosi (Salvatore Giuliano, 1962).
It was an afternoon and a weekend. The street was very wide, with low, rudimentary white buildings on either side. Looking up and along the main street – the only street the village seemed to have – in the direction Le Patron would be travelling out of the place were Lombardy poplars stationed at the village cemetery and the cross and the statute of the Madonna.
There were no people, no cars passing through, not even a sleeping dog in the shadows. The prospects did not look good. And then, from nowhere, he became aware of a group of middle aged to elderly men in their weekend best dark suits, hands behind backs as they passed him in the middle of the road, some talking, some nodding. They didn’t seem to notice the stranger in their village. They continued in the direction of the cemetery. They reached the edge of the cemetery and then leisurely about turned and strolled back down again, passing Le Patron without acknowledgement.
After they disappeared from view – did they go into the village’s one bar? – Le Patron can’t remember – a middle aged woman in widow’s black was quietly standing beside him, proffering a chair, indicating with a hand gesture for him to sit on it. He smiled a thanks, she smiled back and he watched her disappear into a dark beaded open doorway behind him. After a while (two vehicles had driven along the street and not stopped) she reappeared and beckoned Le Patrol to follow her through the darkened doorway. He was immediately in a low ceilinged room and at treadle operated sewing machines – Singer sewing machines – young girls and older women were efficiently working. Another woman in widow’s black gave Le Patron a cool glass of home made lemon juice, and a small plate of home made almond biscuits, and there were smiles all around, including modest ones from the young unmarried girls. There was little attempt at talk, smiles and gestures were enough.
One of the women in widows black was concerned that I got back to the chair, with my lemon drink and almond biscuits, in case I missed a car. Le Patron can’t remember getting a lift, but he obviously did, and neither can he remember if or when the empty glass and plate was collected. And typing this, he wonders how and where the young girls are now. They would be in their mid to late sixties now. Did they vote for Berlusconi?
Silvio Berlusconi. Billionaire businessman and longest serving post war Prime Minister of Italy.
When did sewage and piped water come to their village? And Indesit washing machines, which saved them the chore of washday slapping and lathering and rubbing of clothes in the communal wash trough? How many married? How many went into a convent? How many are grandmothers? Do any still sew? Do they watch game shows on RAI, or soaps on Berlusconi’s Italia 1 channel? How many have iPhones?
And the group of men who walked up to the cemetery are now in it, six feet under.
Where was that village?
Ciao ciao bambina.
_____________________
______________________
Footnotes
1. see To Feed the Hungry, Danilo Dolci; Naples ’44, Norman Lewis.
Yes, Comrade Bwana: The British Empire and the Labour Party
Aden, 1967. Labour Government in London.A.G.Street, The Endless Furrow, 1934.
In 1947 a then popular English novelist, and farmer, A.G.Street (Farmer’s Glory, The Endless Furrow) wrote how it was that Britain came to have the largest Empire the World had ever known:
“Why were sailors from such a small nation so successful wherever they voyaged? Largely because they did not set out with any idea of conquering the world…. In their travels they landed on strange shores, where in most cases they found a state of things that offended their ideas of what was fitting for human beings. So they stayed and put it right, not so much because they wanted the job, but rather because they stumbled upon it, and felt it was up to them to do the right thing. Thus, without deliberate design they founded a great empire overseas.” (1)
The White Man’s Burden
So, according to A.G.Street, be careful where you berth your boat: you might come across people with disagreeable habits who your moral sensibility and sense of duty dictates that you and your countrymen and women spend years educating them and showing them the moral and spiritual way – a.k.a The White Man’s Burden.
Introducing the Colonies (note the boat!), a booklet produced by the British Colonial Office,1949, on the instructions of the Labour Government
The leading ‘thinkers’ of the British socialist Fabians in the late Victorian and Edwardian period – George Bernard Shaw, the Webbs and their like – believed that it would take years to bring these people with disagreeable habits up to scratch. Some like Beatrice Webb thought it was an impossible mission, that many of the “native races” would never be able to run their own affairs (even though they had been managing in their own way for centuries, before the White Man arrived).
The attitude of British Fabians was also shared and supported by British Conservatives and Liberals. In the early 1930s the local party chairman of the Conservative Duchess of Atholl’s constituency went further, advising her that democracy was not only unsuitable for ‘natives’ but also for nine tenths of the white races. (2)
The founding groups in the early twentieth century (which included the Fabians) of the British Labour Party all agreed on the benefits of the British Empire for the British working classes, such as guaranteeing jobs in the Lancashire cotton mills, or providing cheap food for the toiling classes. Before the First World War Beatrice Webb also saw the usefulness of the British Empire in mooting the idea of cleansing the slum areas in London and Manchester of their undesirable semi-criminal and idle lumpen proletariat by boating them out to the open spaces of the British Empire dominion Australia. Frederick Engels the German Manchester factory owner and co-founder of Marxist ideology would have warmed to the idea: in the nineteenth century he had described the lumpen proletariat that he observed in the Manchester area as “scum”, and both Engels and Karl Marx (who coined the term lumpen proletariat) saw this social group as a hindrance to the advance of communism.
In the second Labour Government of 1929 Beatrice Webb’s husband Sydney was appointed by Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald as Colonial Secretary. He echoed his wife’s views when he expressed his ministerial view that some of the subject colonial races would not be fit to govern themselves for at least a hundred years, mentioning, for instance the disenfranchised Empire subjects of Kenya.
Beatrice and Sidney Webb. Keir Hardie, Socialist and Christian lay preacher
The “internationalist” and leading member of the ILP (Independent Labour Party), and evangelical lay preacher, Keir Hardie , was one of the prime movers for the establishment of the British Labour Party. Despite his enlightened reputation (support for the cause of India and woman’s suffrage, and opposed to the colour bar in South Africa) he didn’t extend his internationalist or Christian outlook to Lithuanian workers, let alone – when it came down to it – the “native races” of the British Empire, who, disenfranchised, were digging out diamonds in South Africa, planting cotton in India, picking tea in Ceylon (Sri Lanka) and cutting sugar cane in the West Indies. His internationalism stopped at the English-Scottish border and the Port of Leith.
“Keir Hardie, in his evidence to the 1899 House of Commons Select Committee on emigration and immigration, argued that the Scots resented immigrants greatly and that they would want a total immigration ban. When it was pointed out to him that more people left Scotland than entered it, he replied:
‘It would be much better for Scotland if those 1,500 were compelled to remain there and let the foreigners be kept out… Dr Johnson said God made Scotland for Scotchmen, and I would keep it so.’ According to Hardie, the Lithuanian migrant workers in the mining industry had “filthy habits”, they lived off “garlic and oil”, and they were carriers of “the Black Death”.”
______________
“The first Independent Labour Party MP (Keir Hardie) blamed immigrants for driving down wages of Scottish workers and he accused them of stealing and being dirty. In an article written for the journal The Miner in 1887, he criticised the owners of the local Glengarnock ironworks for using “Russian Poles”. He said: “What object they have in doing so is beyond human ken unless it is, as stated by a speaker at Irvine, to teach men how to live on garlic and oil, or introduce the Black Death, so as to get rid of the surplus labourers.” (2)
The German left revolutionaries Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels were blunt in their mid nineteenth century assessments about the native races of the world, whether in Africa or China: “savages” they called them. They also regarded some of the European races – Slavs and Celts – as untermenschen, who were part of the problem, and not the solution, and in the case of the Celts believed they would need to perish in the Final Solution. Even the French as a race were a bit suspect in their eyes, saved only by the fact that they had subjugated the “native races” in North Africa. The race that met their ideal as torchbearers of the new communist movement (as determined by Marx’s crystal ball gazing which he labelled ‘historical materialism’) were their own race: the Germans. Anglo Saxon and similar Aryan races were also considered by them as torchbearers for the reordering of the class world. (3)
Robert Blatchford, author of Merrie England.
The attitude of Marx and Engels was a geological strata that ran through all socialists, whether Marxist revolutionary, 0r social democratic – and usually Christian – socialist in the Western world.
Two left of centre Englishmen who unusually and fairly uniquely didn’t share this view of “native races” within the British Empire were Robert Blatchford (1851 – 1943) and George Orwell (1903 – 1950). And for different reasons the two also didn’t support the British Empire. A third English socialist who went on to campaign for the rights of British Empire disenfranchised colonial “subjects” was Fenner Brockway, another early member of the I.L.P. (1888 – 1988).
Fenner Brockway, 1930. Born in Calcutta, India, son of British Empire missionaries.
In general, the rest of the Labour Movement and the Labour Party into the early 1950s were positive about the British Empire, and had a low view of many of the Empire’s subjects. Martin Pugh in his Speak for Britain!: A New History of the Labour Party (2010) mentions that the Smethwick Labour Club in the English Midlands was still operating a “colour bar” in 1964.
George Orwell, 1946. Photo Vernon Richards.
George Orwell knew the British Empire from the inside. Between 1923 and 1927 he was an Imperial Policeman in Burma (Myanmar). His first published novel Burmese Days (1934) and his two short pieces A Hanging (1931) and Shooting an Elephant (1936) takes a scalpel to the belly of British Imperialism. In Burmese Days there are echoes of the near halugenic quality of the Frenchman’s Louis Ferdinand Celine’s descriptions of being in French West Africa at a similar time just after the First World War, written in his Journey to the End of Night.
Like Robert Blatchford, who was in the British Army between 1871 and 1878, and rose to be a sergeant, George Orwell was often out of sympathy with his fellow socialists. Both were independent thinkers. In a July 1939 review of a now forgotten book Union Now by the American Clarence K. Streit, Orwell highlights bogus and hypocritical aspects of the European democracies such as France and Britain rationalising their alignment against the totalitarianism of Nazism.
“In a prosperous country, above all in an imperialist country, left-wing politics are always partly humbug…… One threat to the Suez Canal and ‘anti-fascism’ and ‘defence of British interests’ are discovered to be identical……
Like everyone of his school of thought, Mr Streit has cooly lumped the huge British and French Empires – in essence nothing but mechanisms for exploiting cheap coloured labour – under the heading of democracies!…..
The British and French empires with their six hundred million disenfranchised human beings….
……. What we always forget is that the overwhelming bulk of the British proletariat does not live in Britain, but in Asia and Africa.” (4)
__________________________
Royal Australian Airforce Avro Lincoln bombing Insurgent targets in the Malayan jungle, 1950. Labour Government in power in London.
At the start of the Malayan ‘Emergency’ Queen Elizabeth II’s Dad was the Head Honcho
________________
“Some talk about the Empire and Imperialism as if it were something to decry and something to be ashamed of. It is a great thing to be the inheritors of an Empire like ours … great in territory, great in potential wealth. … If we can only realise and use that potential wealth we can destroy thereby poverty, we can remove and destroy ignorance.” – Suffragette leader and I.L.P member Emmeline Pankhurst.
There was nothing “potential” about the wealth being generated within the British Empire, whether before the First World War or after the Second World war. The wealth was there. The Labour Government of Clement Attlee (1945 – 1951) used conscripted troops to maintain the status quo in Malaya, and maintain the output of valuable tin and rubber. Seemingly the Malayan War was termed an “Emergency” at the request of owners of tin mines and rubber plantations. That way they could claim any losses with insurers Lloyds in London, whereas their claims would be null and void if the country was officially at war. This manoeuvre seems to have acted as a template also for Kenya, Cyprus and Aden, for instance.
Mau Mau suspects, Kenya.
Cyprus
Malaya
Aden
The quote above from the leading suffragette Emmeline Pankhurst about using the wealth of the British Empire to destroy poverty and remove ignorance is, without knowing the context in which she was speaking, ambivalent. Did she mean destroying poverty through cheap food and goods imported for the British working classes from the Empire? And in removing ignorance, was she referring to the natives of the Empire? There were many white Christian evangelists sweating under the Tropical skies of the British Empire who were precisely doing that: working on morally and spiritually uplifting the native. Fenner Brockway’s parents worked as missionaries in India, and sent the young Fenner to a Missionary Boarding School in England. Did his missionary parents, bracing their shoulders for the weight of the White Man’s (and Woman’s Burden) know that Christianity first came to the Indian sub-continent when their European antecedents were still pagans?
Missionary and evangelical zeal were to be found everywhere, including within the Labour Party. Besides Labour Party founder Keir Hardy, prominent Labour and Coop activist, and later Labour minister, and Minister within Churchill’s coalition wartime government A.V.Alexander remained an active protestant evangelist to the end of his life in 1965.
For him the benefits of the British Empire was mitigating the poverty and removing the ignorance of the British working class, through cheap food and welfare provision. This view was shared by trade unions leaders, later to be Labour Government ministers, such as Jimmy Thomas and Ernest Bevin. There was nothing unusual in their views within the Labour Party and Trade Union movement.
When the Labour Party was overwhelmingly returned to power in 1945 there had been nothing in its Election Manifesto about introducing self-government in the colonies, with the exception of India. It is said that Ernest Bevin, Foreign Secretary in the Labour Government, justified this by saying the loss of the colonies would mean falling living standards for British people. (The post war Labour Government saddled a near bankrupt nation with the secret development and massive spending on an atomic bomb, which meant imposing rationing of bread, never rationed during the siege economy caused by the Second World War.)
The list of British Empire Colonies run by the Labour Government in 1949. From Introducing the Colonies, Colonial Office/HMSO 1949.
In general it was only in the early 1950s that some in the Labour Party would start to think about, and agree with Fenner Brockway’s views on disenfranchised British subjects. There were, and had been other voices, of course:
Attitude to Africa by W.Arthur Lewis, Michael Scott, Martin Wight & Colin Legum. Penguin Books, 1951.
In 1954 along with others, Fenner Brockway founded the British based Movement for Colonial Freedom .
But of course the work of freeing the “native subjects” was done by themselves.
In the 1950s period of the Labour Party being in opposition, under their leader Hugh Gaitskell, it is difficult to get an idea of whether the Party had started to move, in terms of official Party policies, to the acceptance of self-determination for disenfranchised British colonial subjects. Most of the histories of that Labour Party period concentrate on the wrangles over the Clause Four nationalisation commitment, and unilateral nuclear disarmament, and their failure to win the 1959 General Election.
Labour Party opposition leader Hugh Gaitskell
It was the Conservative Prime Minister Harold Macmillan in 1960 who coined the term and accepted that there was a “Wind of Change” blowing through the British Empire, and particularly in Africa. Remarkably, he was the first British Prime Minister ever to visit the British Colonies in Africa.
British Prime Minister Harold MacMillan with, left, Roy Welensky, Prime Minister of the Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasland, Salisbury (Harare), 1960.
He had been visiting African colonies for a month on a ‘fact finding’ mission when he gave his speech in the heartland of white supremacy sentiment and practice: South Africa. He made the speech to members of the South African parliament in Cape Town on 3 February, 1960.
“In the twentieth century, and especially since the end of the war, the processes which gave birth to the nation states of Europe have been repeated all over the world. We have seen the awakening of national consciousness in peoples who have for centuries lived in dependence upon some other power. Fifteen years ago this movement spread through Asia. Many countries there, of different races and civilisations, pressed their claim to an independent national life.
Today the same thing is happening in Africa, and the most striking of all the impressions I have formed since I left London a month ago is of the strength of this African national consciousness. In different places it takes different forms, but it is happening everywhere.
The wind of change is blowing through this continent, and whether we like it or not, this growth of national consciousness is a political fact. We must all accept it as a fact, and our national policies must take account of it…….
……. As a fellow member of the Commonwealth it is our earnest desire to give South Africa our support and encouragement, but I hope you won’t mind my saying frankly that there are some aspects of your policies which make it impossible for us to do this without being false to our own deep convictions about the political destinies of free men to which in our own territories we are trying to give effect.”
The speech was met with contempt and hostility from the bulk of the white Dutch descended Afrikaner community in South Africa, and with alarm amongst the white politicians and settlers of the East African colonies. He had already given a similar speech, less reported, in Accra, the Gold Coast (Ghana) the month before, on 10 January, 1960.
In the 1960s the Labour Party had too accepted that self-rule (where desired) in the colonies was inevitable. However, like the Conservative Party there were some areas that had a strategic defence interest (docks, airfields, army logistics) that they were loath to relinquish too quickly: Malta, Cyprus and Aden, for instance.
And security and strategic concerns (often in conjunction with the United States) continued to effect ‘native’ populations in scattered colonies: Easter Island in the Pacific Ocean, for instance. Part of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands, it and associated scattered islands are now known as the Republic of Kirbati, becoming independent in 1979.
The forced depopulation of Diego Garcia (part of the British Indian Ocean Territory) in the Indian Ocean to make way for a United States base began in 1968 (Harold Wilson Labour Prime Minister) and was completed in 1973. The permanency of the depopulation was effectively sealed when the Labour Government of Prime Minister Gordon Brown secretly proposed in leaked documents from 2009 to make the area a Marine Conservation area. (5)
So, Darkie Comrades, watch your step. Socialist Internationalism for the British Labour Party stops at the Port of Dover.
Oh, and yes, nearly forgot:
p.s. Fraternal Greetings.
______________________________________________
Footnotes
A.G.Street shared his views on the British Empire in his introduction to the Odhams Press book England Today in Pictures. Odhams Press was a large publisher of popular photo based books, encyclopaedias, popular histories, DIY related reference and tutorial books etc. It was also the publisher and majority share holder, from 1931, of the British Labour Party’s Daily Herald.
Quoted in Hurrah for the Blackshirts: Fascists and Fascism in Britain Between the Wars, Martin Pugh, 2005.
Keir Hardie quotes are from several sources, including scottishmining.co.uk and Wikipedia.
see The Social and Racial Characteristics of…. in Recent Posts.
Not Counting Niggers, July 1939. Orwell: Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters Volume 1.
“According to leaked diplomatic cables obtained by Wikileaks and released in 2010, in a calculated move in 2009 to prevent re-settlement of the BIOT by native Chagossians, the UK proposed that the BIOT become a “marine reserve” with the aim of preventing the former inhabitants from returning to their lands. The summary of the diplomatic cable is as follows : HMG would like to establish a “marine park” or “reserve” providing comprehensive environmental protection to the reefs and waters of the British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT), a senior Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) official informed Polcouns on May 12. The official insisted that the establishment of a marine park — the world’s largest — would in no way impinge on USG use of the BIOT, including Diego Garcia, for military purposes. He agreed that the UK and U.S. should carefully negotiate the details of the marine reserve to assure that U.S. interests were safeguarded and the strategic value of BIOT was upheld. He said that the BIOT’s former inhabitants would find it difficult, if not impossible, to pursue their claim for resettlement on the islands if the entire Chagos Archipelago were a marine reserve.” (This material quoted in Wikipedia)
Postcards to Mrs Pye is part of the “Occasional Postcards” series.
Sporthotel, Igls, Austria. 1961.
Mrs Pye, along with Mr Pye, lived in Brandville Gardens, Ilford, Essex, nine miles to the east of London.
In the late 1950s, when this small collection of postcards starts, Ilford was still part of the county of Essex.
Manor Road, Ilford, 1955.
By the end of 1965, when the last postcard in this collection was sent to Mrs Pye, Ilford was no longer in Essex. It had been absorbed into Greater London.
Package holidays to continental Europe from the UK didn’t, literally, take off in a big way until the mid 1960s.
Package Holidays about to take off: Euravia.Package Holidays about to take off: Britannia.
It took a bit of money, and a bit of initiative, even if booking through Thomas Cook & Co to travel and stay in Paris, or Switzerland or Italy before the mid 1960s. These Technicolour countries of wine, street markets and foreign sights and smells and customs were usually glimpsed in films such as the 1955 David Lean directed Summertime with Katherine Hepburn falling in love in Venice.
Or Paris with Gene Kelly in the 1951 An American in Paris.
A free-wheeling Gene Kelly in Paris… well, in a Hollywood studio set, but the establishing ‘shot on location’ shots gave an authentic taste.
And then there were the saturated Kodachrome pages of National Geographic magazine in the 1950s that in between head hunters in Borneo would feature a spread of the castles and steep vineyards from the perspective of a Rhine cruise boat.
In the postcards that follow, the house number of the Pyes in Brandville Gardens has been brushed out to protect the privacy of the present occupants.
________________
1958
“Lovely little village with beautiful walks all round…..”
____________________
“Arrived here 1.30 pm… after delayed journey due to London train being late… and missing our connection at Paris!…. Plenty of sunshine and not excessive heat.”
_________________
“The more I see of Paris the more I like it….Can find my way easily on the Metro now….Have taken Valerie up the Eiffel Tower…. she is thrilled with it all.”
_________________
1961
“Weather still “scorcher” although had 3 short thunderstorms. Tonight, hundreds of bonfires burning on mountain tops to celebrate mid summer’s day…..”
_____________
1962
“We are going on this little railway this afternoon…. “
____________
“We are enjoying a lovely holiday & think Lauterbrunnen a delightful spot… “
________________
1963
“… We have had several drives through the forest of Xmas trees. Yesterday we had a barbecue picnic in the Jura mountains We collected our own wood, made a fire & roasted our meat. Grand fun… “
_____________________
1965
“We left Luxembourg yesterday having spent 5 days with my cousin and family… Greetings to all the grand girls.”
___________________
For the British, travelling abroad has changed tremendously since the 40 or so years since the postcard from Aachen was sent to Mrs Pye at Brandville Gardens, Ilford. Countries and continents that were exotic, and unreachable for millions are now one cheap flight away. In 2015 Majorca and Tenerife were the most popular holiday destinations for the British, followed by the Algarve, Ibiza, Lanzarote, Orlando in the Unites States, Gran Canaria, Benidorm, Crete in Greece and Disneyland Paris. Snapping on their tails are developing tourist hotspots in Turkey. The top five countries for holidays by the British, in order, were Spain, Greece, the US, Portugal and Italy.
Remarkably, London, nine miles from Ilford, is now the most tourist visited City in the World, according to the annual Master Card Global Destinations Cities survey. The Top Four visited cities in 2015 were, in order: 1. London, 2. Bangkok, 3. Paris and 4. Dubai.
But some things don’t change. Lauterbrunnen in Switzerland is still regularly visited and is very much as it was in 1962….
Above Lauterbrunnen, October, 2008. Photo Pete Grafton.
……and the Sporthotel in Igls, Austria is still there, still run by the same family, the Becks.
Sporthotel, Igls.
Different motors, though….
_________________
The small collection of postcards to Mrs Pye sent between 1958 and 1965 were found in a bric-a-brac shop in Exeter in 2014.
__________________
Next in the Occasional Postcards series: Postcard from the Eastern Front, due Winter 2016 – 2017.
Michael from Shadwell, East London. Photo Hans Richard Griebe.
London Bobby, The City Photo Hans Richard GriebeWomen, Regent Street. Photo Hans Richard Griebe.Three Coins in the Fountain and Three Squaddies . Photo Hans Richard Griebe.Girl in the crowd, Emperor Haile Selassie State Visit, 1954. Photo Hans Richard Griebe.London Bobby, Oxford Street. Photo Hans Richard Griebe.
Photographs taken in London by Hans Richard Griebe of Kiel between August and October in 1954. The link is here: londontown54.com
Former anarchist agitator Danny Cohn-Bendit, left and Agit-Prop Marxist film maker Jean- Luc Godard on the cover of Télérama, May, 2010. These days Godard has swapped his proletarian Gauloises for the plutocrat cigar. Now let’s see that again:
and again…..
and…..
Whoops, something’s not quite right. So back to the magazine:
and now the advertisement for the magazine in the Anver Metro station, Paris, May, 2010:
Où est Le Cigare?
___________________
Danny Cohn-Bendit, 1968.Jean-Luc Godard, 1960s
The anarchist of the 1960s, Danny Cohn-Bendit is a child of upper class parents.
The Marxist film maker, and Maoist (1968 – 1980) Jean-Luc Godard is also a child of upper class parents – very wealthy parents at that. His grandfather on his mother’s side was the founder of the Banque Paribas, now BNP Parabis that almost went under in 2015 and was restructured. The group describe themselves as “Global Corporate and Institutional Banking and Retail Banking and Services”.
Le Patron would not normally draw attention to their background were it not for the contempt that Cohn-Bendit and Godard have shown for their own class. In Soviet propaganda terms, or in a Moscow Pravda editorial they would themselves be described as classic “spawn of the bourgeoisie.”
For a while “Red Danny” (Cohn-Bendit) was almost as much a pin-up as Che Guevera. A recent news item (December 2015) that claimed Cohn-Bendit had, at age 70, got married, prompted broken hearted responses from would be suitors. They can recover their composure: it seems the story is untrue.
Cohn-Bendit became one of the photographic images of the May Days in Paris, and his fame was cemented as much by government supporting opponents highlighting the German origin of his family, and his Jewish background. The May, 1968 students took up the chant Nous sommes tous des Juifs allemande – ‘We are all German Jews’. The chanting didn’t prevent him being expelled from France as a “seditious alien” on 22 May, 1968.
During the 70s, initially living in the family home in Germany, he continued to be involved in the ‘movement’: working in the Karl Marx Buchandlung bookshop in Frankfurt. As most anarchists regard Karl Marx in the same way a Primitive Methodist would regard the Pope, it seems his theoretical ‘position’ was in flux.
He also worked as a member of a ‘radical’ nursery. He got a lot of erotic pleasure being with five and six year olds and wrote about it in Le Grande Bazar (1975), talking about engaging in sexual activities with the young children. The German Green Party into the 1980s had a tolerant attitude to paedophilia. Since then Cohn-Bendit has unconvincingly excused himself by saying he was being ‘deliberately provocative’ in La Grand Bazar. If so – to what end? To upset the ‘bourgeoisie’? To stay in the spotlight?
Staying in the spotlight seems to be his emotional need. It’s a Lights, Camera, Action scenario, whether on the Paris boulevards, or on a confrontation with a Czech president. And where ever he is, he is sure to make sure the media knows where he is, and are briefed to what he is going to say and do. His greatest love is himself. His website features the toddler Danny, Danny the boy, Danny the teenager, Danny the young activist. If he was in the nursery, instead of an adult having erotic feelings about a five year old, and was a child, a five year old, he’d be the one elbowing the other kids out of the way pushing himself to the front if the local media were visiting, or on a daily basis creating an upset to get attention.
In the late 1970s Federal German melting pot of opposition to nuclear power stations and other ‘green issues’ Cohn-Bendit was drawn into the movement that would eventually result in the emergence of the Green Party in Germany.
________________
The film maker Jean Luc Godard who had had a left sentiment prior to 1968 went the whole horrible hog and stuck his colours to Chairman Mao, at a time of appalling repression in the People’s Democratic Republic of China. This grotesque manifestation at this time effected some others in the ‘Arts’ in the West, particularly the performing arts.
Re-education on the land: Xinsheng commune, Qingan county, 4 November 1969. Photo Li Zhensheng, from Red-Colour News Soldier.
If Godard had been in China in 1969 given his class background he would have found himself being ‘re-educated’: forcibly sent to work on the land. He would be getting off lightly. Other perceived enemies of the People’s Democratic Republic got shot.
Photos Li Zhensheng, from Red-Colour News Soldier. ( 1.)
During the period of his support of Chairman Mao he denounced his former cameraman Raoul Coutard for being the cinematographer on a film that had American company backing. Raoul Coutard was one of the best things about watching Godard’s films in the early to mid sixties, for instance Pierrot Le Fou (1965). This was gesture, megaphone politics at its worst. (Is there any other kind?)
Cohn-Bendit, megaphone operative. May, 1968.Cohn-Bendit, 2010, supporter of the E.U. bureaucracy.
In August 1968 when Soviet Pact forces invaded Czechoslovakia, Cohn-Bendit was selling Lenin’s Left-Wing Communism, an Infantile Disorder in the Frankfurt bookshop, and Jean-Luc Godard was reading the Maoist People’s Cause in Paris.
An estimated 200,000 troops and 2,000 tanks (a higher figure of 5,000 tanks is sometimes quoted) invaded Czechoslovakia on the night of 20 August, 1968. It was the largest use of military force against a European country since the end of the Second World War, even exceeding the Soviet military force that invaded Hungary in 1956. The crime that Czechoslovakia had committed? To have a little bit of what citizens (including Cohn-Bendit and Godard) in Western Europe took for granted: the freedom to travel, freedom to express oneself, without being imprisoned, or having your passport taken away, or your children being prohibited from going to college. (Or in Mao’s China, being shot.)
‘A protestor holds a blood stained Czechoslovakian flag in front of a Soviet tank.’ Photo source Czech Press Agency archive.
The loosening of the Marxist straight jacket had started under Alexander Dubček when he was elected First Secretary of the Czechoslovakian Communist Party. Although he wanted the Czech Communist Party to be firmly in control of the State and the reforms – the economy was in a mess – the enthusiasm in the country for the change of direction was endangering the rule of the Communist Party. Dubček was reluctant to use force to reinforce the central role of the Communist Party. It was this that alarmed Moscow. The period was known as the Prague Spring. The winter came early, in August.
‘Protestors throw stones at the Soviet tanks entering Prague’. Photo source Czech Press Agency archive.
photo Josef Koudelka (2.)photo Josef Koudelka.‘Soviet tanks are surrounded by crowds of Czechs protesting against the invasion on Prague’s Wenceslas Square, August 21.’ Photo source Czech Press Agency archive.‘Soviet soldiers try to extinguish a burning tank set on fire by protestors near the Czechoslovak Radio headquarters in Prague.’ Photo source Czech Press Agency archive.
At Radio Prague, journalists refused to give up the station and twenty people were killed before it was captured by the occupying force. It is estimated that a further 100 protesting Czechoslovakians were killed by the occupying forces, upholding the power of Marxist-Leninists to continue the building of the Workers Utopia, not just in Czechoslavakia, but in the rest of central and eastern Europe and the Baltic. As late as 1980 the Central Committee of the German Democratic Republic (East German) were urging fellow Warsaw pact members to use military force to invade Poland and put down the Solidarity movement.
Protester confronts Soviet Tank, morning of 21 August, 1968. Main Square, Bratislava, Slovakia. photo Ladislav Bielik
Whilst Jean-Luc Godard remained committed to the Mao-ist version of Marxist Leninism, and Cohn-Bendit worked in the Karl Marx Buchandlung, the negatives of the photographs that Czech photographer Josef Koudelka took of the Soviet invasion were smuggled out of the country, and published anonymously in the British Sunday Times.
photo Josef Koudelka
Unaware that Josef Koudelka was the photographer who took the invasion photos, the Czechoslovakian authorities allowed him to travel to England on a 3 month working visa issued by the British government. Once there he applied for and was granted political asylum.
Czechoslovakian New Wave film directors and scriptwriters, such as Milos Forman (Loves of a Blonde, and The Firemens Ball) and Ivan Passer (Intimate Lighting) managed to escape to the West. (Foreman happened to be in Paris when the Soviets invaded.) The director of the Academy Award winning Closely Observed Trains, Jiri Menzel, was not so lucky. During 1968 and early 1969 he was shooting Larks on a String, set in a Stalin era industrial scrapyard where the male and female civil and political prisoners were forced to work, and lived in overcrowded, barbed wire surrounded huts. This was no political allegory. This was the reality of 1950s Czechoslovakia.
Larks on a String, Jiri Menzel, 1969.
Larks on a String, Jiri Menzel, 1969.
Film director Jiri Menzel, circa 1968. (3.)
Larks on a String, Jiri Menzel, 1969
Once the film was completed it was immediately banned, and was not seen until 1990, following the collapse of the Communist regime. In an interview recorded for the DVD release of Larks on a String Jiri Menzel said he was not able to leave the country – his passport had been taken away from him.
It was five years before he made another film, and seven years before he made Seclusion Near a Wood (1976). In 1985 My Sweet Little Village was released. These post Prague Spring years were the years of “Normalisation” as the Communist Central Committee, with First Secretary Gustáv Husák at the helm, called it.
Normal. Ostrava, 1974. Photo Viktor Kolár (4.)The years of ‘Normalisation’. Ostrava, 1984. photo Viktor Kolár.My Sweet Little Village, 1985. Jeri Menzil.
The Czech photographer Viktor Kolár covertly photographed the years of “Normalisation” in the industrial city of Ostrava, and the surrounding area, whilst earning a living, at one point, working as a labourer in the Nová Hut’ steelworks.
Jeri Menzil’s My Sweet Little Village still remains one of the Czech and Slovak Republic’s favourite films. Menzil had the ability, almost in a Good Soldier Švejk way in the period of “Normalisation” to get one past the authorities, by re-affirming what is best about being human. Both My Sweet Little Village and Seclusion Near a Wood are loving, and sometimes rye observations of human inter-action, irrespective of the political background of the time, typical of all his films from Closely Observed Trains onwards. It is an approach that Jean-Luc Godard would, at best, not understand, and at worst would dismiss as either ‘bourgeois’ sentimentality or of ‘not facing reality’.
The writer on Film, Ray Durgnat, said about Godard in 1967: “Godard keeps babbling on about the world being absurd because he can’t keep an intellectual hard on long enough to probe for any responsive warmth”.
Durgnat said a lot of pungent and insightful things about Godard in the essay the quote comes from Asides on Godard, in The Films of Jean-Luc Godard, Studio Vista 1967. As much as Le Patron likes Ray Durgnat’s writing, in this instance it isn’t intellect you need for responsive warmth, but an open heart. Godard’s shrivelled damaged little heart naturally leapt, a year later, into the sloganising Marxist-Leninist-Maoist rhetoric, where he found a sense of purpose, and with equally sloganising people, a sense of belonging. Despite supporting a Maoist paper called The People’s Cause, he (and the paper) had no understanding of ‘The People’ and loathed and rejected just about everything they, the people, enjoyed.
Theses days Godard is no longer a Maoist, but still identifies himself as a Marxist.
These days Danny Cohn-Bendit has travelled a long way from being a part player in Parisian street theatre. In the journey the anarchist ideal of a bottom up democracy has been replaced by a top down authoritarianism. Benito Mussolini took a similar journey, from Italian anarcho-syndicalism to the fascist corporate state. The journey that Cohn-Bendit embarked on in 1968 led to a grotesque position – equal to Godard becoming a Maoist – when, with other European MEPs he travelled in December, 2008 to Prague to meet and berate the Czech President Václav Klaus. More of this in a moment, but first some details to where he had arrived at in the 1990s and beyond.
In 1994 he became a Green MEP in the European Parliament, and has remained one since. He is a significant politician within the French and German Green movements, and his belief in the necessity of the European Union to force policies – environmental policies, for instance – on member states is authoritarian. In 2003 during the Convention that was preparing the text of the European constitution – which was to become known as the Lisbon Treaty – he demanded that EU member countries who voted No in referendums to the conditions of the constitution should be forced to hold a second referendum. If the result was still No, then those countries should be expelled from the E.U. The planned constitution (The Lisbon Treaty) was rejected by French and Dutch voters in 2005. Irish voters rejected it in June 2008, but accepted it in a second referendum in October 2009.
There are some significant differences between the Green Parties in Europe. The German Green Party, for instance, approved the rejection of Scottish Independence by voters in the 2014 Scottish Referendum on the question, at odds with the pro-independence position of the Green Party in Scotland. And although the Czech writer, dissident, thinker, and Czech President (1993 – 2003) Václav Havel supported the Czech Green Party from 2004, he remained committed to Direct Democracy, even though some Green Parties stance on environmental matters is authoritarian. A clash in democratic approaches resulted in Cohn-Bendit resigning from the French Greens. More of that in a moment.
______________
At the invitation of the then Czech President Váklav Klaus a group of MEPs who were members of the “Conference of Presidents of the European Parliament” flew to Prague on 5 December, 2008. To put what happened when they got there in a context, imagine any other President of an autonomous European nation – say Mary Robinson, President of the Republic of Ireland between 1990 and 1997 – getting this kind of drubbing from visiting politicians from Brussels.
Christopher Booker wrote about the extraordinary meeting for the British Daily Telegraph on 14 December, 2008.
“There was…… a remarkable recent meeting between the heads of the groups in the European Parliament and Václav Klaus, the Czech head of state, in his palace in Hradcany Castle, on a hill overlooking Prague. The aim was to discuss how the Czechs should handle the EU’s rotating six-monthly presidency when they take over from France on January 1.
The EU’s ruling elite view President Klaus…. with a mixture of bewilderment, hatred and contempt. As his country’s prime minister, he applied to join the EU in the days after the fall of Communism in the 1990s. But now Klaus is alone among European leaders in expressing openly Eurosceptic views, not least about the Lisbon Treaty, which the Czech parliament has yet to ratify.
Klaus was an outspoken dissident under the Communist regime, and he has come to regard the EU as dangerously anti-democratic. But he compounds this sin with highly sceptical views on global warming, on which he recently published a book, Blue Planet in Green Shackles…….
So when Klaus was due to meet the MEPs, one of them decided this was a moment to display the Euro-elite’s hostility to him. Daniel Cohn-Bendit, who is German born but lives in France, first came to prominence in Paris in 1968 as a student agitator. He is now leader of the Green MEPs. Talking loudly in the plane to Prague, he made no secret of his intentions, and briefed French journalists on how to get maximum publicity for his planned insults.
As Cohn-Bendit was aware, the only flag that flies over the castle is the presidential standard (though the “ring of stars” is much in evidence elsewhere in Prague, flown outside every government ministry).
As described to me by someone present, President Klaus greeted the MEPs with his usual genial courtesy. Whatever his own views, he assured them, his countrymen would conduct their presidency in fully “communautaire” fashion. (Communautaire: supporter of the principles of the European Community.)
Cohn-Bendit then staged his ambush. Brusquely plonking down his EU flag, which he observed sarcastically was so much in evidence around the palace. (Le Patron: News reports from many sources said that Cohn-Bendit went on to say that the European Flag should have been flying from the Presidential palace.)
(Cohn-Bendit) warned that the Czechs would be expected to put through the EU’s “climate change package” without interference. “You can believe what you want,” he scornfully told the president, “but I don’t believe, I know that global warming is a reality.” He added, “my view is based on scientific views and the majority approval of the EU Parliament”.
He then moved on to the Lisbon Treaty. “I don’t care about your opinions on it,” he said. If the Czech Parliament approves the treaty in February, he demanded, “Will you respect the will of the representatives of the people?”
He then reprimanded the president for his recent meeting in Ireland with Declan Ganley, the millionaire leader of the “No” campaign in the Irish referendum, claiming that it was improper for Klaus to have talked to someone whose “finances come from problematic sources”.
Visibly taken aback by this onslaught, Klaus observed: “I must say that no one has talked to me in such a style and tone in the past six years. You are not on the barricades in Paris here. I thought that such manners ended for us 19 years ago” (i.e when Communism fell). When Klaus suggested to Hans-Gert Pöttering, the president of the EU Parliament, who was present, that perhaps it was time for someone else to take the floor, Pöttering replied that “anyone from the members of the Parliament can ask you what he likes”, and invited Cohn-Bendit to continue.
“This is incredible, said Klaus. “I have never experienced anything like this before.”
After a further exchange, in which Cohn-Bendit compared Klaus unfavourably with his predecessor, President Hável, he gave way to an Irish MEP, Brian Crowley, who began by saying “all his life my father fought against the British domination [of Ireland]… That is why I dare to say that the Irish wish for the Lisbon Treaty. It was an insult, Mr President, to me and the Irish people what you said during your state visit to Ireland.” Klaus repeated that he had not experienced anything like this for 19 years and that it seemed we were no longer living in a democracy, but that it was “post-democracy which rules the EU”.
On the EU constitution, Klaus recalled that three countries had voted against it, and that if Mr Crowley wanted to talk about insults to the Irish people, “the biggest insult to the Irish people is not to accept the result of the Irish referendum”…..
Everntually Pöttering closed the meeting by saying that he wanted to leave the room “in good terms”, but it was quite unacceptable to compare himself and his colleagues with the Soviet Union. Klaus replied that he had not mentioned the Soviet Union: “I only said that I had not experienced such an atmosphere, such a style of debate, in the Czech Republic in the last 19 years.”
Czech Communist Secret Service (StB) surveillance files on future Czech President Váklav Klaus. Source Radio Praha. (Radio Prague.)
The hectoring nature of the meeting was reported in Czech media, and was a news item throughout the former Communist Eastern Bloc countries. It is reported that across all political sentiments in the Czech republic the reaction was similar: that the comments of Cohn-Bendit and the other MEPs was an “undue interference in Czech affairs”. The MEP and the leader of the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) Nigel Farage went further and compared Cohn-Bendit’s actions to a “German official from seventy years ago or a Soviet official from twenty years ago.”
______________
Cohn-Bendit’s contempt for democratic processes continues.
French Greens’ Cohn-Bendit quits party in fiscal Pact row.
European lawmaker Daniel Cohn-Bendit revoked his membership of the French Greens on Sunday (23 September) in protest at the party’s decision to oppose the ratification of the European Union’s budget discipline pact.
The move threatens to rob the Europe-Écologie Party of one of its most recognisable deputies – known for his rabble-rousing during 1968 student riots in Paris – and may exacerbate tensions within the group, which supports France’s Socialist-led government and has two ministerial posts.
The French Greens voted overwhelmingly against the terms of the pact at a grassroots assembly on Saturday, concluding that it would not provide long-term answers to the EU crisis nor help foster environmentally friendly policies.
France is expected to ratify the pact early next month, though a major revolt within the coalition could force the Socialists into an embarrassing reliance on the conservative opposition.
“Yesterday’s federal council was dramatic. Dramatically pathetic,” Cohn-Bendit told French television station i-Tele.
“I’ve decided to suspend my participation in this movement. It’s clear to me that deep down, things are finished between me and Europe-Ecologie.”
Cohn-Bendit said the French Green party’s position on the fiscal treaty was “completely inconsistent” arguing that the party should pull out of the French government and vote against the budget.
“I don’t want to endorse this leftist policy drift,” the Franco-German MEP further went on.
Cohn-Bendit, nicknamed “Danny the Red” for his student activism, has served as deputy for French Green parties since 1999 and is co-president of the European Parliament’s Greens group.
– Reuters, 24 September, 2012.
Just in case you missed it: it was a collective decision taken by a meeting of grassroots members. Paris, ’68 anyone?
______________
And, oh yes, that Disappearing Cigar.
It’s marvellous what you can do with Photoshop. Not only remove the cigar, but reposition the fingers. In France 2010 it was not permitted for advertising posters in public places to even inadvertently include cigarettes, cigars – (and goodness knows what has happened to Maigret’s pipe). Cohn-Bendit the Green politician would not have a problem with the Photoshopping out of his pal’s cigar. And Godard, like Cohn-Bendit is happy to comply with the distortion. He is, after all, promoting the product: himself. Anyway, as a Marxist who probably knows his Russian Revolution history, he will know that anything that offends the ruling elite gets removed. Long live the Revolution, Comrades.
Before: Lenin left, Trotsky circled right. After: Trotsky removed.
____________________
Sources and Notes
All photographs used in this Post: Copyright the respective owners.
Li Zhansheng is a photojournalist. He was a photographer with the Heilonjiang Newspaper, and photographed the Mao Cultural Revolution as part of his work with the newspaper. However, besides allowed ‘positive’ images of peasant meetings, etc, he managed to secretly take photographs of the realities behind the Cultural revolution, including those forcibly sent to the countryside to help the ‘revolution’ (hard labour camps), and executions without trial. These latter negatives he hid underneath the floorboards in his family one room flat in Harbin. He and his wife, Yingxia, were themselves sent to a hard labour camp for two years, in 1969.
Li Zhansheng with his wife Yingxia and children in their Harbin flat, September 1972. Taken with a self-timer.
The photographs he took during the Cultural revolution are published as Red-Colour News Soldier by Phaidon, 2003. It is still in print.
2. The photographs that Josef Koudelka took during the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia are published as Invasion 68: Prague, Aperture, 2008. It is still in print.
3. Jiri Menzell’sLarks on a String and Closely Observed Trains are currently available DVDs, with English sub-titles, and an English Menu. Vesničko Má Stredisková (My Sweet Little Village) and Na Samoteu Lesa (Seclusion Near a Wood) are Czech DVDs, with English sub-titles and a Czech Menu. It is not too difficult to figure out from the Menu how to switch on the English sub-titles. subtitlescafedalston.co.uk sell by post or in person Na Samote u Lesa (Seclusion Near a Wood) which is how Le Patron got his copy. They also sell online a small selection of other Czech films, film posters and items. All the DVDs are otherwise available from amazon.co.uk
4 The photographs taken by Victor Kolár in Ostrava, during the period of Czech ‘Normalisation’ are in Viktor Kolár, Torst, Prague, 2002.
Viktor Kolár, published by Torst, Prague, 2002.
Unfortunately only very expensive second hand copies of this soft back are presently available, although a search through ebay might yield copies cheaper than the current asking price on abebooks, which varies between £111 to £207, at the time of writing (January, 2016). Fortunately Viktor Kolár does have a website where some of his work can be seen. victorkolar.com
Glasgow, George Square. 2005.Glasgow, George Square. 2005.Glasgow, George Square. 2005.Glasgow, George Square. 2005.
Edinburgh, Duddingston Loch
Edinburgh, Duddingston Loch. “The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch”, 1780s. Attributed to Henry Raeburn. National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh.
Paris, Hotel de Ville.
Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.
Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.Paris, Hotel de Ville. 2008.
“I was there mate, so I know what I’m talking about.” “Oh really?”
Eddie Cochran and his Gretsch guitar
Eddie Cochran and the Summertime Blues
The long, hot summer in the U.K. of 1958 was awash with rock n roll music that blew your socks off: Buddy Holly’s Rave On, Duane Eddy’s Rebel Rouser, Jerry Lee’s High School Confidential… and Eddie Cochran’s Summertime Blues. Oops!! The latter not even quite right.
Not at all right, it seems. (1)
Le Patron did not – as he wrongly remembered – obsessively play during that Essex summer the London Label Summertime Blues on the portable plug in record player in his bedroom, windows open, whilst his Dad mowed the grass outside, his sister dusted her Wade figurines, and his Mum cooked the sunday lunch. Oh no. He would have lost serious money if he had put a bet on that.
Being there doesn’t mean you remember right. According to the UK hit parades of 1958, Summertime Blues reached its highest position in the British Top Twenty – at Number 18 – on 13th November, 1958. Forget summer. The nights were dark. And the Number One that damp week in November was It’s All in The Game by the rarely remembered Tommy Edwards.
Eddie Cochran
Le Patron is writing about Eddie Cochran as Eddie Cochran died in St.Martin’s Hospital, Bath, Somerset, and so did Le Patron’s Dad, and in a manner of speaking, they both shared the same house too, in Essex in 1958. But first…. The Summer of ’58.
Le Patron
The Summer of ’58
In Rock n Roll legend – as far as the U.K. goes – the summer of 1958 is seen as the final splendid showering of rock n roll. All the American greats were in the U.K. Top Twenty, mostly on the London label (RCA, Coral & Brunswick aside). Buddy Holly got to No 5 in August 1958 with Rave On; Jerry Lee’s explosive High School Confidential made No.12; the staggering Rebel Rouser made No.19 for Duane Eddy in September 1958, and Elvis was there with the Platinum Hard Headed Woman.
Just to take the week in August when Buddy Holly got to No 5 with Rave On: the Everly’s were sitting at the Top with the double A sided All I Have To Is Dream/Claudette, with Elvis snapping at their heels with Hard Headed Woman. The Crickets Think It Over had entered the bottom 20 and was rising, and Little Richard’s Ooh My Soul was in the bottom 20 too. So yes, it was a hot, exciting summer. The Patron played again and again the opening lines of Rave On: “Well-ahella-ahella, the little things you say and do”; Jerry Lee’s blistering High School Confidential which ripped in with “Come on honey, get on your dancing shoes, before the juke box blows a fuse” Or the opening, stunning, mesmerising twangs of Rebel Rouser. Where was that sound coming from?!
It was a far cry from the BBC Light Programme’s Sunday lunch time record requests show Two Way Family Favourites. The closest you might get to the source on that programme was Guy Mitchell, maybe a ballad from the Everly’s, or the poppy Lollipop by the Mudlarks (an English cover of the Chordettes U.S. original). But there was never ever going to be anything that would blow the valves out of their radiogram sockets.
In a small town in Essex in the summer of 1958 listening to Jack Jackson’s Decca show on Luxembourg was the first stop for listening to this electrifying sound from across the Atlantic. (The AFN – (American Forces Network) – signal from Germany was even weaker than Luxembourg’s)
The second way to hear it was to stand in the record booth at the local shop where you could listen before you bought or did not buy a new release. And thirdly, dropping a coin in the slot of a juke box.
So that was the summer of ’58. According to the mythology, it was the Indian Summer of that 1956 – 1958 explosion of American Rock n Roll. Even Le Patron accepted the myth. It didn’t need Don MacLean’s American Pie (1971) to talk about the day the music died (February, 1959 and Buddy’s plane crash). The myth had already been established somewhere around 1964, when Mods and Rockers fought it out on the beaches of England’s South Coast.
Little Richard
But like Le Patron’s dodgy memory, the myth is wrong too. This is the myth: in 1959 Buddy Holly was dead, Elvis was in the Army, Little Richard had found God, and Jerry Lee never recovered from being found out, in May, 1958, that he had married his 13 year old first cousin once removed. And – according to the myth – after that came three or four years of Bobby this, and Bobby that, singing bland bubblegum pop. Rock n roll was dead. (Even Bob Dylan believed this. Years later, commenting on that 1959 – 1962 period he saw it as a successful conspiracy of the WASP majority to suppress the wild, racial elements of rock n roll). Oh really?
Firstly, even if Little Richard hadn’t found God, his recorded music had already gone off the boil. Baby Face, which followed Ooh My Soul in the summer of 1958 was as dire as Tony Sheridan and the Beat Brothers (The Beatles) 1961 My Bonny. Likewise Jerry Lee’s singles by 1959 weren’t as strong, apart from Loving Up a Storm. Incidentally, although Jerry Lee’s May 1958 UK tour was cancelled on the back of the press moral indignation, and the Methodist Rank Organisation pulling the plug on bookings in their theatres, his High School Confidential successfully climbed the Top Twenty to No.12. And Col. Parker successfully issued back catalogue material that always saw Elvis in the Top Ten, whilst he was in the U.S. army.
Brenda Lee, the Everly’s, Roy Orbision, Elvis (out of the army in March, 1960), Ricky Nelson, Duane Eddy continued to record material in the 1959 – 1962 period that were massive hits at the time and are now part of rock history: Let’s Jump the Broomstick; Cathy’s Clown; Running Scared; It’s Now or Never; Hello Mary Lou; Peter Gunn….(2).
Duane Eddy
And interesting new things were happening in that 1959 – 1962 period. Music was evolving, as it always does. A giant like Ray Charles was breaking into the UK Top Twenty, and like Elvis he took white and black music and melded aspects of it: I Can’t Stop Loving You, Your Cheating Heart, from white American Country music and Georgia on My Mind from the white American Song Book, and succeeded with the black Hit the Road Jack and What’d I Say? Buddy Holly was one of several performers who were impressed and inspired by Ray Charles, and his 1958 Early in the Morning was influenced by the Ray Charles approach. In 1961 Jerry Lee made a rare re-appearance into the UK Top Twenty with his version of Ray’s What’d I Say?
Sam Cooke too was breaking into the U.K Top Ten during 1959 – 1962: Wonderful World, Chain Gang, Cupid, Twisting the Night Away and Another Saturday Night. His cool persona, with the Apollo Harlem showtime routine, was breaking the ground for Stax and Tamla Motown to follow. Bob Dylan would have revised his opinion that WASPS killed off the music because of the racial elements, if he had seen Sam Cooke performing Twisting the Night Away to an audience who look as if they’ve been bussed in from a white businessmen’s convention, Sam getting the sober suited execs. to clap as he does some neat moves, singing “Dancing with the chick in slacks… dancing up and back”. (3. The link to this performance is footnoted below)
So what’s the beef? And what was wrong with Bobby Vee? He cut some good stuff, including with the Crickets. And Bobby Vinton’s Blue Velvet?
O.K. R.I.P the Summer of ’58. Here comes winter.
W i n t e r t i m e B l u e s
When Eddie Cochran joined Gene Vincent on the January-April 1960 UK tour he was no ‘has-been”. His C’mon Everybody had reached No.6 in March 1959, and Something Else got to No.22 in late October, 1959. Gene Vincent, however, hadn’t been in the UK Top Twenty since October 1956,with Blue Jean Bop. At the Bradford concert the thin-skinned Gene got a bit shirty.
BADGERED ROCK STAR QUITS THE STAGE
More than 2000 teenagers at a rock’n’roll concert at the Gaumont, Bradford on Saturday night were astonished when the American star of the show, Gene Vincent, stopped in the middle of a song and walked off stage. His accompanying group faltered to a ragged halt, and harassed compere Billy Raymond hurried from the wings to the microphone to lead a finale in which all members of the company, including a solemn-faced Vincent, took part.
In his dressing room later, the 25-year-old singer from Norfolk, Virginia, explained his startling exit. “Four guys at the back had been heckling throughout the act. I didn’t particularly mind during my fast numbers, but when they tried to ruin Over The Rainbow I could just not take it any more. It is one of the best things that I do and it has been going down well all over the country. I will never play at this place again”
– (Yorkshire Post)
As the tour progressed it was clear the real star of the show was Eddie Cochran. When the tour management suggested he should go top of the bill he declined, as he had a soft spot for Gene. Eddie, it is reported was homesick on the UK tour, ringing his Mum every day, and although he’d experienced cold winters, he wasn’t used to the lack of central heating in 1960s Britain, and that got to him.
When he and Gene finished their last concert in April at the Bristol Hippodrome he hired a car to take him, his girlfriend and Gene through the dark night to London Airport for the flight back to the States. The car crashed near Chippenham, and Eddie died of his injuries two days later at St. Martin’s Hospital in Bath, Somerset on 16 April, 1960.
Gene, and Eddie’s girlfriend Sharon Sheeley, survived. Eddie was 21.
Eddie & Sharon. They were engaged to be married.
So it seems Le Patron was listening to Summertime Blues sometime in October, 1958, (notthe summer), whilst outside his Dad , after the first frost of autumn, dug over the vegetable patch. Mum cooked the meal in the kitchen and his sister listened to the newly introduced Saturday Club, a lame BBC attempt to “get with it”, hosted by Brian Mathews.
Many years later Le Patron’s Dad no longer worked in a garden. In the early 1990s he died in a dementia ward of the same hospital Eddie died. By then St.Martin’s had no “Casualty” (A&E, Accident and Emergency, as it is now called).
A day or so later Le Patron and his Mum went to register the death at the local Registrar of Births, Deaths and Marriages. Whilst his Mum was talking to the receptionist, Le Patron noticed a framed Death Certificate, proudly displayed on an otherwise bare wall. It was the Death certificate of Eddie Cochran. Le Patron looked closer and saw that in the column “Occupation” Eddie was listed as “Entertainer”. It was all so long ago, that Summer of ’58.
It is surprisingly difficult to find the date for the UK release of Summertime Blues. An Eddie Cochran fan site says September, 1958, but doesn’t say when in September. There is also a variation in the highest position it got in the UK Top Twenty. One source lists it as low as 21. All sources indicate the highest position at around 13 – 18 November, 1958. It is surprisingly that if it was released at the end of September it should take 6 weeks to get to no.18 in the bottom half of the Top Twenty.
The bizarre mythology that 1959 – 1962 was a sort of musical vacuum (before the rise of the Beatles, and the British Groups invasion of the States), filled by bubblegum pop, doesn’t stand up to examination. Here are some, but not all, of the releases by the big U.S. names during 1959 – 1962: Duane Eddy: Peter Gunn, Forty Miles of Bad Road, Some Kind of Earthquake, Because They’re Young, Dance with the Guitar Man. Brenda Lee: Let’s Jump the Broomstick, Sweet Nothings, I’m Sorry, Emotions, Dum Dum, Fool No 1. Roy Orbison: Only the Lonely, Blue Angel, Running Scared, Crying, In Dreams, Pretty Woman (1963). Elvis: A Fool Such as I, Little Sister, A Mess of Blues, Big Hunk of Love, Stuck on You, It’s Now or Never, Are You Lonesome Tonight, Good Luck Charm, Return To Sender, She’s Not You, Devil in Disguise. The Everly’s: Till I Kissed You, Let It Be Me, Cathy’s Clown, When Will I Be Loved, Walk Right Back, Crying in the Rain. Ricky Nelson: Travellin’ Man, It’s Late, Hello Mary Lou, Young World, Teenage Idol, It’s Up To You.
Princess Juliana & Prince Bernhard, on a town visit, Holland, 9th May, 1940, the day before Germany unexpectedly attacked Holland. Private photograph. Collection Pete Grafton Reverse of Julianna & Bernhard, 9-5-40 photo.
Le Patron spotted this photograph in a bric-a-brac shop in Haarlem in 2005, and bought it for €1.50. For a while he didn’t realise the significance of the photograph, until he discovered that on the 10th of May, 1940,the day after the photograph was taken by an on-looker, German forces attacked Holland, and Belgium, 75 years ago this month.
It is conjecture when the person with the camera handed in the roll of film for developing and printing, and in what Dutch town this was, (it was not necessarily Haarlem) but she or he probably got the prints back after Holland had been forced to surrender on 15 May, 1940. The day before, 14 May, 1940, the Germans had blitzed central Rotterdam, and had demanded that if Holland did not capitulate they would flatten Utrecht the following day.
The centre of Rotterdam, May 1940, flattened by the Luftwaffe.
The photo has been printed on the Belgium made Gavaert ‘Ridax’ photographic paper. Without consulting the Belgium Parliament, the Belgium King, Leopold III, ordered Belgium Armed Forces to surrender on 28 May, 1940. Writing in his diary at the time, the soon to be Director-General of the British Political Warfare Executive Robert Bruce Lockhart wrote:
“Reynaud has spoken on Paris radio at 8.30 a.m. “I have grave news to announce. King Leopold of the Belgians capitulated to Germany this morning at 4 a.m.” A day of gloom, although Leopold has always been suspected. Frank Aveling (friend of Leopold) who knows him better than any Englishman has always told me that the King is (1) a totalitarian in his political views and (2) a Peace Pledge pacifist in his religious and sociological views!” (1)
Although a German, and with a brother in the German Army, Prince Bernhard didn’t intend to be part of a Dutch capitulation to German National Socialist forces. A keen photographer he took the following photographs “between raids” at the Palais Noordeinde in Den Haag (The Hague) the day after the German attack, on 11 May, 1940.
“Resting in the sun” From left to right, the Dutch Queen Wilhelmina, Princess Juliana, a close friend of Juliana’s, the daughter of her close friend, and Princess Beatrix. Note the Queen has a coat on, and Juliana has a fur over her lap. Caption and Photo: Prince Bernhard“Interval Between Raids” Left to right, Princess Juliana, with Princess Irene on her lap, the nanny, Princess Beatrix, Juliana’s close friend, with her daughter on her lap. Assumed to have been taken later in the day when the sun was warmer. Note the rifle leaning up against the wall. Caption and photo: Prince Bernhard.German army demolishing a road block in Holland, May 1940.
German army units in Grote Markt, Haarlem, May 1940.
“During the German Invasion, the Prince, carrying a machine gun, allegedly organised the palace guards into a combat group and shot at German planes. The Royal Family fled the Netherlands and took refuge in England. In disagreement with Queen Wilhelmina’s decision to leave the Kingdom, the young Prince Consort, aged 28, is said to have refused to go initially and wanted to oppose the Nazi occupation within its borders, but eventually agreed to join her as head of the Royal Military Mission based in London. Once safely there, his wife Juliana and their children went on to Canada, where they remained until the end of the war.” – source, Wikipedia entry “Prince Bernhard of Lippe-Biesterfeld.”
Queen Wilhelmina in England. Note Dutch Royal insignia on headlamp. Photo: Prince Bernhard.
Prince Bernard in Britain, in modified RAF uniform. He was in the RAF 322 “Dutch Squadron”. Note his Leica camera. Photographer: Unknown. Taken from Het Fotoarchief van Prins Bernhard.
Prince Bernhard went on from flying Spitfires in the 322 “Dutch Squadron”, to flying a variety of planes in missions over France, Italy and the Atlantic.
King Leopold III of Belgium continued to live in Belgium as the ruling monarch, with the assent of the National Socialists.
King Leopold III
Another monarch, the war hungry absolutist Kaiser Wilhelm II, had been living in forced exile in a country mansion in the Dutch village of Doorn (near Utrecht) since 1918. When Hitler invaded Poland, and when the German forces occupied Paris, the ex-Kaiser sent letters of congratulation to Hitler. Kaiser Wilhelm II had been regarded with contempt as a military strategist by his equally belligerent German Army Officer class since 1908, and Hitler, who was anti-monarchist, shared their sentiments. When the Germans invaded Holland, both London and Berlin invited him to move to their countries. He declined. He died at Doorn in 1941.
Kaiser Wilhelm II, 1905.
What’s Happening in the Photograph?
Princess Juliana and Prince Bernhard are no longer the centre of attention as the photo was taken. Note that two women in the crowd are smiling and looking at the person or people who is/are behind Juliana and Bernhard. The Queen, Wilhelmina? If so, the photographer will not have had time to wind the film on and manually cock the shutter for the next shot. Why would she or he be more interested in snapping the Queen’s daughter and husband?
It’s a warm late spring day, with the sun shining in from the left hand side of the photo, and Juliana and Bernhard are lightly dressed. The onlooking boy wears short trousers.
Who is the man walking in front of Juliana and Bernhard. A plain clothes policeman? Then why is he looking down, and not up, and alert?
Bernard has his hand on the winding arm of a 16mm ciné camera, possibly either the American Bell & Howell, or a German Agfa. Going by the shape of the camera case, Juliana has a German Leica 35 mm camera. In general, the feeling is that this is not too formal an occasion.
There are no clues in which Dutch town this is.
The date on the reverse of the snap says 9-5.1940, which gives the photograph the significance, but the detail that caused Le Patron some unease was the pollarded trees with no foliage. On the 9th of May? Other photos of the day of invasion show trees with foliage. There are shadows of young leaves, for instance, in the photo with the Royal Family resting between air raids, taken on 11 May, 1940. On 19 May, 2015, mulling this worrying detail over, on a bench by the brook known as the Dawlish Water, Le Patron looked up and almost next to him he was suddenly aware of a tree that was showing similar characteristics, when all the trees around him were well in bloom, and even the characteristically late ash trees were pushing out foliage. He took a couple of photographs of this tree and sent them to a horticulturist friend. This was his reply:
“Definitely either a Black Poplar (Populus nigra), or alternatively an Aspen (Populus tremula).
If I had to guess, from the pics and the look of the not quite fully out leaves and the bud shape/spacing,….I’d say the former, as its’ a larger tree generally, as your example is!
Having consulted my Hilliers reference book, both these are “late “ to come into leaf, in the U.K.”
This isn’t to suggest the pollarded trees in the “Juliana & Bernhard 9-5-1940” photo are black populars, but does show that some trees can be very late, compared with others.
_____
After the Allies had landed in Normandy in June 1944, in anticipation of their advance, Heinrich Himmler ordered that the Belgium King Leopold III and his family be moved to Germany. When the war in Europe finished on 8 May, 1945, in anticipation of serious political instability in Belgium the Allies did not allow him to return and his brother Charles acted as Regent. When he was allowed to return in 1950 the country was violently divided, with three people shot dead by Belgium police at a demonstration during what has been described as the most violent General Strike in the history of Belgium. The King was forced to abdicate to his son, Baudouin.
Photo: Prince Bernhard.
Because of a cruel twist, western Holland (including Amsterdam and Haarlem) remained occupied until the end of the war (with a dreadful famine in the winter of 1944 and spring of 1945 that is estimated to have killed 18,000 people). Prince Bernhard arrived with liberating forces and was closely involved in the surrender negotiations of the occupying German forces in Holland in 1945, and deliberately chose to speak Dutch, and not German – his native tongue – in the surrender negotiations with the occupying German forces.
Queen Wilhelmina had remained in England during the war, and returned to liberated Holland in May, 1945. Princess Juliana also returned, from Canada, to Holland in May 1945. The Dutch Royal Family were feted by crowds where ever they went.
From Het Fotoarchief van Prins Bernhard. Photo: Prince BernhardPrincess Juliana, Prince Bernhard and family at Teuge aerodrome, 4 August, 1945. A new little Princess, Margriet, born in Canada in 1943, is in the middle of the photo. Note a Royal Aide or Dutch military personal aide with dolly on the right. The Prince now has a multi turret lens cine camera. (Teuge aerodrome was used by the Luftwaffe, and is approximately 95 km east of Amsterdam, and 36 km north of Arnhem.) Photo from Het Fotoarchief van Prins Bernhard
The Hongerwinter (Hunger Winter), besides the estimated 18,000 deaths, had a permanent effect on the growth of many young people (including Audrey Hepburn), pregnant women, and their babies. Many people were forced to eat sugar beet and tulip bulbs, although not, as far as is known, tree bark, that had happened in the famines in the Ukraine and China.
Grote Markt, Haarlem. May 1940.Grote Markt, Haarlem, 2006. Photo: Pete Grafton.
__________
1. The Diaries of Sir Robert Bruce Lockhart, Volume 2, 1939 – 1965. Macmillan, 1980.
NOTES
All photos taken by Prince Bernhard and of the Dutch Royal Family are from Het Fotoarchief van prins Bernhard de Jaren 1940 – 1945, Verzetsmuseum Amsterdam, 2005. ISBN 90-74159–75-3.
The 8th of May, 2015 is the 70th anniversary of the end of war in Europe in 1945.
East London Teenager Boy VE Day was one of the most emotional days in my life. There were Union Jacks out and every one was saying “We want the King!” Everyone was shouting for the King. Men and women. Mind you, they were shouting for Louis 16th a few weeks before they cut his head off. You can’t go on the emotions of… – People were so pent up. There was mass shagging in the streets… – No sort of class distinction. I walked into a posh hotel and everyone was offering me drinks. Everybody. What amazed me was where they got the drink from! No one ever had it. At least, we didn’t, because before this, pubs were closed. People had to walk miles to get a drink. A bloke would say to another bloke “I know a pub that’s got some beer.” The pub would be packed solid until they drunk the beer out. So I don’t know where they got the drink from.
East End Girl On VE Day I watched my Dad dance up and down the street. He was dead drunk, my Dad. He tap danced all up and down our street. My Dad used to have cups for tap dancing. Everybody was out on the street, drunk. We watched from the windows.
Somerset Girl On VE Day they had bonfires on hilltops. They took weeks building up huge bonfires on all the hills – on Street Hill and Wearyall Hill, between Street and Glastonbury, and all the hills around.
Somerset Boy From Ham Hill we could see all the other fires. A sailor at our fire actually threw himself in the middle of the bonfire and they had to haul him off. He was in flames. They had to roll him down the hill to put the flames out. He was drunk. That was Victory night.
2nd Somerset Girl VE day in Winscombe was very dead. We were longing for something. We could have gone to Weston but there wasn’t a late bus to come back. We really felt left out of things. You read about all these marvellous things going on in London – dancing in the streets.
Paratrooper I was in Ireland on VE Day. There’s a bay there called Dundrum Bay and I was sitting on a little bit of grass thinking to myself: “Well, I don’t know, all this bleeding time, all that square bashing, all them manoeuvres, for me to be sitting here when it’s all over. I’m still here. And them poor sods I joined up with, who I was working with before the war, are probably blown to bits, or something like that. And what for?”
The following day we was on a road run. They took us on a road run all round the country lanes, and we were running down this slope in this little lane and an old Irish boy’s walking along, with an old hat and a bloody great knurled stick in his hand, and as we’re running past he said “What the bloody hell are you running for? The war’s over!” We was pissing ourselves laughing.
Liverpool Mother I spent my VE Day in Southdown Hospital. After going right through the war, when all the celebrations were on I took appendicitis and was taken away. I could hear all this singing going on and I was saying to myself: Ooh, I’d love to be out there.
Liverpool Teenage Girl On VE Night there was a gang of us got together. We were still working the railway, this gang. We were on 2 to 11 shift, my mate and I. We got that much drink, we walked up from Central Station and the next thing we remembered doing was sitting in Abercromby Square Gardens about 4 in the morning – singing. Everyone went mad those two days. I don’t think anyone slept.
Teeside Boy Soldier We were stationed in Catterick and a gang of us went to Middlesbrough. There was a lad from Newcastle and he took a box of hand-grenades and a bloody great box of flares. In Middlesbrough he was throwing hand-grenades in park. We finished up in Acland Road. We came across a pile of road chippings and barrels of tar. How we did it I don’t know, but we got about three of these barrels stacked one on top of the other and set fire to bottom one. And we were dancing around them.
Staffs Miner VE Day they gave you extra money to stop in. I was on nights when word came through – day’s pay and home Jeeves, and don’t spare the horses! Extra pint in pub! Extra ale!
Royal Engineer I was in Germany on VE Day. Our division took Bremen and another division took Hamburg. We went into Bremen brewery, me and the engineers. We had to take a lorry and pick up the company’s beer. We all got pissed and nearly drowned because down in the wine vaults of the brewery the maniacs had knocked the pipes off and the sherry ran all over the floor. You was wading with sherry up to your knees. No lights on. We were shining torches. And the stink! You was intoxicated with the smell……
Bodleian Library manipulation and distortion of Militargeographische Angaben uber England (1)One of three original documents that the Bodleian Library turns into the publication above. This original 1941 edition is in the Library of Congress, Washington.
Prior to Operation Sealion – the German name given to their planned invasion of Britain – military intelligence reports had already been prepared in Berlin. The documents were headed as Militärgeographische Angaben über England. (“Military Geographic Information about England”). They comprehensively described, from an invading military logistic perspective, region by region, the physical terrain, the transport infra- structure, the power stations, the national electricity grid, the location of large “grist” (flour) mills (for hungry troops), and so on. The amount of detail and photographs, and maps was extraordinary. The intelligence material also had a brief overview of the social and racial characterises of the English. In a strikingly doctored, cut down and misleading version of Militärgeographische Angaben über England, published by the Bodleian Library, Oxford, 2007 as German Invasion Plans for the British Isles 1940 (see their cover above) there is a section on the Social and Racial Characteristics of the English. It is reproduced here with the caution that in translation (commissioned by the Bodleian Library), or in the editing, it too may have been shortened or doctored in some way. However, the observations and sentiments expressed about English social classes will be accurate. (For further points about the distortion of the Bodleian “German Invasion Plans” see Footnote 1. below)
“England is… a land of opposites in social respects. The impact of this, however, is softened by the widespread emergence of similarities in lifestyle; and the differences, because they are considered traditional, do not have such a divisive effect as they would in less conservative countries.
The not inconsiderable upper class consists of rich families as well as the old and new aristocracy, whose assets together make up the main part of the nation’s wealth. Next, with its own elaborate hierarchy, comes the extensive working middle classes, whose members enjoy sizeable incomes and considerable prosperity; in general they have a considerably more comfortable lifestyle but lower level of education than in Germany.
There is also a lower class, fairly substantial in size, of workers on poor to average pay and the long-term unemployed, who have a surprisingly low material and intellectual standard of living. They inhabit the “slums” (homes of misery) with their poor sanitary conditions, filth, and at times morbid forms of social existence (e.g. child poverty), in a state of poor health and in some cases long-term malnutrition. Some of these negative developments must be put down not to undeserved poverty but wholly or in part to insufficient competence in domestic matters, specifically among women, as well as to a lack of mutual encouragement.
The most striking features displayed by the more disagreeable sections of this class include a lack of personal ambition, indifference to the demands of the community and nation, and interests that stop with sport and frivolity, the sensations of city life.
In some cases one is dealing here with the residue of an urban social group that has already been making its presence felt for over a hundred years and whose numbers make up an alarming proportion of the population as a whole.
Racially, the population is a mixture of Mediterranean, Alpine, and Nordic elements, with the latter predominant.
The west of England, above all Wales, is home to remnants of an indigenous population whose roots go back to Celtic times and beyond. Unlike the bright English, they are dark and small in stature. Even though they have largely abandoned their language, they have still retained a reasonably strong awareness of the distinctive heritage and culture to which they belong. Radical political aspirations are confined to narrow circles and are of no practical significance.”
National Socialist German Workers’ Party flagEngels, The Condition of the Working Class in England, 1845 edition
As the German National Socialist Adolf Hitler identified enemies and hindrances to his creation of a Thousand Year Reich, based on race, so too did InterNational Socialists Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Their “Utopia” was based not on race, but class, although race was significant for them, and many races were written off not only as not part of the Final Destiny, but as a hindrance to it. Here is some of what Engels had to say about the Irish in his The Condition of the Working Class in England, 1845 edition.
Friedrich Engels
“The southern facile character of the Irishman, his crudity, which places him but little above the savage, his contempt for all humane enjoyments, in which his very crudeness makes him incapable of sharing, his filth and poverty, all favour drunkeness. . . . the pressure of this race has done much to depress wages and lower the working-class. . . . That poverty manifests itself in Ireland thus and not otherwise, is owing to the character of the people, and to their historical development….
Aran islands
….. The Irish are a people related in their whole character to the Latin nations, to the French, and especially to the Italians…. With the Irish, feeling and passion predominate; reason must bow before them. Their sensuous, excitable nature prevents reflection and quiet, persevering activity from reaching development — such a nation is utterly unfit for manufacture as now conducted. . . . Irish distress cannot be removed by any Act of Repeal. Such an Act would, however, at once lay bare the fact that the cause of Irish misery, which now seems to come from abroad is really to be found at home” (2)
Engels assessment, written in the early 1840s of some of the reasons for the condition of the Irish peasantry is identical to the reasons given by the National Socialist assessment, written in 1939/1940 for the causes of poverty amongst some of the English working class in the 1930s. Engels assessment was primarily based not on political or economic criteria, but on race.
Friedrich Engels regarded all people of a Celtic background (he mentioned, for instance, the inhabitants of the Scottish Highlands) as an impediment to the forward march of an ‘enlightened proletariat’, whose heightened political consciousness would act as the force that would eventually lead to a proletarian paradise. His friend and political colleague Karl Marx believed, dogmatically, that he had discerned it as a scientific based historical fact.
Isle of HarrisSt. KildaSt.Kilda
Engels regarded Slavs and Basques as retrogressive elements, too, standing in the way of “progress” and that they would have to be dealt with, or would “perish in the revolutionary process.” (His words.)
Ambivalent about the people of France as a positive revolutionary force, he nevertheless approved of their Government’s subjugation of the inferior Arabs in their north African colonies.
Negro and Jew were untermenschen. (sub-human). Despite his Jewish background Marx was also dismissive of Jews and contemptuous of negroes.
The flag of the United Socialist Soviet Republics
Compared with the German National Socialists of the 1920s and 30s, Marxist socialists, years earlier theoretically, and then practically, embraced the removal of those who got in their way of arriving at their Messianic goal. Lenin wrote in 1918. “Ruthless war on the kulaks! Death to them!” (3) The programme/pogram against Kulaks in the USSR started in 1918, but reached its appalling climax in the early 1930s with Stalin remaining faithful to the tenents of Lenin.
Corpses, the Ukraine, 1922. (4)
Hundreds of thousands were uprooted and sent to gulags (concentration work camps) with hundreds of thousands, or more, worked to death on projects such as the White Sea Canal. Others were executed. Like the improvised gallows of the Nazis public hangings in occupied Europe eighteen years later as a warning to those who resist, some kulaks were hung and left on village gallows for the local population to take note of what happened to those who were perceived to be class “traitors”.
A translation of what is known as Lenin’s 1918 “Hanging Order”
11-8-18 Send to Penza
To Comrades Kuraev, Bosh, Minkin and other Penza communists
Comrades! The revolt by the five kulak volost’s must be suppressed without mercy. The interest of the entire revolution demands this, because we have now before us our final decisive battle “with the kulaks.” We need to set an example.
1) You need to hang (hang without fail, so that the public sees) at least 100 notorious kulaks, the rich, and the bloodsuckers. 2) Publish their names. 3) Take away all of their grain. 4) Execute the hostages – in accordance with yesterday’s telegram.
This needs to be accomplished in such a way, that people for hundreds of miles around will see, tremble, know and scream out: let’s choke and strangle those blood-sucking kulaks.
Telegraph us acknowledging receipt and execution of this.
Yours, Lenin
P.S. Use your toughest people for this. (5)
Definitions by the Soviet Marxist-Leninists of what constituted a kulak shifted sloppily, like an unsecured cargo in a boat’s hold. It is reported that in many villages, neither villagers or kulaks knew which was which, partly because the criteria was not clear. Being a perceived enemy of the revolution was often enough, even when the individual had no land, for he might be harbouring “kulak” thoughts. Bearing in mind land ownership and cultivation in Ireland in the 1920s, as a comparison, a kulak, very roughly, was considered to own one or two cows and five or six acres of land. Estimates range widely on the numbers of kulaks who died. A conservative estimate for the 1930 to 1940 period puts the figure at three quarters of a million. Others have put it much higher.
The Marx and Engels emphasis on “backward races” largely disappeared with the ascendency in Russia of the Bolshevik Party in the worlds’ first “proletarian” revolution. Ideologically it had to disappear because it was in economically backward countries such as Imperial Russia – contradicting Marx’s “scientific” law – that became the centres of Red Revolution. The sickle, the emblem of backward, peasant agricultural communities, now became, along with the proletarian hammer, the symbol on the red flag of the United Socialist Soviet Republics. Peasants vastly outnumbered industrial workers in the U.S.S.R. The next great “triumph’ of Red Revolution was in an even more “backward” country: China. Writing about the Chinese in the 19th century Mark and Engels had written of the “Heredity stupidity of the Chinese” (Marx, 1853); “The overbearing prejudice, stupidity, learned ignorance and pedantic barbarism” (Engels, 1857) (6)
Class, always central to Marxist ideology became foremost, in the ideological somersaults that had to be performed to rationalise the circumstances in which the revolutionary Marxist-Leninist parties found themselves in. Besides the obvious class enemy of the aristocracy and large land-owners, in the USSR the small land owning Kulaks were identified as one of the immediate “reactionary” elements to be wiped out.
In the backward peasant agricultural societies that existed in Pol Pot’s Cambodia and Mao Tse-Tung’s China the twisted Marxist ideology identified “intellectuals” (brain workers) as a class enemy, and hundreds of thousands of what they deemed intellectuals were either worked to death, or executed.
Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin, Mao Tse-Tung
Grotesquely, at the same time, revolutionary posters in both countries had images of classic intellectuals (brain workers) – Marx, Engels and Lenin – staring into the triumphant socialist future, whilst at the same time anyone wearing glasses and not reading Lenin or Chairman Mao was a potential suspect. As far is known neither Marx, Engels or Lenin ever picked up, or knew how to handle a hammer or a sickle. They were good with pens, though.
Unlike the Nazis who only started to plan for the Final Solution to exterminate their perceived race enemies, the Jews, in January, 1943, and kept very circumspect about their plans, and consequent activities, the nineteenth century writings of Engels clearly pointed the way, followed by Lenin proclaiming in 1918 death to the perceived class enemies of the United Socialist Soviet Republics in his Comrade Workers, Forward to the Last, Decisive Fight! (7)
The openness on how to deal with class enemies was characteristic of many who supported the Marxist revolutionary socialist government in the USSR in the 1920s and 1930s. The Irish playwright, reviewer, polemicist and socialist admirer of the U.S.S.R, George Bernard Shaw, writing a preface to a print edition of his play On The Rocks (1933) derided the principle of the sanctity of human life as an “absurdity to any good socialist” and called for extermination to be put ‘on a scientific basis’ and added that to kill off the acquisitive classes is ‘quite reasonable and very necessary’, since no punishment would ever cure them of their capitalist instincts. (8) He repeated a variation of his views on film in 1931, asking that a pain free way of killing people should be developed. In 1934 he called for the development of a “humane’ killing gas, writing in the British Broadcasting Corporation’s magazine The Listener of 7 February.
Sidney and Beatrice Webb travelling to the U.S.S.R., 1932.
His English Fabian socialist colleague Beatrice Webb was aware of, and approved of the campaign against the kulaks. In 1932 she was uneasy about what was happening to the kulaks getting known in Britain. She reportedly had said that it had been very poor stage management to allow a party of British visitors in the Ukraine to see cattle-trucks full of starving “enemies of the state” at a local station. She thought it was “ridiculous to let you see them. The English are always so sentimental”. (Recalled conversation by her niece Konradin Hobhouse, in a letter to the Manchester Guardian, February 1958.)
Soviet Communism – A New Civilisation, 1935. Historian A.J.P.Taylor described it as “The most preposterous book ever written about Russia.”
Besides his support for the USSR, there was a point in the 1930s when Shaw simultaneously admired Hitler’s National Socialist Germany, and the Italian fascist regime of Benito Mussolini. Before the first world war Mussolini was a prominent and active revolutionary socialist, influenced by syndicalist ideas, and edited, amongst other publications, Lotta di Class (The Class Struggle), and later Avanti!, the newspaper of the Italian Socialist Party. He took its weekly circulation from 20,000 to 100,000. Impatient with ‘reformist’ social democracy, and rejecting the historical determinism of Marxist he developed his own brand of national socialism, partly inspired by the writing of the German Friedrich Nietzsche. Mussolini’s Italy of the 1920s and 1930s, which was not based on racial theories, promoted syndicates between employers and employees. Shaw’s support for the national socialist regimes, besides the USSR, was not so illogical. George Orwell was aware of, and commented on Shaw’s position, in a footnote in his James Burnham and the Managerial Revolution article, 1946. (9).
Orwell, Franz Borkenau (author of the Spanish Cockpit) and Robert Bruce Lockhart, who had known Lenin and Trotsky, were three who understood at the time – at a deeper level – the ideological inter-connection between the United Socialist Soviet Republics, the German National Socialists and Mussolini’s corporate state. Musing in his diary on 18 May, 1933, Robert Bruce Lockhart wrote: “… Russia does not hate fascism so much as the jelly-bellied democracy of Britain. She prefers the fascist system of government: (1) because the Fascist form of rule justifies and is the same as her own; (2) because the corporate state is more akin to her own ideal and in the event of a change goes over en bloc to Communism; and (3) she understands exactly where she is with Mussolini: trade and no propaganda nonsense. Result is Mussolini is never attacked in Soviet Press. Gorky once wrote something against Musso. It did not go in.“(Diaries of Sir Robert Bruce Lockhart 1915 – 1938, edited by Kenneth Young.)
In a May, 1940, review of Franz Borkenau’s The Totalitarian Enemy, George Orwell wrote:
“….We cannot struggle against Fascism unless we are willing to understand it, a thing which both left-wingers and right-wingers have conspicuously failed to do – basically, of course, because they dared not.
Until the signing of the Russo-German Pact, the assumption made on both sides was that the Nazi régime was in no way revolutionary. National socialism was simply capitalism with the lid off, Hitler was a dummy with Thyssen pulling the strings – that was the official theory, proved in many a pamphlet by Mr John Strachey and tacitly accepted by The Times. Blimps and Left Book Club members alike swallowed it whole, both of them, so to speak, had a vested interest in ignoring the real facts. Quite naturally the propertied classes wanted to believe that Hitler would protect them against Bolshevism, and equally naturally the Socialists hated having to admit that the man who had slaughtered their comrades was a Socialist himself…… Then came the eye-opener of the Hitler-Stalin pact. Suddenly the scum of the earth and the blood-stained butcher of the workers (for so they had described each other) were marching arm in arm, their friendship ‘cemented in blood’, as Stalin cheerily expressed it. National Socialism is a form of Socialism, is emphatically revolutionary, does crush the property owner just as surely as it crushes the worker. The two régimes, having started from opposite ends, are rapidly evolving towards the same system – a form of oligarchical collectivism….”
(Volume 2, The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell: My Country Right or Left, 1940 – 1943, Secker & Warburg, 1968)
The 1939 Russo-German Pact, as Orwell describes it, was often also called the Non-Aggression Pact. That is, non-agression between the German National Socialists and the United Socialist Soviet Republics. Their first, and joint aggression, was their invasion of Poland in September, 1939.
Soviet officer, giving a Nazi salute, left and German officers, Poland.German and Soviet Forces together, Poland, September, 1939.
Poland, September, 1939. German and Soviet officers and soldiers
The non-aggression pact held for three months short of two years. Whilst it did, the USSR attacked Finland in late November, 1939. The German Nazis attacked Denmark and Norway in April 1940, followed by attacking Holland, Belgium, Luxembourg and France in May 1940. The USSR attacked Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia two months later, in July 1940. Germany attacked Roumania October, 1940, and then Greece and Yugoslavia in April 1941.
And then, in Hitler’s biggest strategic military mistake (though not on National Socialist race ideology and geographical grounds) German forces attacked the USSR in June 1941.
Six months after the United Socialist Soviet Union had occupied their pre-agreed areas of Poland (agreed with the German National Socialists), the USSR systematically executed Polish “class enemies” in a short period, beginning on 3 April, 1940. The victims were executed in several Polish locations, including near the Katyn woods. 22,000 were shot in the back of the neck by a small team of NKVD executioners. The “pain free” way of killing the “acquisitive classes” that George Bernard Shaw asked for was reserved for the executioners. It was soon realised that the strong recoil on the Russian made pistols the NKVD executioners used caused hand and arm ache after 12 executions. They were therefore issued with German made Walther pistols, with a softer recoil. Vasilli Mikhailovich Blokhin, chief executioner for the NKVD, executed approximately 7,000 of the 20,000 who were killed. Besides Polish army officers – who were the largest group – Polish NCOs, university professors, physicians, lawyers, engineers, teachers, writers and journalists were also amongst those shot. The Polish film director Andrzej Wadja’s father was one of the executed. The bodies were buried in shallow mass graves in 1940, and were discovered and exhumed by the German National Socialists in 1943. In 1943 the USSR angrily denied they were responsible and broke off diplomatic relations with the exiled Polish Government in London, who had correctly accused them. The culprits, according to the USSR, were the German National Socialists. The USSR stuck to this story until 1990. And then blamed Stalin for the executions, and not Marxist theory.
NOT THE TRUTH but called “The Truth about Soviet Russia”, 1942. Sidney and Beatrice Webb, with an essay on the Webbs by George Bernard ShawEnemies of the People, Pol Pot’s Cambodia, 1975 – 1979.
“Accused peasants are kept under guard by local militia as they wait to be denounced at a mass rally as one of the ‘four elements’ – landlords, rich peasants, counter-revolutionaries, or ‘bad characters’ – as indicated by the sign.” – Red-Colour News Soldier: A Chinese Photographer’s Odyssey through the Cultural Revolution, Li Zhensheng, Phaidon, 2003. All photos copyright Li Zhensheng. (The above two photos are from one photo spanning two pages in the above publication. They have been reproduced as above because of the limitations of the photo scanner used in scanning the size of the original, and not for editorial reasons.)
“Counter-revolutionaries” China, April 1968. Photo: Li ZhenshengCounter Revolutionaries driven through Harbin, China, 5 April, 1968. Photos: Li Zhensheng
Counter-revolutionaries and “criminals”, near Harbin, 5 April, 1968. Photos: Li Zhensheng“Revolutionary Justice” Near Harbin, 5 April, 1968. Photo: Li ZhenshengFlag of the People’s Republic of ChinaFlag of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea
Flag of the (Ultra Nationalist) National Bolshevik Party, Russian Federation, 1995.Logo of the Communist Party of Great Britain, 2015.
Logo of the British Socialist Workers Party.
And so it goes on…….
At the time of writing, in 2015 the totalitarian left continues to meet the totalitarian right. The new Greek Foreign Minister, Nikos Kotzias in the Syriza dominant Greek Government was a previous member of the Central Committee of the Greek Communist Party. In the 1980s he applauded the attempted suppression of the Solidarity movement by the Polish communist government. The Economist magazine is reported to have said that he “enjoys cordial relations with the religious-nationalist segment of the Russian elite”. Indeed he does.
Aleksander Dugin, Russian ultra nationalist, speaking at Bolshevik National Party meeting, 1996. Note the BNP flag on the left hand side.American anti-semite and former leader of the Ku Klux Klan David Duke, left, with Russian ultra nationalist Aleksandr Dugin. Photo believed to be taken in 2004.Meeting of mutual interests: Nikos Kotzias (ex-communist and now Greek Foreign Minister) on the left, with Alexsandr Dugin, Russian ultra nationalist, centre. Unknown date, but believed to be post 2010.Greek Foreign Minister, Nikos Kotzias, 2015.
Russian TV online news story, 1 February, 2015:
“EU must stop ‘feverish’ anti-Russian steps, think long-term relations – Greek FM:The EU should consider long-term relations with Moscow, instead of making feverish anti-Russian moves, new Greek Foreign Minister Nikos Kotzias said, adding that his country does not want to give up its historic ties with Moscow…”
Besides social democrats, democratic socialists and green groups comprising the original elements in what became the “Coalition of the Radical Left” (SYRIZA), Greek Maoists, Trotskyists and Communists were also part of the original ‘radical’ mix.
1. The Oxford Bodleian Library is a ‘respectable’ library of rare manuscripts. Academic fidelity has gone out the window with their publication of German Invasion Plans for the British Isles 1940. No such title in the original German was produced in Berlin, nor were the original documents covered with the imprint of the National Socialist swastika. The Bodleian Libary’s editorial thinking is that swastika’s sell. And of course, they’re right. But that has nothing to do with academic fidelity to the original documents.
The Bodleian Library on the back cover of their publication claim the material they have translated is from “One of the only surviving copies found by Allied Forces…”. How many is One? Two? Three? Ten? Twenty? More? At the time of writing a seller on Abebooks is selling an original German edition of the Berlin documents from 1940, and 1941. “Two important items, 1, Militargeograhische angaben uber England prepared 15 August 1940, numerous photographs of the southcoast and coloured maps and profiles, designed to provide information for German forces invading Britain 446pp., coloured map, additional information at rear c.50pp., large folding map. Modest blemishes and chip to rear cover and modest stain to front else vgc. Also 2. Militargeographische angaben uber England. London 2 Auflage August 1941 Text und Bildheft 18pp., 51pp., Seperately in case 5 coloured folding maps, as called for, all vgc with interesting stamp to cover “First Canadian Army Documents 23 October 1944″ indicating when it was captured. In summary two seperate items, historically interesting and rare, German text. Bookseller Inventory # 18674”
Similar original documents are also available from David Archers Maps.
In the anonymous Editor’s Note to the Bodleian ‘fake’ he or she writes “The text for this edition has been abridged and some of the headings have been altered”. Abridged by how much is not discussed. No reasoning is given for the editorial guidelines in changing England to Britain, for instance. In a forward it is acknowledged (blink and you’ll miss it) that this fake is drawn from ‘Portfolio A” but doesn’t mention, to put it in a meaningful context, how many other Portfolios there were. The Bodleian Library has produced other small bite sized Second World War books in the same series, keenly priced and aimed at the impulse buyer. Just to add to the ‘period feel’ they have produced them in the stressed British Economy Standards wartime look. And that is a fake too, as the British Economy Standards didn’t come into force until later in the war, and weren’t, of course, on the original source material.
2. The complete Condition of the Working Class in England is online from various sources. Telling extracts from it, such as Engels’ view of the Irish, are available in English, with a link to the original German at jonjayray.tripod.com/engels.html
4. The authenticity of photographs can be questionable. When the advancing western Allied Forces in 1945 stumbled across the appalling scenes in slave work camps and concentration camps in Germany, photographers and cinematographers were advised to shoot establishing shots, besides close ups of corpses and dying inmates. The concern was that when seen by a viewing public some would not believe what they were seeing and would dismiss the photos and films as propaganda, unless there was a general establishing view first. The impact of the images reduced people to tears in cinemas, for instance, in Britain. Others, reasonably, covered their eyes, so horrific were the images. Others, who had believed that stories of Nazi atrocities were largely Allied propaganda, such as an active anarchist war-resister in wartime London, realised their mistake. (see You!, You! & You! Chapter 29 “Lets Face It – Who Cared About the Jews?”). Because the USSR was not over-run there is no irrefutable photographic evidence of the enormity and barbarity of the crimes committed by the Marxist-Leninist Bolsheviks. (The same reasons apply to what has happened in China, and is continuing to happen in North Korea). There are no photographs of cattle trucks loaded to bursting point with “kulaks” being sent to Siberian labour camps, for instance, with the dying strewn across the railway sidings. The very few photographs from the Ukraine, in the early 1920s and then the early 1930s, are sometimes difficult to authenticate.
Some of the photos from the Ukraine in the early 1930s cannot be refuted as they were taken by the Welsh journalist Gareth Jones. They usually show a dead malnourished clothed body, lying on the pavement, whilst pedestrians walk by. Photo evidence from the early 1920s is problematical, not only in the captions that over the years have been attached to them, but also in interpretation of what we are looking at. The photograph of naked corpses loaded on a cart, reproduced above, has appeared on the internet with either 1921 or 1922 or 1921-22. Photographs that document the Ukraine at this time were usually taken by Western Food Aid agencies. But what are we looking at? Those who have died from starvation? Why are they naked? Victor Kravchenko in his I Chose Freedom: The Personal and Political Life of A Soviet Official (1947) was enforcing policies against the Kulaks in the Ukraine in the early 1930s, and records how some peasants deliberately made themselves naked in their homes, in the mistaken belief that the NKVD would be too embarrassed by their nakedness to haul them out.
Another interpretation of the naked corspes is that they have been hung from gallows, on orders from Lenin. We just don’t know.
5. When the newly elected and first President of the new Russian Federation, Boris Yeltzin was elected in June 1991, he ordered in August that the files of the KGB be opened. It was from this time, for a while, that historians had relatively free access to study documents never seen before. Lenin’s ‘Hanging Order’ was one of those documents. There would have been many other damning documents from the pen of Lenin, but there had been several removals of politically sensitive documents over the years, usually following a power struggle within the Politburo. In other instances, some damning documents survived in the most strange of circumstances, such as the documentation discovered in a church in the Tambov area in 1982 detailing the orders of the suppression of the 1920 – 1921 organised peasant uprising a few hundred miles south east of Moscow in the Tambov area, where chemical warfare was used by the Marxist-Leninists. In 2004 the material was finally written up.
The cost of sending a postcard in Britain was relatively stable between 1956 to decimalisation in 1971. In the examples below, between 1956 to 1968, a period of 12 years, the price increased by one penny. (The going 1956 rate of two pence (2d.) had first been introduced in 1940. It was increased to 3d in 1965.)
The new 1971 decimal rate 0f sending a postcard doubled overnight, from 3d to the equivalent of 6d (2½p.) Even allowing for the inflation of the 1970s, the cost of sending a postcard sky-rocketed. By 1986 it was 12 new pence – a touch under 2/6d, that is: a touch under 30 old pennies per postcard. The feeling at the time that the introduction of decimalisation in 1971 led to some financial shenanigans in public and private sector pricing was not always wide of the mark.
Nairn, 1956.
_____
Bournemouth, 1957.
_____
Minard Castle, 1960.
_____
Leven, Fife. 1960.
_____
Cirencester, 1962.
_____
Bournemouth, Central Gardens. 1968.
_____
Loch Rannoch and Schiehallion, Perthshire. 1968.
_____
The Sea Front, Anderby Creek, Lincolnshire. 1972.
_____
Girvan, Ayrshire. 1974
_____
Banf from MacDuff. 1975.
_____
Mountain and River – The Sma’ Glen, Perthshire. 1979.
_____
Best wishes from Scotland. 1986.
And, if you still send a postcard – rather than a photo from your mobile – Royal Mail will charge you 97p, a touch under one pound, if you send it to Germany, or any other European country. If, however, you send a postcard from Germany to the UK (at the time of writing, November 2014), Deutsche Post will charge you 75 cents. At present conversion rates, that is 59p.
Greetings from Germany, April, 1958.
“We are having a wonderful time, going sight-seeing this afternoon. Food is marvellous. Everybody is very friendly and helpful. Going to the night clubs to-night, the bottom right hand photo is the street of 1000 night clubs!! Quite a place……” (Reeperbahn, in St.Pauli)
At it’s peak, in the Edwardian period, the picture postcard was the 2014 equivalent of the mobile phone text and photo. As some Royal Mail delivery services may soon be history (there have been noises about their pulling out of some rural deliveries), and as stands of picture postcards spin forlornly in the occasional gust of wind on British seaside fronts (yellowing each summer), and costing up to 50% less than the stamp you put on it, Le Patron will post occasional pieces inspired by the picture postcard.
The letters between Mother and Daughter span 1939 – 1950, and are now being published every Friday. This is the link to the book –lendarlinggirl.com– and here is an extract from Part Two 3 Life As Medicine. Len, born in Scotland, is working for the Ministry of Supply in Cairo. She is a shorthand typist, and is 21.
Part Two 3: Life As Medicine
“Some of the English girls don’t seem alive at all – they take life as a sort of medicine.” – Vera, a young Russian, quoted by Len, 28 August, 1947.
18 August, 1947. Cairo.
Hello my Darlings,
You’re such a joy to me, for when I hear from you I realise more than ever how much you both mean to me. Your letters are – well it’s almost like talking to you and believe me that’s what I need. 18th of August, one says the date to oneself, thinks of ones longing for ones people and the U.K. and on the other side the need for money and the other things which keep one in this Lotus Land.
I know how you feel about the “10lb look” (apologies to Barrie), but I really do want to lose it and E. is the only person who agrees with me – everyone else says I’m alright and that once plump always plump, which is a fallacy and inspired by lazy defeatists. I do need some one else to want me lose weight too and the incentive of the studio portrait is a help. Also re. dignity, it’s there O.K., you needn’t worry about that and he knows it. After all, I’ve told him to be charming and outwardly he hasn’t taken any offence and really that’s an awful lot more for him to do than me to lose 10lb and put on some nail polish. N’est ce pas?
In his last letter Ernst mentions Canada with quite a lot of keenness, I’m rather glad. He received your letter Mum and told me he was replying in a few days, I expect you have his letter by now.
Buying the house – what’s noo? I want us to have the house, and us all (inc. E) to go to Canada. The house is an asset and why shouldn’t we be ‘men of property’ even if we’re elsewhere. Our schemes are nebulous, but it’s better to have such schemes which can be adapted or suddenly clarify than no scheme at all.
Thanks so much for all your letters, I have them all to 187. It’s grand to get the dough, I’m exchanging some of it with U.K. bound people like Betty Mac who think they’ll find it useful. The Black Market could not be found, so I changed all my dough at the ninety seven and a half touch, found it maddening, but what could I do. (1)
Pat was at Ish at the week-end. (2) As you know I don’t propose going away till Ernst’s birthday at the end of September , so sometime in October I want to go to Ish.
Right now I’m busy collecting addresses in U.K. for everyone seems to be going that way, naturally I’ve given our address, so you’d better prepare for people popping in.
On Sunday after breakfast – which we had about 8.30 I went over to the Stokes. I talked to them for a while, then walked with them across to Gezira – whilst they went on to Wilcox.
Guess who I met in Gezira – Major Wallace. You remember I met him in the Fort William-Glencoe bus in September, 1945 and on the steps of the “Britannia” gangplank for a few minutes on the morning of a riot in February 1946 (3)
He’s a gem of a man and one to whom the adjective charming can be fearlessly applied. I do wish you could meet him Mum, for honest you’d get on together so well. He went into raptures when I said you came from Dornoch. I s’pose I said it in a cold Anglified way and when he repeated it after me, (in rapture) he really rolled it around his tongue and practically made a poem out of the word.
He was telling me his daughter of 18 has just left Roedean (you know, the school) and was starting on a tour of Scotland with her cousin and was also going to the Musical Festival at Edinburgh (the people I know who are going there – lucky so-and-sos – Ethel Wilson, Olga Rundall, co-voyager-out, etc.). (4)
He also told me about her playing the violin, whereupon I said “Oh, was it her picture in the Sphinx”. And it was. (5)
Mr Wallace as he is now took me out of the sun for this conversation and got me one of those gorgeous jugs of shandy. He was telling me that some pals and he have 16,000 acres in Cyprus and export to Britain and all about. As it’s a Crown Colony they have Imperial Preference etc. He told me too of all the car trips all over Europe which he’s done and was giving me various alternative itineraries for hitching home. I was talking to him also of the Summer Isles out from Gruinard Bay in Wester Ross and of Barrie’s “Marie Rose” being centred around one of them. (6)
He’s a pensioned official of the Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada and now acts in a freelance capacity. I just wish I could really get in with his family. I’d be car-ing home then next year if I’d my way. However, he made a most charming companion for a short while.
As I’d had a lot of sun I slept for a little in the Ladies’ Lounge after looking at my French verbs, then went across to Wilcox for tea with the Stokes. It was lovely sitting there under the trees and they insisted I go back to supper with them.
My Digs. Of course I knew snags were bound to arise and they’re arising. The room is excellent and so are the breakfasts. However here are some points of interest, and of complaint, three of them:
1. This morning her clock was wrong and her watch was wrong, – about 20 mins. to half an hour. In consequence I missed the bus.
2. Last night I got in from the Stokes about 11.30 (as you know Mum, early for Cairo). She’d given me a key , but lo and behold although it turned, I couldn’t get in for the door was bolted. Of course she let me in, but this morning suggested I let her know when I was going to be late, I said I didn’t know, where upon she said I could phone her, but I intend doing no such thing, for it’s not as if she’s got to alter meals, my having b&b.
3. The other night she suddenly intimated she wanted her money in advance. I mentioned this in passing to the Stokes. I’ve 50Pt. to pay for this fortnight (i.e. the balance of £5, half of the month’s dough – from 15th to end of the month), and Mr Stokes says I should pay this at the end of the month and tell her she’s getting the rest of the money at the end of each of the month and not in advance. Her argument is that she pays for everything in advance. Mr Stokes says that’s not my worry and they pay everything in advance, but Mr W. pays them at the end of the month. He says too she can’t hold a pistol to my head as they are all desperate for people just now, not like the war years when they had the upper hand. He says I stand to lose a month’s dough and the principle of the thing’s bad.
The Stokes were dears the way they championed my cause unasked and they also said if she says I’ve got to go I can bunk in with them for a while, so I intend to stand firm – wish me luck. I don’t mention all this for sympathy, but because I know it’ll interest you. I t’s part of the growing up process I hadn’t encountered before.
People keep on asking for bulletins about you Mum, they’re not content with knowing you got home safely at all almost want day to day bulletins.
Anything you want from the Musky , as I hope to go down there at the beginning of next month? (7).
I was nearly ill when I read the description of your accident on the DM.(8). Please take care of her Dad. Remember all those lovely plans can mature without money, but one must have ones health, for you can’t fight without that.
Good gracious, is the leopard skin ready all ready? Don’t work too hard at it Mum. Unless I receive your wee slip giving gen on thread I won’t get it on Thursday, for I daresay I’ll be going into town again pretty soon, after that. Thanks so much for your letter of comfort (re. E and me) I feel a new woman. (9)
I don’t mind you telling the people you said you’d tell about my homecoming and am with you in what you say about them – they are nice types. It’s just this dislike of the Reid-Ballantine clan which overwhelms my outlook – sorry. I know how you feel about the announcement angle Mum and can sense you’re feeling of wanting to tell the world we’re doing all right, but just ignore that clan, we don’t alter our behaviour for them. (10). I feel so strongly that E must have a good long holiday (and only hope he does) in our lovely land and that it will do him so much good and take away all that ME (11) tension and you know it’s with this thought in mind and the hope that it’ll be gratified that makes me feel a bit tense myself waiting for the months to slip by, wanting UK, wanting the dough I get out here to save and wanting E and you two all at the same time.
Must close this letter now and get it off – it’s 19th now.
Your own most loving Len xxxx
____________________________________________
1. Len is converting her British sterling to Egyptian Pounds.
2. Ish: Ishmailia, seventy miles to the north east of Cairo, on the west bank of the Suez Canal. Nearby was a RAF camp, which today is used by the Egyptian airforce.
3. From a news report of the time, 21 February, 1946: ‘Riots Erupt in Cairo. British troops in Cairo today opened fire on angry crowds demanding an end to foreign influence. Twelve people are reported to have been killed and over 100 wounded’. There had also been protests in the Suez Canal Zone, beginning in December 1945. The protests reached their peak in Cairo, as reported above, in February, 1946. The Turf Club in Cairo, for instance, was set alight by protestors and eleven members died. British Army casualties during this period have been put at 33 soldiers killed and 69 wounded.
4. This was the first Edinburgh Festival.
5. A Cairo English language paper for the Brits.
6: Unknown to either of them, Gruinard Island, in Gruinard Bay, had been lethally toxic since 1942, and remained toxic until declared safe in 1990. Scientists from the Chemical and Biological Warfare Station at Porton Down, Wiltshire, had released a virulent strain of anthrax on the island, killing sheep that had been tethered. The conclusion was that anthrax bombs dropped on German cities would be very successful, apart from the problem that the cities would remain toxic wastelands for years. Len, in 1949, would be working at Porton Down.
7. Musky: the Arab market quarter. Variant spellings exist. Cecil Beaton in his Near East (1943) spells it Moski.
8. Mum had tripped or fallen and pulled a ligament.
9. This letter of comfort is not in this collection.
10. Mum’s sister Ena was married to Bill Reid. Their brother Dennis was married to Euphemia Ballantine – Aunt Phem. The cause for Len’s dislike of them is unknown. The ‘home coming’ is when Len’s tour of duty in Cairo would be over; the ‘announcement’ is more than just her returning to Scotland – Len and Ernst were engaged.
Photos taken in the former DDR 2000 – 2009, using German cameras made between 1932 and 1959. All photos by Pete Grafton, except where stated.
The Deutsche Demokratische Republik: DDR (German Democratic Republic: GDR), a one party Marxist-Leninist satellite state of the Soviet Union was established on 7 October 1949. It’s guarantee of ‘legitimacy’ was the Soviet Union and the Soviet Army armed forces. These forces were used in 1953 to suppress the protests and industrial actions of DDR workers and farmers protesting against the government imposed working conditions and output expectations. In 1961 the Marxist-Leninist government built the Berlin Wall, and a national boundary concentration camp fence that ran from the Baltic in the north to the Czechoslovakian border in the south to keep their own citizens in. The Stasi, the secret police, meanwhile developed a labyrinth of spying on virtually all the citizens of the Democratic Republic, pressurising, or blackmailing it is estimated, by some, of up to one third of citizens to spy on each other. The collapse of the Democratic Republic, along with the other satellite states (Poland, Czechoslavakia, Hungary) became inevitable when the Soviet Union First Secretary, Gorbachev told (in secret) the First Secretaries of these states that they would no longer be guaranteed the armed intervention of Soviet Union forces to uphold the legitimacy of their regimes.
Summer celebrations leading up to the 40th anniversary of the DDR, 1989. Photo: Harald Hauswald
Four weeks after the 40th anniversary of the founding of the DDR, and with First Secretary Honecker boasting of the improvements that were going to be made to take the Berlin Wall into the 21st Century, the Berlin Wall was breached on 9 November 1989. In the months following, some of the DDR Central Committee hastened to the safety of Moscow, including First Secretary Honecker, who then, with others, followed in the 1945 footsteps of some German National Socialists, and made their way to South America. Following multi-party elections in March 1990, the reunification of the West German Federal Republic and the German Democratic Republic took place in October 1990.
2000
From the train, Hamburg to Berlin, passing through the former DDR
The main railway line between Hamburg and Berlin ran through the DDR and the track was deliberately kept on low maintenance (it was the main link to the Federal Republic ) by the DDR. The station buildings , however, reflected the low maintenance of all buildings in the DDR. In 2000, ten years after reunification, many of the small farmyards viewed from the carriage window still had a DDR built Trabant parked next to the tractor. The former DDR border was not so far east of Hamburg, and a sure sign one had crossed into it was the characteristic low slung national grid electricity pylons, that seemed to only just clear the trees in the meadows and flat farmland. Berlin FC arriving back at Berlin Schönefeld Airport, following a 3 – 1 defeat against Barcelona, March 2000. Berlin FC, a DDR team, almost went under following reunification because of lack of financial support in the new German republic. They clawed their way back and continue to have a strong fan base similar to that of Hamburg’s St.Pauli FC. Berlin Schönefeld was the DDR Berlin airport.
2007
Schwerin in the former DDR is to the east of Hamburg, and is a comfortable day trip away, using the Hamburg Haupbahnhof to Rostock (on the Baltic) train. Online picture searches of Schwerin show photos of the ‘picture book’ palace in its large grounds with the lakes. In 2007, however, away from the Palace – now the administrative centre for the state of Mecklenburg-Vorpomern – Schwerin was a town that architecturally was a striking reminder of pre-war Germany, and the post war DDR. Both eras in March, 2007 were bathed in dust and decay. One or two streets and their buildings in the centre had been spruced up with fresh plaster and repointed brickwork and bright coats of paint, but round the corner, any corner in town was the reminder of a national socialist and Marxist-Leninist socialist imprint. A Federal German 1955 manufactured Agfa medium format camera took the pictures. The train from Hamburg was almost like a ghost train – few passengers. A group of black men (for that is how they identified themselves) from Africa moved through the open compartment, saying to another group (using English as their common language) that there was “more black men” near the front of the train. The got off onto an empty platform in the middle of the flat countryside at a station called Hagenow, 30 km from Schwerin. It seemed to be stranded in the flat countryside, with a lone round brick tower as the only landmark. My curiosity aroused, I saw from the timetable that I could get off at Hagenow on the return to Hamburg, and pick up another train an hour later. When I got off on the returning train there were no signs of the black men. There were no signs of anyone. A goods train passing through Hagenow Bahnhof. The only sign of life. Work in progress: a new underpass at Hagenow Bahnhof, linking the platforms. Note the coiled power cabling. Locked sheds by Hagenow Bahnhof, a few metres across the tracks. A few more metres from here was a road, a quiet road, and some houses, possibly railway worker, or ex- railway worker housing. As I was taking this photograph a man in his eighties passed by on a path, and paused. He liked my camera. He said that he too used to have an Agfa. Given his age, it would have been one from before the war, before the creation of the DDR. “Berlin ruft de Jugend” – “Berlin summons the youth”.
Empty schnapps bottles, Hagenow.
2008
A lot of West German money was being spent renewing and bringing up to date the infrastructure of the former DDR. Wage earning citizens of western Germany were, and are still taxed (2014) towards the costs of this continuing work. Examples obvious to a visitor is the upgrading of the railway network – new stations, track, signalling and rolling stock. This is one of many, many examples. However, even eighteen years after reunification, the physical skin of the old DDR was still everywhere in 2008, including Berlin. Helsingforser Strasse, near the Sunflower Backpacker hostel. Ostkreuz S Bahn station, Berlin. Ostkreuz S Bahn station, Berlin. DDR Weighing Machine, S Bahn, Berlin. The new Berlin Haupbahnhof (Central Station), viewed from near the restored Reichstag – the German parliament since reunification.
2009
DDR design: Lampshade in room, Weimar, June 2009. Open window, Weimar, June 2009. Fly Me to the Moon, Weimar. The new indoor Atrium shopping centre, Weimar. Taken on a 1932 Ikonta, manufactured in nearby Jena. Street scene near the new Atrium indoor shopping centre. Note the tourist landau bottom left of picture. Nationalist Socialist (Nazi) buildings, near the Atrium indoor shopping centre, Weimar. In June 2009 they were being renovated, for a possible use as offices. Although Weimar gave its name to the democratic multi-party German Weimar Republic, 1919 – 1933, it was an early centre of Nationalist Socialist activity and support. Weimar had a special significance for National Socialists because of the association with Schiller and Goethe, symbols of German culture and civilisation. The Hitler Youth movement was started in Weimar, and it is said that in the 1933 elections 50% of the voting population of Weimar supported the National Socialists. The local No.6 bus to Buchenwald from Weimar. Buchenwald, and the site of the concentration camp, is on a wooded hill a few miles to the north of the town. However, like other former regional DDR administrative states, Thuringia, which includes Weimar and Jena and Erfurt, a notable number of voters revealingly support Die Linke (The Left) party since its formation in 2007. Political Party posters in Weimar, June 2009. “No Nazis in Weimar”. Poster in the centre of Weimar, June 2009.
The vote for the Left Party, in both elections to the European Parliament and legislative elections within the German federation in 2009 showed a striking split between the former West Germany and East Germany.
“The party was founded in 2007 as the merger of the post-communist Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS), successor to the Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED) that ruled East Germany until 1989, and the Electoral Alternative for Labour and Social Justice (WASG), a left-wing breakaway from the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD).” – Wikipedia
Within the former East Germany there is still a discussion amongst a significant number of people about the kind of society that they want. Many are unhappy about a society based on profit as a gaol and competitiveness. Many (and not just some of the older generation) value aspects of a socialist society with its equitable goals. There was a discussion in 1989 and 1990 within some of the community in eastern Germany that the former DDR should remain separate from the West German Federal Republic, and establish its own multi-party democratic state.
In Thuringia in the Legislative Elections of 2009 the results were: Christian Democrats 31.2%; Social Democrats 17.6%; Liberals (Right wing free market) 9.8%; Greens 6% and the Left Party 28.8%.
20 years after the Berlin Wall was breached the striking difference in support for the Left Party in the 2009 elections between the former Federal West and DDR East is shown in results such as these, from a sample of former DDR local regions, compared with a sample of former West German Federal Republic regions:
2009
Former DDR
Thuringia 28.8%; Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania 29%; Berlin 20.5%; Saxony 24.5%
Former West German Federal Republic
Bavaria 6.5%; Schleswig-Holstein 7.9%; Hamburg 11.2%
In 2013 the appeal of Die Linke (The Left) in the former DDR was, on the whole, only slightly less. It is difficult to know whether the slight dip reflects an ageing population dying in eastern Germany, or whether there were other factors at work.
2013
Former DDR
Thuringia 23.4%; Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania 21.5%; Berlin 18.5%; Saxony 20.0%
Former West German Federal Republic
Bavaria 3.8%; Schleswig-Holstein 5.2%; Hamburg 8.8%
At a Garden Party in Weimar in June 2009 these were some of the issues talked about, along with a resentment, from some, that salaries for teachers, in eastern Germany were less than teachers in western Germany. This was a reflection of the occasional tensions that occur between Ossis and Wessis. (‘Easties’ and ‘Westies’) Jena, to the east of Weimar is home to Carl Zeiss, manufacturers of cameras, lenses and optical equipment. Of the former DDR towns and cities I visited since 2000, it was in the summer of 2009 the one that seemed – superficially to a visitor – the one that was the most vibrant.
There were still reminders of the former DDR – a Trabant parked in Carl Zeiss Place, and the monolithic buildings, but there was a freshness too.
photo on display: Harald Hauswald
Carl Zeiss optical innovators and manufacturers has been in Jena since the nineteenth century. During the economically depressed 1920’s it merged with and absorbed other German optical and camera manufacturers to become Zeiss Ikon. It already had world leading camera lenses such as the Zeiss Tessar lens, and their lenses were fitted on the medium format Rolleiflex cameras. In the late 1930’s they introduced the Contax rangefinder camera that many argued was a better camera with a better lens than the Leica rangefinder. (There were reliability problems, due to complex engineering, though).
After the war Jena like the rest of Eastern Germany came under Soviet control and industrial plant throughout the Soviet zone was dismantled and sent back to the USSR, including manufacturing capacity at Zeiss Ikon. Carl Zeiss with some of its technicians established itself in the south west of Germany, in the Federal Republic. But in Eastern Germany Carl Zeiss Jena remained, and the quality lens and the cameras that it started to produce again, and develop, were a valuable and desperately needed hard currency export for the DDR. Unlike most other DDR manufactured products Carl Zeiss Jena cameras – which included the Werra and then the Praktica range, amongst others – were well put together.
When I walked out of the Jena railway station in the summer of 2009 a taxi driver in the stance across the road spotted my Werra and shouted across “Is that a Werra?” “Naturally”, I replied, and he beamed back. Since reunification Carl Zeiss has also reunited, manufacturing photographic lenses, optical lenses, specialist glass and other products, either as Carl Zeiss, Jenoptic or Schott AG.
photo on display: Harald Hauswaldphotos on display: Harald Hauswald
photos on display: Harald Hauswald
June, 2009, the Goethe Gallery, Jena: Exhibition of photos by Harald Hauswald, taken from his book Seitenwechsel, published by Aufbau Verlag. (Roughly translated: Seitenwechsel = Changeover)
The Coen Bros Inside Llewyn Davis – some aspects loosely based on the early life of Dave Van Ronk – might have been an even more interesting film of a person and a time and a place if it had drawn on the story of another, younger, American folk singer. Unlike Dave Van Ronk he wrote his own material and Nick Drake recorded more tunes of his than any other singer-songwriter of that era. The tracks from his one, and only LP, produced in London, are now registering over 100,000 hits on You Tube. His name was Jackson C Frank.
“FRANK, Jackson C (b. ’43, Buffalo, NY) USA singer/songwriter infl. in London during mid-’60s folk boom. Songs covered by Sandy Denny, Bert Jansch, Fairport Convention; Frank himself made only one LP Jackson C Frank; ’65, reissued ’78: cult classic prod. Paul Simon, second guitar played by a young Al Stewart; incl. best known song ‘Blues Run The Game’ (world-weary gem of genre), eight other originals. Regular feature on folk club circuit; once shared flat with Denny, Simon, Art Garfunkel; began work on second LP ’68 but never completed it. Said to have been badly injured in fire at Woodstock home. Jansch called him ‘as influential as Bob Dylan’ in mid-’60s; evidence of album suggests great ability unfulfilled.“
– unattributed entry in Penguin Encyclopedia of Popular Music, First Edition, 1990.
He’d caught a boat to England in early 1965, and it was briefly in England that he made his mark. By the mid 1970s, back in the U.S., he had virtually disappeared off the scene and his life became a sad and tragic decline. He died in near obscurity in 1999. This is a recollection of those autumn months in 1965 that were leading up to the release in December of his CBS album, produced by Paul Simon, and beyond into the early summer of 1966, when Jackson moved out of his Twickenham, London flat, possibly to be with Sandy Denny.
Vietnam and James Baldwin
In 1965 in Britain women still wore stockings and suspender belts. Men had to buy condoms in gents barbers shops. Tears was the biggest selling hit single, sung by the north of England comic Ken Dodd. The National Anthem was still played at the end of the pictures and Le Patron was shouted at, after watching Judy Dench in Four in the Morning, for not standing still as it played, as he made his way to the exit. (In anticipation of the National Anthem most cinema goers quickly shuffled out of the fire exit doors into the street, or the foyer, as the credits rolled, whilst some women discretely headed for the Ladies to re-arrange their underwear after two hours of snogging and groping in the back row).
And an American, Jackson C Frank sailed on a boat to England to buy a 1952 Bentley, a long wheel base Land Rover and an Aston Martin DB5. He also brought a Martin guitar with him, and Katherine Henry his girlfriend came too. (Well… that’s the Wikipedia version, and that of some other potted biographies.)
In the U.S. in 1965 the Democratic Party government sent 50,000 troops to Vietnam, as American involvement increased from USAAF bombing and reconnaissance. In the American South civil rights activists were killed by white supremacists, and in the Watts area of Los Angeles, in August 1965, 28 people died in race riots.
The biggest film of the year was Mary Poppins, making more money than the other big 1965 hit film, Sound of Music, both featuring Julie Andrews. Dr Zhivago with Julie Christie and Omar Shariff was popular too. The Beatles second feature film – in colour – Help! had come out that summer. Clint Eastwood, the former TV cowboy, was having his second significant big screen outing in For a Few Dollars More (A Fistful of Dollars had been released in 1964). Away from the mainstream there were interesting films such as Roman Polanski’s Repulsion, exteriors edgily shot in the streets of South Ken, and Michael Caine was on the ascendency in The Ipcress File, a year before 1966’s Alfie.
But still you needed to go into a gents hairdressers to furtively buy condoms (and not get a haircut). And Levi jeans were hard to find (and expensive).
Jackson C Frank’s black Bentley saloon, his dark green Land Rover, and silver Aston Martin DB5 were parked outside 50 Cole Park Road, St Margarets, Twickenham. Cole Park Road was a leafy suburban road of mostly large detached houses, built in the interwar period on the fields of Middlesex, an area that soon became known as south west London.
Acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey. Revision date: 1954-1955.
Jackson could have flown into Heathrow, just a few miles to the north north-west of Twickenham. (Also built, after the Second World War, on the meadows of Middlesex.) Pan Am had started the first regular New York – London Heathrow flights in 1958. Jackson could have afforded the flight.
Acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey. Revision date: 1954 – 1955
When he was ten he was attending a school in Buffalo, New York.
“The brand new school was made out of brick but it had a wooden annexe that was used for music instruction. It was heated by a big furnace. One day during music lessons the furnace blew up. I was almost killed on that day. Most of my classmates were killed. I spent seven months in hospital recovering from the burns.” (Quoted in CD liner notes by Colin Harper, Jackson C Frank, Blues Run the Game, “Expanded Deluxe Edition”, 2003)
Jackson after the explosion, with Elvis at Graceland
In 1964, at the age of 21 Jackson was entitled to the insurance payout from the fire: $110, 500. He and a friend headed for Toronto, Canada, spending as they went “… I bought a Jaguar straight out of a showroom.” Returning to Buffalo he decided to catch a boat – and not take the plane – to England, in April 1965.
Jackson’s life around this time is not – it seems – quite as Wikipedia, and some other sources, report. He did catch a boat – the Cunard Queen Elizabeth – from New York to Southampton, but it was in February, and not April. And the reason he bought a ticket was because his girlfriend of two years, Katherine Henry, was looking for a way to get out of the relationship. Unable to say she was calling it off, she booked a ticket to escape to England. But when Jackson found out, he booked a ticket too. She still found it difficult to say “It’s off”, and she recalls they spent a lot of the Queen Elizabeth journey in one of the onboard bars, drunk. She told her story in 2009 to Andrew Male in Mojo 186. (1)
They stayed in the The Strand Palace, which she recalls was across the road from the Savoy, where Dylan had stayed. They lived in Twickenham, until she returned to the U.S. in June 1965, to have an abortion. Jackson accompanied her. She didn’t come back. Jackson did. She said she found his intensity, his imagined slights too heavy. She says there was an element of paranoia – centred on Jackson imaging that she was only interested in him because of his insurance money – that was not easy to deal with. But they had some good times, too. She described their few months in Twickenham as pretty domesticated. They occasionally went off on a trip, once to Whitby on the Yorkshire coast.
Katherine and Jackson, Whitby. Sometime between March and June, 1965. Attributed to/Source: Richard Stanley
At some point they met Tom Paxton, who was also over from the States, with his wife and living in London. Paul Simon was another young singer songwriter who had arrived in London in 1964. There was a lively folk club scene in Britain particularly in London. Besides the traditional folk scene, there was an emerging folk new wave of interesting guitar stylists and singer-songwriters. Davy Graham’s Folk Blues and Beyond had been issued on Decca in January 1965, and Bert Jansch had his first LP out on Topic by the Spring. There is no indication of where Katherine and Jackson were living those few months together in Twickenham. But when Fan, Pussy, Sue and Doreen moved into the ground floor of 50 Cole Park Road in September, 1965, for the second year of their teacher training at the nearby all female Maria Grey College, Jackson was living upstairs with a young English woman called Caroline, and the three cars were parked outside. No biographies of Jackson mention Cole Park Road, or Caroline.
Up until the summer of 1965 Jackson was an unknown singer-songwriter. Although he’d played with friends in Buffalo he was reportedly training to be a local journalist when he received his insurance pay-out. Katherine recalls that when she moved back to the States she heard that he had started playing a lot more in folk clubs: her leaving him had broken the couple cocoon the two of them were in. Although shy, he started playing regularly at Les Cousins, and other London folk clubs. He started to be a face on the scene.
He seemingly would give visiting American folkies – including Dave Von Ronk – a drive around London in one of his cars.
Although he had been known to have been singing traditional folk material in Buffalo Le Patron speculates that his self-penned repertoire expanded on the back of Katherine leaving him. Catch a Boat to England was possibly written just after they arrived in England, when he was still with Kathleen, as was Yellow Walls, but other songs, for instance You Never Wanted Me, is a cert to have been written after she decided to stay in the U.S. in June. He recorded it in December.
Le Patron first visited 50 Cole Park Road in late September, 1965, and moved in in early November, he and Doreen having begun a relationship. The girls went off most mornings to college whilst Le Patron had already left a couple of hours earlier. He was working as a labourer in the building maintenance section of a slightly dodgy property company, on jobs all over London, from Chelsea, to Finchley to Walton on Thames.
Doreen and Kate, a regular visitor. The lounge, downstairs at 50 Cole Park Road. Photo: Pete GraftonFan, Cole Park Road. Photo: Pete Grafton.Kate, Cole Park Road. Photo: Pete Grafton.
Fan and Kate, after a Saturday shopping raid on Biba’s, Kensington. Yoghurts from Express Dairies.
It was a peculiarity of the time that there was a vibrant music scene in the Twickenham/Middlesex, Richmond/Surrey, west south west London area. Down the road in Richmond the Stones two years before had been regulars at the Station Hotel, and their spot had been filled by the Yardbirds by 1965. The Who regularly played to the north in Wealdstone and there was a regular venue at the Jolly Rogers, Isleworth, with the likes of Geno Washington and the Ram Jam Band, and Zoot Money and the Big Roll Band playing in the area. Eel Pie Island, in the Thames, was a fifteen minute walk from Cole Park Road, where Long John Baldry and the Hoochie Coochie Men played, along with visiting black blues and folk artists such as Jessie Fuller. Around this time Sandy Denny, still a nurse, was singing solo in the Kingston folk club, and Maria Grey college that Doreen, Fan, Sue and Pussy, and Kate, attended also regularly booked folk singers.
One Saturday night at the Maria Grey College Le Patron saw a double bill of, first on, a young lean Bert Jansch, and after the interval, Paul Simon. Although it wasn’t a contest, Bert won it by a mile. Bert just played, whilst Paul Simon pontificated and blethered between numbers. He was wearing the “I’m a purist folk singer” halo (he had the neat haircut and the fine wool pullover to go with it) and he got tore into Marianne Faithful for being on RSG (Ready Steady Go) the night before, covering something he used to sing, but she used strings!!! – lush orchestral strings!
It sounds as if anyone in work and earning, and at the age of 20 and into music would be having a rip-roaring time living in the Twickenham area in 1965. But it wasn’t necessarily like that. Besides anything else, even if it did cost two to ten bob (ten to fifty pence) to go to listen to a band or individual, the going rate for an unskilled worker, whether in the building trade, or working in shops or cafes hovered around 5 bob (twenty five pence) an hour. Le Patron was on 5/4d an hour.
Le Patron, 50 Cole Park Road. Photo: Kate MacPhail
A take home pay of around £10 didn’t go far, particularly if you weren’t living at home and having to pay rent. For a single person too, income tax ferociously ate into your gross earnings, or that’s how it seemed when you worked with seasonal students who’d get all they’d been taxed back in the autumn, or aware of what the married blokes take home pay was.
Le Patron was, too, (besides being knackered after work) ploughing the anti-social, introverted furrow at this time, labouring over books on existentialism, and other mind-expanding tomes that he hoped would explain what it ‘was all about’. He enjoyed the company in the downstairs flat, and one of the girls would ask him to do posters for the folk gigs at the college. But like Jackson and Kathleen had been, he and Doreen were in their own couple cocoon, which was no bad thing.
Le Patron had very early on, when asking who the expensive cars belonged to, learned from the girls that an American folk singer lived upstairs, with someone called Caroline. Le Patron doesn’t know what the furrow Jackson was ploughing, but it was a quiet one. He was rarely seen and rarely heard. No sound of him playing, of trying out a new song, no sound of a radio. Very quiet. No creaking floorboards above. No crashing up and down the stairs. The recollection was that he was shy, that he was polite, and he had a warm fleeting smile. You rarely caught a snatch of conversation between him and Caroline upstairs, and they never used the downstairs garden for drying clothes, or relaxing in the sun come Spring and early summer 1966.
Caroline was a southern Home Counties young woman, with the good bone structure, and the quiet air of someone who had been to a girls boarding school (and hadn’t rebelled). And yet, by living with a man and not being married, and living with an American, and a folk singer, even if he had money, was rebellion enough in 1965. She had dark, straight hair, and like Jackson was quiet. In her case maybe it was Home Counties reserve, rather than shyness. Jackson was 22 at this time, and she was around the same age.
As noted, Le Patron was ploughing the anti-social furrow. It would be the girls who would nip upstairs to ask Jackson to sign their copy of his just released LP, or to get a visiting Tom Paxton to sign a poster Le Patron had done for the gig he’d just done that evening.
Tom Paxton gig at the Maria Grey College, 31st January, 1966. Poster: Pete Grafton
“I was in London/Richmond/Soho during 65/66. One evening I was performing playing blues at Les Cousins. Al Stewart was also playing that night – and after my set I was approached by the legendary Judith Piepe who asked me to move in with her, Paul Simon, Al Stewart – and Jackson C Frank. For reasons that now escapes me I said ‘No’ – I must have been mad. This was before the album (Jackson C Frank) but after Bert and John (Renbourn) had started singing ‘Blues Run the Game’. I used to hang around Potters Music Shop at the bottom of Richmond Hill where Jackson used to trade guitars. One of my friends bought one of his Martins.
I remember a particular night at Maria Grey College in St Margarets. The star performer was Tom Paxton and I found myself standing next to Jackson in a very crowded room. I was struck by the severity of his scars – and suddenly he turned to me and said that he just had to get out – NOW. It seemed to me at the time that he was claustrophobic – at the time I put it down to the effect of the fire.” – David Freeman (2)
The girls had a party one Saturday evening, either just before Christmas, or just after the New Year, 1966. Jackson and Caroline would have been asked if they wanted to join in, but they kept themselves to themselves. In Jackson’s case, I’m sure out of shyness. Johnny Silvo was there, playing with two others, possibly Wizz Jones and Diz Disley. Le Patron can’t quite remember. A memory of a couple of guitars, one of them possibly a 12 string, and a mandolin. And wearing a bright red Guardsman tunic there was Jeff Beck, the first time Le Patron had seen anything like it. Jeff was there because he’d been asked by a bloke called Bill who was going out with one of the students from the college, and had sung on the chorus of the Yardbirds For Your Love that caused Eric Clapton to decide to move on, and Jeff to become the lead guitar.
Le Patron, during the party, going to the toilet overheard Caroline and Jackson upstairs, leaning over the banisters of the landing, talking about the music: Caroline: What do you think of it.Jackson:Yeah, nice. That was it. Just crumbs of memories of Jackson.
Or the time the front door bell went one Saturday afternoon, and no-one being in, Le Patron answered it. One door bell for both flats. Le Patron opened the front door to two policemen, who were looking for the owner of the cars outside. They wore flat peaked hats, like the drivers out of Z Cars, and a brand new Police Zephyr was parked opposite. Le Patron went up the wide Wilton carpeted stairs and knocked on a door off the landing and Jackson opened it, listened to what Le Patron said, smiled with a nod, and came down. Le Patron went back into the little room Doreen and he shared. And eavesdropped. The little room happened to be the one closest to the front door.
They politely pointed out that two of the cars didn’t have Road Tax, and therefore shouldn’t be parked in the road. That bit over, they asked about the cars, what the top speed of the DB5 was, and all being car enthusiasts Jackson in turn asked about their police Zephyr, was it the latest model….. and so on.
Jackson’s LP was recorded for CBS in their London studio, and produced by Paul Simon. It came out in December 1965, and the girls bought it, and Doreen and Le Patron bought it. Le Patron liked it enough, but emotionally he was too cut off to really hear and feel the intensity of the lyrics. He preferred Davy and Bert’s LPs. As Life is the Great Educator, and not books on existentialism, the emotional power of the lyrics now roots an older Le Patron to the spot, particularly Here Comes The Blues, and Yellow Walls.
Nova magazine. The garden, 50 Cole Park Road. Late Spring – early Summer, 1966. Photo: Pete Grafton.
In the late Spring, early summer of 1966 the news filtered down from upstairs that Jackson and Caroline were moving out. It became known that they were splitting up. The cleaner reported that Caroline was too good for Jackson. There had been no raised voices, no banging doors. Always the same peace. No fore-warning. There was a cleaner for 50 Cole Park Road, as employing one was a condition on the lease, for both flats. The house was owned, it seems, by a BOAC pilot, who’s austere and unsmiling wife would periodically turn up for a house inspection.
With the girls being at college during the day, and Le Patron being out at work, one day we returned to an empty space in front of the house where the cars used to be, and a couple of tea chests in the downstairs hall with a note to say “Help Yourselves”. It was mostly bits of crockery, and kitchen utensils. Amongst it Le Patron found Jackson’s AA Member’s Handbook for 1965. With its town and city centre maps, and distances between towns, and the atlas, Le Patron figured that it would be handy when hitching, so he took it.
At present there is no note or biographical detail of where he moved to next in London, nor is it clear if he and Sandy Denny moved in with each other. On the latter the probability seems that they didn’t. Neither is it known if Sandy, wittingly or unwittingly, was the cause of the separation between Jackson and Caroline. Or whether, like Katherine, Caroline found aspects of Jackson’s personality ‘difficult’.
The girls and Doreen and Le Patron moved out around late June/July and went their separate ways, Doreen deciding to give up teacher training. By 1967 Doreen and Le Patron had moved to Glasgow, and discovered one or two folk there had heard of Jackson C Frank – and what was to become one of Le Patron’s best friends even had a copy of the LP. The signed copy of the LP that Doreen and Le Patron had disappeared in a squat.
Over the years you’d bump into someone who knew his music, and you’d both ask: “I wonder what happened to him?” Occasionally there would be something on the telly to remind you of him: Billy Connolly holding a copy of Jackson’s LP, and saying how great it was. What happened only started to trickle out on the back of interest in Sandy Denny a while after her death, and the growing reputation of Nick Drake, decades after his death.
The 2003 double CD release of Blues Run The Game ‘Expanded Deluxe Edition’ on Castle, with liner notes by Colin Harper was the start of the wider interest in Jackson. Colin highlighted the role of Jim Abbott who befriended Jackson and found him sheltered accommodation in Woodstock. (3)
The awareness of Jackson accelerated with the CD releases of Where The Time Goes, Sandy ’67, (2005) and Family Tree, (2007) private recordings by Nick Drake mostly from 1967 and 1968. The Sandy Denny material was drawn from albums she did with Alex Campbell and Johnny Silvo in 1967. She was going out with Jackson around this time. She recorded Jackson’s You Never Wanted Me with Alex Campbell, and Milk and Honey with Johnny Silvo. (4) There was an underlying streak of melancholy in many of Sandy’s songs, typified in her most well known tune Who Knows Where The Time Goes, which she had already written by 1967. Maybe that was something that drew the two of them together for a while.
Nick Drake recorded on his Philips cassette recorder his renditions of Jackson’s Here Comes The Blues, Blues Run the Game, Milk and Honey, and the traditional song Kimbie, in the style that Jackson had recorded it. Robert Frederick in liner notes draws particular attention to Milk and Honey:
“The unusual melodic phrasing beginning on the third beat of the measure, the guitar picking patterns, the sense of embracing sorrow and accepting loss, even the lyric references to seasons – all of these can be found in Nick’s later songs. In fact, he could have been using Milk and Honey as a template when writing Day is Done – these two songs are musically so similar.”
Like Peter Green, and Nick Drake, for Jackson C Frank, the blues was not a musical style that you picked up and put down at random. It was not a ‘lifestyle’ choice. The explosion at his school caused more than physical scars. The blues, unfortunately for him, truly ran the game. But like Peter Green and Nick Drake he has given a lot of people a lot of pleasure on a scale over the years he could never have anticipated when living in a London suburb in the autumn of 1965.
And you don’t need to buy condoms in gents hairdressers anymore. Or stand for the Queen at the pictures. And black Americans study with white Americans together in southern schools and colleges; can sit where they like on public buses, and use the same public toilets and eat in the same road-stop cafes.
Medgar Evers, prominent Civil Rights Activist, assassinated 1963
And Medgar Evers, who Jackson sang about in Don’t Look Back would have been vindicated, and probably amazed at the man currently using the Executive Toilet in the White House.
There’s still the nuclear weapons (East and West) and excursions into other lands by the major former Second World War Allies, still looking after their interests: Russia, the U.S.A, Britain, France…. Oh well. A step at a time.
Notes
The two most interesting, and probably most accurate recollections of Jackson in London at this time, and after, are the Mojo interview with Katherine Henry, and a recollection by John Renbourn that Le Patron has unfortunately mislaid, but is online somewhere.
The Le Patron recommended CD of Jackson is Jackson C Frank, on Earth Recordings, 2014. This is the 1965 album. The 2003 double CD on Castle – which includes the album – diminishes Jackson’s work for including material that, with one or two exceptions, would never have been issued if he were still alive and well. And that includes the single version of Blues Run The Game, that few liked when bought back in 1965.
Added January, 2017. Blues Run the Game, a film about Jackson C Frank iscurrently in production, directed by Damien Aimé Dupont. A trailer is here: https://vimeo.com/184539090
2. The Dave Freeman recollection is from www.hut-six.co.uk/jcfrank. At the home page click on Link to Memories of Jackson.
3. At the time of writing (May, 2014) the CD is available second-hand at daft prices: £80 upwards! But it is available, or was, as a download from iTunes. The Earth Recordings CD (see above) is available at approx. £8.
4. One of those curious associations, that always crops up, that Johnny Silvo was downstairs and Jackson was upstairs at Cole Park Road, and eighteen months later he is accompanying Sandy Denny singing one of Jackson’s songs.
My thanks to Doreen for sharing her memories of the Cole Park days. And Kate, Fan, Pussy and Sue – if you’re still around – do get in touch.
“Switzerland is a special and fascinating place. Its unique institutions, its direct democracy, multi-member executives, absence of strikes, communal autonomy, its universal military service, its wealth, and four national languages make it interesting in itself. But it has a wider significance, in representing the ‘Europe that did not happen’, the Europe that escaped the centralisation of state and economy associated with the modern world. Today there is a new special feature. Switzerland is an island surrounded by the European Union and resists membership.” – from Why Switzerland?, Jonathan Steinberg, Cambridge University Press.
FASS-90, Swiss made.
“You don’t see where the problem is when every male citizen who has been in the army has an assault rifle (FASS-90) under his bed.” (see You Know You’re Swiss When… below)
Swiss politician corners electorate Photo Pete Grafton
Swiss Facts
Eight million people, 23% of which are “resident foreigners”, a third of this group having Swiss citizenship. A Federal Government, with 26 self-governing cantons, and a seven member cabinet, representing different political parties and a rotating President. Four spoken languages: 63.6 % German; 19.2% French; 7.5% Italian and Romansch 0.6% (40,000 people), plus 8.9 “other languages”. (1990 Census). Those who believe in a God: 38.4% Roman Catholic; 52.8% Protestant; 0.88% Jewish Faith, Hindu and Moslem.
Pinned to a wall in a Lausanne backpacker hostel, some years ago, was the following witty list:
You know you’re Swiss when…
1. You complain if your bus/train,tram is more than five minutes late. Make that 1 minute.
Commuters for Interlaken on the Wengen – Lauterbrunnen cogwheel train, (change at Lauterbrunnen for Interlaken). Photo Elspeth Wight
2. You’ve ever been confused with a Swede.
3. You laugh when Americans believe that Swiss Miss is a Swiss product, but then have no clue that Néstle and Rolex ARE.
4. You get frustrated if you go grocery shopping abroad and there aren’t at least 10 different kinds of chocolate and 15 kinds of cheese available.
5. You have learned three to four languages and think this is completely normal.
6. You have been asked – upon stating your nationality – whether you live in the mountains and whether you can yodel.
7. You can pronounce Chuchichäschtli and you know what it means. (1)
8. You have ever been asked who the President of Switzerland is and then failed miserably trying to explain why you’ve lost track.
Bern, the Federal Capital of Switzerland. Photo Pete Grafton
9. You know what Röschti are and you have crossed the Röschtigrabe at some point. (2)
10. You went to a state-funded ski camp every year with your class mates in high school.
11. To you, skis are like the extensions of your feet, because you’ve skied since you could walk.
12. You are amused when people ask you what language is spoken in your home country and/or you have to explain that “Swiss” is not a language, that there are four national languages and none of them is called “Swiss”!
13. You owned a Swatch growing up… or still do.
14. You’ve even seen Sandmännchen dubbed into Romansch. (3)
15. As a female, you give all your friends three kisses on the cheek as a greeting…
16. You love Migros and you swear that some of their products are better than anything you’ve ever seen elsewhere. (4)
17. You’ve ever been asked by your non-Swiss friends to intervene in a fight and used “Hey, I’m Swiss” as an excuse not to.
18. Your country has six different public television channels in three different languages – and you don’t think this is unusual.
19. You get amused when you see Swiss German people being subtitled on German television. (5)
20. You firmly believe it is more important to do things accurately than do them quickly.
21. You were legally allowed to drink beer and wine at the age of sixteen.
22. You walked to kindergarten without supervision, wearing a large orange triangle around your neck.
23. You think it’s normal that everyone has a bunker underneath their house, or is registered for one of the public bunkers under the school building, for emergency situations. By the way, here’s a fun thing to do: invite over some of your foreign friends (Americans make very good candidates) and take a picture of the look on their face when they SEE the bunker. Priceless!!!!!
24. When being asked to explain how certain things work in your country, you have to use the phrase “it differs for each canton, so…”
25. You are asked to vote on a “Referendum” or “Initiative” at least 6 or 7 times a year.
Geneva Photo Pete GraftonGeneva Photo Pete Grafton
26. You are used to drinking water from any public fountain in the street unless there is a warning sign that says “No drinking water”.
Fountain, Bern. Photo Pete Grafton
27. You grew up believing all cows must wear bells.
Happy Cow Photo Pete Grafton
28. You think driving somewhere for four hours is a hell of a long time.
29. You get slightly irritated or at least confused if your foreign visitors ask to see a chocolate factory.
30. You don’t see where the problem is when every male citizen who has been in the army has an assault rifle (FASS-90) under his bed.
FASS-90, Swiss made.
31. You know what Betty Bossi books and products are and have bought one. (6)
Betty Bossi book
32. You know someone that collects the tin foil lids from coffee cream tubs.
Wood store. Everything is saved and used in Switzerland. Photo Elspeth Wight
33. You have to pay twice the prices for museum entries because you’re not a citizen of the EU, although you live in Europe.
34. You are in a non-European country and can hear people talking Swiss German and just go up and strike up a conversation with a complete stranger.
35. No matter how much of a “bad-ass” you think you are, you will still pick up your candy wrapper off the floor if an old lady asks you to.
36. You think everything is cheap abroad compared to Swiss prices!
Some More Photos
Vevey Photo: Pete GraftonLausanne. Photo Pete GraftonThe path to Murren Photo Pete GraftonChess in the Park, Geneva. Statues of John Calvin and John Knox are in this park. Photo Pete GraftonBasel Photo Pete Grafton1950s picnic sign, Jura. Photo Pete GraftonGeneva. Photo Pete GraftonRed Cross Museum, Geneva. Photo Pete Grafton
The Red Cross and the Geneva Conventions on warfare started in Geneva in the mid nineteenth century. They flowed from the stimulation caused by the publication of Geneva born Jean-Henry Dunant’s A Memory of Solferino, an eye witness account of the aftermath of the battle of Solferino, June, 1858 , when thousands of soldiers of both sides were left dying or wounded unattended in the aftermath. The battle was fought between French and Sardinian armies against the Austrian army near Solferino on the Italian mainland. The arguments, in his self-published book, for the care of the wounded and dying, and for introducing conventions in warfare, were initially championed by a group in Geneva. As the momentum developed the Swiss Federal Government hosted a congress that led to the first Geneva Convention on Warfare being ratified, on 22 August, 1864.
Photo Pete GraftonPhoto Pete Grafton
The Swiss Federal Council
“The Federal Council is the seven member executive council which constitutes the federal government of Switzerland and serves as the Swiss collective head of state. While the entire council is responsible for leading the federal administration of Switzerland, each councillor heads one of the seven federal executive departments” – Wikipedia
The Swiss Federal Council, 2014
The Swiss Federal Council 2014, left to right: Johann Schneider-Ammann, FDP Liberals, Dept. Economic Affairs, Education & Research. Eveline Widmer-Schlumpf, Conservative Democrats, Dept. of Finance. Simonetta Sommaruga, Social Democrats, Vice President for 2014, Dept. of Justice and Police.Didier Burkhalter, FDP Liberals President for 2014 & Dept. of Foreign Affairs, Doris Leuthard, Christian Democrats, Dept. of Transport, Energy & Communications. Ueli Maurer, Swiss People’s Party, Dept. of Defence, Civil Protection & Sports. Alain Berset, Social Democrats, Dept of Home Affairs. Federal Chancellor Corina Casanova.
Political Enemies of Direct Democracy
Historically
LeninStalinMussoliniHitlerMao
Presently, within the United Kingdom, amongst many, many others….
Lord KinnockLord Mandelson
IN? OUT? Shake it all About…
A British opinion poll in November 2012 revealed that 56% of those polled wanted the United Kingdom to leave the European Union, 30% wanted to stay, and 14% who were undecided. In a March, 2001 Swiss referendum, 76.8% of those voting rejected applying for membership of the European Union. However there does remain a minority in favour of full membership, including both the Swiss Social Democrats and Swiss Green Party. Meanwhile, surrounded by the European Union, unelected Commissioners in Brussels periodically bluster, and bully the Swiss Federation.
With the Conservative Party leadership rattled by such polls, and the growing electoral support for the United Kingdom Independence Party, the Conservative Party has promised a referendum on continuing European Union membership should they win the 2015 British General Election. The promise is based on Conservative leader Cameron re-negotiating aspects of Britain’s membership with Brussels, and then going to the electorate with an In – Out referendum on the outcome of the renegotiations. At the time of writing, (March 2014) the Labour Party and Liberal Democrat Party policy is to oppose offering a referendum.
Labour Milliband: No ReferendumLiberal Democrat Clegg: No referendum
The mechanism for creating the referendum was for Conservative backbencher James Whitton to introduce a Private Members Bill, based on the Conservative Party draft EU referendum bill. It went through the House of Commons, and then was debated in the unelected House of Lords. There were two ‘readings’ (debates) in the House of Lords, the second on 10 January, 2014. What follows are some of the press reported quotes of those unelected “Lords” opposed to the proposed referendum.
“Peers have been accused of showing contempt for British voters over the proposed EU referendum, saying the public cannot be trusted to make the right decision.”
Lord Mandelson
“Lord Mandelson, the former EU Commissioner, said any vote would be a ‘lottery’ in which the electorate would be swayed by irrelevant issues…’We should be very wary of putting our membership in the hands of a lottery in which we have no idea what factors, completely unrelated to Europe, will affect the outcome.’
Lord Kinnock
“Lord Kinnock, a former Labour leader and European Commissioner, said the referendum was a ‘lame gesture’ in response to the daily drum of the unyielding Europhobes.”
Lord Oakeshott
“Lord Oakeshott, Liberal Democrat, said there is ‘no need’ for the Bill because voters can have their say in the 2015 General Election. Referenda are a ‘cowards wayout’ for politicians who don’t want to make decisions.’ “
Baron Thomas of Swynnerton
Baron Thomas of Swynnerton (aka Hugh Thomas, historian and academic) said that referendums were alien to British philosophy. ‘Parliament makes decisions, not people’ he said, quoting the former Labour Prime Minister James Callaghan.
Gripen fighter aircraft. Photo copyright: Anders Zeilon
Four days later the Swiss online edition of The Local (14 January, 2014) ran a story that would have flabbergasted most of Britain’s professional ‘democratic’ politicians – whose unstated motto is “I trust myself, but not those who elected me” The following story would have caused them palpitations. Think of the implications in a British context.
“May referendum looms on Gripen plane deal”
The Swiss public could vote as early as May on a deal to buy 22 fighter planes from Sweden after opponents on Tuesday submitted over 100,000 signatures seeking a referendum
The goal of the campaigners is to block the purchase of the Gripen fighters, which would cost the mountain country 3.13 billion francs ($3.47 billion). Under Switzerland’s system of direct democracy, citizens can have the last word on a huge array of issues if campaigners muster enough signatures from voters in order to force a plebiscite. Polls have shown that a majority of voters oppose the Gripen deal. Approved by the government in 2011 and backed by parliament last year, it cannot be blocked as such. But opponents have been able to contest the law that allows the purchase to be funded by drawing an annual 300 million francs from the army’s budget over ten years. The coalition campaigning against the deal is steered by the left-leaning Socialists and Greens, as well as anti-militarists, but also includes economic liberals opposed to the price tag. The opponents also argue that the model of Gripen chosen by the authorities only exists on paper, as its maker, Sweden’s Saab, is still developing it. Last month, Saab’s Gripen beat the Rafale, made by France’s Dassault, and the F/A 18 Super Hornet built by US company McDonnell Douglas in the race to sell 36 planes to Brazil. The estimated value of the Brazil deal is $5 billion.
The air force of neutral Switzerland currently has 32 Super Hornets in service, purchased in 1996.
There are currently 166 Gripen fighters in service globally, with 100 in Sweden, 26 in South Africa, 14 each in the Czech Republic and Hungary, and 12 in Thailand, according to Saab.”
And Then………
Bern cancels Swedish fighter-jet air show
The Swiss government’s eagerness to avoid graft accusations could explain why Switzerland cancelled Swedish fighter jets taking part in an air show, reports from Stockholm said on Tuesday.
Sources told Sveriges Radio (SR) that the Swedish participation had been cancelled because the Swiss government did not want to be accused of trying to sway public opinion in favour of the Jas Gripen.
The government is facing a citizens-initiative referendum that will have final say over whether the country should buy the Swedish jets.
Saab headquarters in Sweden told SR that the company was not engaging in any marketing activities in Switzerland whatsoever ahead of the plebiscite, which is scheduled for May.
And the Outcome……..
Voters shoot down Swedish fighter jet deal Published: 18 May 2014 18:41 GMT+02:00
The Swiss allowed a multi-billion-dollar deal to buy fighter jets from Sweden to crash and burn Sunday, when a majority turned out to nix funding for the purchase.
Swiss reject world’s highest minimum wage (18 May 14) New Swede named to Bern amid Gripen flap (30 Apr 14) Defence minister under fire for ‘sexist’ speeches (28 Apr 14) Critics charge Gripen jet costs could triple (31 Mar 14) In all, 53.4 percent of voters balked at releasing the 3.1 billion francs ($3.5 billion) needed to purchase the 22 planes from Sweden’s Saab, according to official referendum results.
Polls ahead of the referendum predicted that voters would turn down the government plan, which called for the new fighter jets to replace the Swiss Air Force’s ageing fleet of 54 F-5 Tiger aircraft to defend Switzerland’s air space.
Citizens from French-speaking Switzerland were the biggest opponents of the deal.
Voters in Neuchâtel, for example, voted 69 percent against, while those from Geneva, 67 percent.
Almost 55 percent voted against the Swedish jets in the Italian-speaking canton of Ticino.
Support for the planes was strongest in German-speaking cantons, but a majority opposed their purchase in Zurich (51.4 percent) and Basel City (67.7 percent).
Another example – reported in the Swiss 26 February 2014 edition of The Local – of the referendums that occur in the Swiss Federation was the following:
“Swiss to vote on world’s highest minimum wage”
A proposed minimum wage of 22 francs an hour ($24.80) would have a damaging effect on Switzerland’s job market, says Swiss economics minister Johann Schneider-Ammann, as voters prepare to decide
Schneider-Ammann launched a campaign on Tuesday objecting to the proposal, which will be put to Swiss voters in a referendum on May 18th. Switzerland does not currently have a national minimum wage.
If the plan is approved, Switzerland’s lowest hourly salary will exceed that of current record holder Australia by more than ten US dollars. Australian workers are entitled to A$16.37 per hour ($14.67).
The UK’s minimum hourly wage is £6.31 ($10.55), while Germany recently agreed a €8.50 ($11.69) minimum from 2017. The current US rate is $7.25.
Speaking at a media conference reported by Reuters, Schneider-Ammann said: “The government is convinced it would be wrong for the state to impose a nationwide wage.”
“A minimum wage of 4,000 francs could lead to job cuts and even threaten the existence of smaller companies, notably in retail, catering, agriculture and housekeeping.”
“If jobs are being cut, the weakest suffer most,” he said.
In an interview with newspaper Tribune de Genève, Philippe Leuba, economics minister for canton Vaud, agreed.
Bringing in a minimum wage would compound the problems created by the recent anti-immigration yes vote, he said.
“Don’t forget that one franc in two is earned through exports. Our standard of living depends on our ability to export and if we fail to maintain relations with the EU there will be considerable difficulties for the economy, for salaries, for jobs and for apprenticeships. So let’s not multiply our mistakes by saying yes to a minimum wage.”
In November, Neuchâtel became the first Swiss canton to propose a minimum wage of 20 francs ($21.75), to come into effect in 2015, after residents voted to accept the principle.”
Decentralisation, Direct Democracy and Anarchism
As a historian, Hugh Thomas (aka Baron Thomas of Swynnerton) wrote one of the earliest standard works on the Spanish Civil War, a well regarded book that was seen as a well-balanced presentation. This is quite a feat as the Spanish Civil War still arouses strong viewpoints, as what happened, and what the outcomes were, are still pertinent to how societies organise themselves, politically, economically, socially and militarily. No historian dealing with the Spanish Civil War can avoid dealing with one major element of that War: the decentralist, communal anarchist inspired revolutionary events on the mass scale that occurred. In the areas where they had mass support: the appropriation and communal organising of the land, and factories (particularly in Barcelona), the sexual politics – encompassing the freeing arrangements of looser marriages and abortion rights, a progressive education approach and the organisation of their FAI/CNT militias were unique in the history of Western Europe. Nothing like it had happened on this scale before, nor has happened since. It is a credit that Hugh Thomas stuck to impartiality when writing his The Spanish Civil War, given that he may have been hostile to the egalitarian anarchist ideal, and frustrated at its lack of military effectiveness on the campaign front.
The other Western European country that had significant numbers of believers in the de-centralist anarchist ideas of how societies should be organised was Switzerland between the mid nineteenth century, through to the early twentieth century. There were various groups – in Geneva, for instance – but the Swiss watchmakers in the Jura region were the significant body. They fascinated the Russian anarchist theoretician Prince Kropotkin, who like his fellow anarchist Bakunin, was also a political refugee in Switzerland from Tsarist Russia. He visited them in 1871 to find out more about them.
Switzerland was a noted haven, besides Britain, during the mid to late nineteenth century for political refugees. The British periodical The Spectator noted this, in a 8th August, 1885 edition:
“SINCE the time when the English regicides found a safe asylum at Vevey, Switzerland has always extended a generous hospitality to the political waifs and strays of neigh- bouring nations. Whether the refugee be a princely Pretender with views inimical to the welfare of France, a German Minister fleeing from the wrath of Bismarck, a Communard, red- handed from a murderous conflict in the streets of Paris, or a Russian Revolutionist with a price on his head, he may count an a quiet life and freedom from molestation on the sole condition of respecting the laws of the land and refraining from acts which might embroil the Confederation with foreign Powers.”
Not So, Orson
The Swiss Confederation has a set of prejudices against it and about it, just as all nations have, but it is remarkable that the prejudices about them and false observations are so wide of the mark – even by the normal Richter scale of misinformed prejudice.
Orson Welles as Harry Lime in “The Third Man”
In trying to weasel his way out of any condemnation of his immoral trade in fatally diluted penicillin Harry Lime says to his former friend Holly Martins (played by Joseph Cotton)
“In Italy for thirty years under the Borgias they had warfare, terror, murder, and bloodshed, but they produced Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, and the Renaissance. In Switzerland they had brotherly love – they had 500 years of democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo clock. “
Er, not so Orson. (Orson Wells claims he added these lines himself, to the Graham Greene Third Man screenplay). A stable peace within the Swiss Federation did not arrive until the mid nineteenth century. In addition, at the time of the Borgias in Italy, Switzerland was reckoned to be the most powerful and feared military force in Europe, according to some historians.
Italy, at the time of the Borgias (approximately 1455 – 1503) gave the world Machiavelli, who lived in a similar time period as Calvin. And Machiavelli’s contribution to the development of a democratic society? Many of his Machiavellian followers, even if they are unaware of, or have never read his The Prince, crowd out the parliaments of ‘democratic’ countries. Some of the British variety have recently been de-selected, expelled or imprisoned for massively falsifying their expenses claims.
It could be argued that the French Protestant John Calvin, who was a religious refugee to Switzerland, and eventually built up a large following and influence from Geneva (where he died in 1564 and whose lying in state was crowded out) had a historically massive effect in the development of what became humanistic rationalism (even if he wouldn’t have approved of it). And like the German protestant Luther, the sovereignty of individual human conscience, alongside non-hierarchical religious assemblies were central to his beliefs. These elements, in a secular world, became part of the progress to a more humane and democratic ethos to aspire to and live by.
And cuckoo clocks? Really Orson, Switzerland would not have one of the highest per capita incomes in the world if it depended on the export of cuckoo clocks (which are, incidentally, mostly made in German Bavaria). Chemicals, pharmaceuticals, micro-engineering and the conservation and imaginative use of their resources are just some reasons why this is so.
Why Switzerland? by Jonathan Steinberg. Published by Cambridge University Press
For those interested in developing genuine political democracy the question is simple: Why not Switzerland? Why not the Swiss model?
And why Social Democratic Parties, and the Green Parties are – beneath the ‘progressive’ sheen – inherently dictatorial and anti-democratic (like the forces they criticise) is another story, and another Post.
p.s. The Latest from Switzerland
“Swiss seem happiest with their lives: OECD”
Published: 18 Mar 2014 23:28 GMT+01:00
Updated: 18 Mar 2014 23:28 GMT+01:00
Swiss residents live longer than those in any other country in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and have the highest level of life satisfaction among the group’s 34 members, a new report says.
Residents in Switzerland have an average life expectancy of 82.8, compared with the OECD average of 80.1, says the Society at a Glance 2014 report of OECD social indicators.
According to its data, the mountain country is also the place where people “seem most satisfied with their lives”, compared to other OECD nations.
“When asked to rate their general satisfaction with life on a scale from 0 to 10, the Swiss recorded a 7.8, much higher than the OECD average of 6.6,” the report said.
Overall, the report gives Switzerland high marks for avoiding the social problems faced by many developed countries in the wake of the 2007-08 financial and economic crisis.
“In no other country is a smaller share of the population (around four percent) reporting that they cannot afford to buy enough food,” it says.
The report highlights the country’s low fertility rate of 1.52 children per woman as one of its challenges.
This is below the OECD average of 1.7 and well beneath the “demographic replacement rate” of 2.1 needed to avoid population shrinkage.
Switzerland has been offsetting its low native birth rate by admitting more immigrants.
The report notes that more than a quarter of Swiss residents are foreign born, more than double the OECD average.
Among other findings of the report:
— Public social spending at 18.9 percent of GDP in Switzerland is lower than the OECD average of 21.9 percent
— Health expenditures, averaging $5,600 per capita, are exceeded only by the US and Norway
— Swiss annual disposable income ranks among the highest in the OECD but the ratio between the average income of the richest and the poorest residents is seven, compared to an OECD average of 9.5 percent.
1. Chuchichäschtli: classic Swiss German, meaning “kitchen cupboard”.
2. Röschti: a fried potato dish, a Swiss German favourite. Röschtigrabe: a humorous term to describe the ‘divide’ between German speaking Switzerland and French speaking Switzerland.
3. Sandmännchen: “Sandman”, a popular children’s TV programme, particularly, but not exclusively, throughout German speaking Europe. Although there was a West German produced series, it is the former East German series that is the most popular, and continues to be watched, including by Le Patron’s enklekinder – grandchildren – when younger.
4. Food supermarket.
5. Schwyzerdütsch – Swiss German has its own grammar and many different words, but it is particularly the soft pronunciation and the almost Scandavnavian ‘sing-song’ intonation that foxes most people when heard for the first time, when trying to identify the country of the speaker.
6. Switzerland’s favourite series of cook books.
Sources and Links (highlighted)
Why Switzerland, Jonathan Steinberg, Cambridge University Press.
Photos Copyrighted where stated. Photos by Pete Grafton and Elspeth Wight: free dissemination with photographer credit for non-commercial use. For commercial use, contact Le Patron.